I have been using a pair of the winter work gloves by Patagonia for two winter riding seasons now + all normal winter outdoor wearing and have not had a problem with them wearing out prematurely yet. I would think that any winter work glove made be Marmot, Cloudveil, OR, or Patagonia would easily last you as long as any winter cycling glove would.
Skin allergies suck. I have several myself. Good luck finding a glove that works for you.