Wow--remarkably similar experience Smarter. I'm 46 and awaiting MRI results. Mine is likely a minor meniscus tear. I have done some extensive cycling in the past but sort of lost the passion last year and went back to running and basketball (not a brilliant move). I have a Trek 1000 road bike and am looking for a hybrid or a MTB for NYC streets. I will do only horse trail type riding.
Am I better off with a used higher end bike or a new one. Looking to spend around $500. Thanks.