I recently got these shoes. I think they are good. Not great, but good
I rode them earlier this week on 20F with windchill of 0F (strong side/headwinds). After about 45 minutes outside, my feet were somewhat cold. I wore them with some medium weight cotton socks (Hanes @Target). I may look for some different socks.
I have no experience with their waterproofness yet.
My main gripe is their looks. The gray ones look God-awful. You would think they could spend a few bucks and make it look nicer?
On the other hand, better quality shoes from brand name manufacturers are a lot pricier, I looked around and most seem to start at $100. So for your budget I think it s not a bad choice
Duppie