That "cyclist" got the same fitting that I did a few days ago when I picked out my 58cm Specialized Globe. The LBS guy asked how tall I am. "Six foot two, six foot three." He says, "a 58 should be good...that's what I ride". I told him I liked the look of the Globe. He adjusted the seat, then let me ride it around the block. I bought it 10 minutes later. I'm happy with it.