I have a Brooks (B17), and havent' come to terms with it yet. I have WTB RocketV SE on all of my road bikes, and since they are usually around $29 street, I have a few extra on the shelf. Try one, I don't know if it will work with your anatomy, but it may be worth a try.
NEVER skimp on the 'contact points' (hands, arse, feet). If any of them are not comfortable, the ride will suck, guaranteed.
Jim