Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   "The 33"-Road Bike Racing (https://www.bikeforums.net/33-road-bike-racing/)
-   -   CTL, FTP and winter training... does it really make a difference? Scenario inside... (https://www.bikeforums.net/33-road-bike-racing/967871-ctl-ftp-winter-training-does-really-make-difference-scenario-inside.html)

Ygduf 08-27-14 10:37 AM


Originally Posted by echappist (Post 17075269)
Wouldn't have chimed in other settings, but we are dealing with an OP who has obviously over-reached and perhaps over-trained. Don't see "everyone else rests too much" being conducive to someone who apparently has had the same cycle of intense build up followed by huge drop in training for a few years.

you know how when I post this and you get a note saying you were quoted and then you read this text and it is clearly intended for you and all that?

yeah.

Anyway, sorry everyone. I apologize for quoting dz and responding to him that I feel like instead of needing more rest I think lots of people could do more with less rest.

Anyway, I still feel that way so I guess I'm not that sorry. But unless you're [MENTION=74778]mattm[/MENTION] you shouldn't take it personally.

furiousferret 08-27-14 10:43 AM

Why are you apologizing for giving an opinion?

echappist 08-27-14 10:54 AM


Originally Posted by Ygduf (Post 17075318)
you know how when I post this and you get a note saying you were quoted and then you read this text and it is clearly intended for you and all that?

yeah.

your are posting in a public forum. if it's not a private message, it's for public consumption, ipso facto

Anyway, sorry everyone. I apologize for quoting dz and responding to him that I feel like instead of needing more rest I think lots of people could do more with less rest.

Anyway, I still feel that way so I guess I'm not that sorry. But unless you're @mattm you shouldn't take it personally.
then why bother with the charade? no one expects you to change your strongly held opinions, but that doesn't mean your opinions aren't up for discussion. No one cajoled you into airing your opinions.

mattm 08-27-14 11:22 AM

God dammit reading this drivel just made me spill my cappuccino all over my desk!!!

globecanvas 08-27-14 11:26 AM

This thread has taught me something surprising and valuable.

We can say god dammit!

Ygduf 08-27-14 12:06 PM


Originally Posted by echappist (Post 17075373)
your are posting in a public forum. if it's not a private message, it's for public consumption, ipso facto

then why bother with the charade? no one expects you to change your strongly held opinions, but that doesn't mean your opinions aren't up for discussion. No one cajoled you into airing your opinions.

discussing my opinions is fine.

Saying that I "think I'm perfect" is not discussion.

IPSO FACTO!

Ygduf 08-27-14 12:06 PM


Originally Posted by globecanvas (Post 17075489)
This thread has taught me something surprising and valuable.

We can say god dammit!

reported.

revchuck 08-27-14 01:47 PM


Originally Posted by revchuck (Post 17073325)
It was dz, Matt posted the same time I did. My 18 hour weeks were just over 100 ATL IIRC.

I checked that period last night, and it turns out that my ATL was between 120 and 140 for most of that time.

mike868y 08-27-14 02:21 PM

this thread got so out of hand, so fast. hilarious.

i'm with fudgy and dz. i lead a pretty boring life (by choice) so if I'm not riding, working, eating, or sleeping...i don't know what the hell else to do.

MDcatV 08-27-14 02:41 PM


Originally Posted by mike868y (Post 17076141)
this thread got so out of hand, so fast. hilarious.

i'm with fudgy and dz. i lead a pretty boring life (by choice) so if I'm not riding, working, eating, or sleeping...i don't know what the hell else to do.

youth, so wasted on the young.

mattm 08-27-14 02:54 PM


Originally Posted by MDcatV (Post 17076221)
youth, so wasted on the young.

On the same note, I've noticed that convertibles are wasted on the old... they don't even have hair to blow around in the wind anymore!!

mike868y 08-27-14 02:56 PM


Originally Posted by MDcatV (Post 17076221)
youth, so wasted on the young.

trust me, i partied plenty in college. just found it didn't leave me a very happy or content person. i'm much happier with my life now and honestly wouldn't have it any other way.

MDcatV 08-27-14 03:00 PM


Originally Posted by mattm (Post 17076253)
On the same note, I've noticed that convertibles are wasted on the old... they don't even have hair to blow around in the wind anymore!!

i'll have you know i possess a full head of hair, but no convertible.

shovelhd 08-27-14 03:39 PM

I'm with mattm and valygrl. The only data that is accurate is the raw power. All metrics are suspect due to the estimated FTP. I would draw no conclusions from them. However your training cycles are very valid data. To rest for weeks doing nothing then blast, rest, blast, rest, burn is no way to train for consistency my friend. You need a little structure. Even Fudgy the Wunderkind trains with some kind of structure. You don't need a coach, you need a plan. A coach can help with that, or you can parlay the free advice here and devise your own.

My my suggestion would be to take at least one week completely off with no strenuous activity, long periods of standing, etc. Then start a base program at a low weekly TSS. If you go on a group ride or solo ride on the weekend keep the hard stuff for that but minimize it during the week. Focus on tempo, a little threshold, and recovery rides. As it gets towards the holidays the start ramping up the intensity and adding in rest weeks.

caloso 08-27-14 04:14 PM


Originally Posted by mattm (Post 17076253)
On the same note, I've noticed that convertibles are wasted on the old... they don't even have hair to blow around in the wind anymore!!

This is because there is no convertible minivan on the market, despite Top Gear's efforts.

revchuck 08-27-14 06:39 PM


Originally Posted by MDcatV (Post 17076221)
youth, so wasted on the young.

Hear, hear!


Originally Posted by mattm (Post 17076253)
On the same note, I've noticed that convertibles are wasted on the old... they don't even have hair to blow around in the wind anymore!!


Originally Posted by MDcatV (Post 17076275)
i'll have you know i possess a full head of hair, but no convertible.

Ditto. If I want wind in my hair, I'll roll down the window of my F150. And yes, I did say "roll down." ;)

Creatre 08-28-14 05:08 AM


Originally Posted by mattm (Post 17076253)
On the same note, I've noticed that convertibles are wasted on the old... they don't even have hair to blow around in the wind anymore!!

I have a convertible, but I keep my hair buzzed! I'm such a waster!

rbart4506 08-29-14 06:35 AM

Getting this back on topic again... I've been running a CTL of 105+ for the last 6-8wks, guess that might explain the constant tired feeling. Still riding well, but I know it's a matter of time before some real rest is required...

MDcatV 08-29-14 07:04 AM

[MENTION=27519]rbart4506[/MENTION], IME, not just with me but as someone who has provided training advice to lots of people and has reviewed season power files, 100+ CTL is a pretty darned high CTL. are you adjusting your FTP periodically and accordingly based on testing data or have you kept it constant for the season?

rbart4506 08-29-14 06:51 PM

I've adjusted as the season has gone on, but my Catskills TT showed that my FTP was probably a bit higher then I had it listed. I didn't adjust at that point because the TT had a significant uphill portion and I wasn't sure how much that skewed the results. I also did a number of long rides with extensive climbing in July and August that really dropped the TSB and I think caused a spike in ATL and CTL. Definitely after GMSR I need a bit of break especially I plan on doing 6gap...

gsteinb 08-30-14 05:21 AM

If one surveyed all riders the most common scenario one would find is guys-- both--not resting enough and not going hard enough. That middle ground is a much more pleasant place to ride and lure folks into its web of suck.

rbart4506 08-30-14 02:16 PM


Originally Posted by gsteinb (Post 17083798)
If one surveyed all riders the most common scenario one would find is guys-- both--not resting enough and not going hard enough. That middle ground is a much more pleasant place to ride and lure folks into its web of suck.

Yup... I know I sit there all too often! Have to work on that next season. I've made progress this year for sure, but there's more in here I know it...

mike868y 08-30-14 02:44 PM


Originally Posted by gsteinb (Post 17083798)
If one surveyed all riders the most common scenario one would find is guys-- both--not resting enough and not going hard enough. That middle ground is a much more pleasant place to ride and lure folks into its web of suck.

I'm quite happy riding for fun and the resulting mediocrity, thank you very much.

Creakyknees 08-31-14 10:57 AM

sorry I'm late to this thread... have we come to any conclusions yet?

mattm 08-31-14 11:46 AM

lol


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 05:34 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.