Since it appears that the BD touring bike is a rebadged Fuji touring bike, chances are it's the same wheels as well. I don't know who does the QC on them - could be Fuji, could be BD. In either event, you most likely got one bad part, so a warranty repair should be sufficient.
Unfortunately, spotty warranty service is a commonly discussed problem with BD. I believe the owner of BD is a member of the forums, so if the typical routes don't work, you could either PM him or start a thread in the Road Cycling forum.