Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Advocacy & Safety (https://www.bikeforums.net/advocacy-safety/)
-   -   Punish passed by local police car today (https://www.bikeforums.net/advocacy-safety/923545-punish-passed-local-police-car-today.html)

Buzzatronic 11-25-13 11:14 AM

Thanks for the feedback folks. I think I'm going to just let it drop at this point. I really don't see an upside even with an off the record chat with the driver or a supervisor. If he did it on purpose, my calling him out won't change his feelings on bikes in the road and he'll continue this behavior. If he did it unintentionally due to being distracted it could result in a mark on his record which I will be blamed for and possible retaliated against. It's just not worth it.

I-Like-To-Bike 11-25-13 11:15 AM


Originally Posted by 10 Wheels (Post 16276642)
Blow it off and ride much more. Silly idea to contact the police.

Also a silly idea to jump to a negative conclusion about a so-called "punish pass" or get worked up (sweating bullets!) over a 10 mph speed differential with 18" of clearance. Strictly routine traffic cycling for any cyclist no longer using training wheels.

spivonious 11-25-13 11:19 AM


Originally Posted by I-Like-To-Bike (Post 16276668)
Also a silly idea to jump to a negative conclusion about a so-called "punish pass" or get worked up (sweating bullets!) over a 10 mph speed differential with 18" of clearance. Strictly routine traffic cycling for any cyclist no longer using training wheels.

Way to insult me, ILTB. I've been riding in traffic for a year and a half and been passed with less than 2' of clearance about 3 times. It is not routine, and if you're routinely passed that close, you need to get out of the gutter.

noisebeam 11-25-13 11:20 AM


Originally Posted by I-Like-To-Bike (Post 16276668)
Also a silly idea to jump to a negative conclusion about a so-called "punish pass" or get worked up (sweating bullets!) over a 10 mph speed differential with 18" of clearance. Strictly routine traffic cycling for any cyclist no longer using training wheels.

yes. no one should ever be surprised by someone passing and if paying attention can also give oneself more room if it makes one feel better.

I-Like-To-Bike 11-25-13 11:24 AM


Originally Posted by spivonious (Post 16276680)
Way to insult me, ILTB. I've been riding in traffic for a year and a half and been passed with less than 2' of clearance about 3 times. It is not routine, and if you're routinely passed that close, you need to get out of the gutter.

Take a ride down to Philadelphia sometime. You will be sweating an armory in the first hour.

shipwreck 11-25-13 02:31 PM

[QUOTE=spivonious;16276625]Seriously?? 18 inches and I would be sweating bullets. That is close enough to reach out and touch the car. Way too close to be considered safe. What happens if my chain slips and I veer left? What happens if a gust of wind comes and blows me left? What happens if I get a blowout and fall left? 18 inches gives no room for error.

QUOTE]

AdrianFly 11-26-13 08:31 AM


Originally Posted by 10 Wheels (Post 16276642)
Blow it off and ride much more.

THIS!!:thumb:

dynodonn 11-26-13 09:21 AM

In reading all these stalwart responses in regards to 18 inch passing clearances and near 20mph speed differentials, on can see why the US has such a low bicycle commuting share, and why a number of states have adopted a 3 foot 'minimum" passing law.

dynodonn 11-26-13 09:40 AM


Originally Posted by noisebeam (Post 16276685)
yes. no one should ever be surprised by someone passing and if paying attention can also give oneself more room if it makes one feel better.



I've been caught off guard before, I don't stare into my mirror constantly, and I'm not able to hear all rear approaching motorists due to wind and traffic noise. My most memorable close pass and being caught off guard, was a motorist drifting in my direction at a 40 mph speed differential, missing me by inches. I had just looked into my bike mirror a few seconds earlier with the motorist positioned properly in the adjacent traffic lane, then diverted my attention to an upcoming intersection, and just as I returned to check my mirror, the motorist was along side me, inches away.

I-Like-To-Bike 11-26-13 12:13 PM


Originally Posted by dynodonn (Post 16279370)
In reading all these stalwart responses in regards to 18 inch passing clearances and near 20mph speed differentials,

Where in this thread did you read about responses in regards to near 20mph speed differentials?

noisebeam 11-26-13 12:26 PM


Originally Posted by dynodonn (Post 16279443)
I've been caught off guard before, I don't stare into my mirror constantly, and I'm not able to hear all rear approaching motorists due to wind and traffic noise. My most memorable close pass and being caught off guard, was a motorist drifting in my direction at a 40 mph speed differential, missing me by inches. I had just looked into my bike mirror a few seconds earlier with the motorist positioned properly in the adjacent traffic lane, then diverted my attention to an upcoming intersection, and just as I returned to check my mirror, the motorist was along side me, inches away.

You may have been unaware it was passing closely, but you were not surprised that a specific vehicle was going to pass shortly.

WebFootFreak 11-26-13 12:33 PM

Buzzatronic

I think in your situation I would do the same thing. A 10mph differential is really not much, but the distance was definitely questionable. Since you have it recorded, make sure you save a copy. That way if it happens again, you have proof that it's not just a random occurrence (especially if it's the same car).

I'm lucky to have not experienced a near miss, but since most of the roads I'm on either have ample shoulder or are not heavily traveled, that chance is decreased further.

NoviceJohn 11-26-13 12:36 PM


Originally Posted by Buzzatronic (Post 16274951)
I got passed today really close by a local police cruiser, felt like a typical punish pass. My question is what's the upside (if any) of reporting this? I have it on video but based on my previous dealings with the PD regarding footage like this, they don't seem to care much unless I'm actually hit by a car. I have to wonder if they'll care even less when it's one of their own on film putting me in danger.

I guess my biggest concern is being harassed if I report this. I ride these streets 3-5 days a week and I certainly don't want to get put on any "list". :(

Anyone have any advice or stories to share for when the police are the drivers putting you in danger on the road?

if this happens often in your area or to you personally, I say file a report. If nothing happens, then I say get the recording (if you have a camera strapped on), go to the media, and see where that goes. When your local PD refuse to act, the media will make them because the PD chief, just like any other political position, doesn't want bad press of any kind. When the chief gets bad press, the mayor gets bad press because it makes him / her look like they're not doing their job.

I-Like-To-Bike 11-26-13 01:24 PM


Originally Posted by NoviceJohn (Post 16280039)
if this happens often in your area or to you personally, I say file a report. If nothing happens, then I say get the recording (if you have a camera strapped on), go to the media, and see where that goes. When your local PD refuse to act, the media will make them because the PD chief, just like any other political position, doesn't want bad press of any kind. When the chief gets bad press, the mayor gets bad press because it makes him / her look like they're not doing their job.

I suspect the only entity to get "bad press" from media attention to this incident or similar routine traffic encounters would be cyclists, and the alleged cyclist victims would be seen by most people to include political and law enforcement officials as over sensitive crybabies. The losers in this scenario would be all cyclists.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:12 AM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.