The Fuel EX 8 really doesn't belong on the list given how little suspension travel it has. The Trek Remedy is a better match for the other bikes. That said, I'd pick the Pitch Pro. Don't like Cannondale, not a fan of the crazy G2 geometry on the Roscoe. The Pitch Pro seems like a better value than the Remedy 7. I've also had a chance to test-ride it on local trails and it seems to work pretty well...