Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Bicycle Mechanics (https://www.bikeforums.net/bicycle-mechanics/)
-   -   To grease or not to grease? (https://www.bikeforums.net/bicycle-mechanics/101302-grease-not-grease.html)

72andsunny 04-21-05 03:39 PM

To grease or not to grease?
 
Should I grease the splines on my Shimano Octalink Splined Cranks?

1) Zinn says it makes no difference.
2) ParkTools website says to grease.
3) Bikeforums search results seems evenly divided.

I'm leaning towards greasing, anybody know the pros and cons?

Thanks!

Captain Mike

2004 Santana Noventa Stowaway

sydney 04-21-05 04:10 PM


Originally Posted by 72andsunny
Should I grease the splines on my Shimano Octalink Splined Cranks?

1) Zinn says it makes no difference.
2) ParkTools website says to grease.
3) Bikeforums search results seems evenly divided.

I'm leaning towards greasing, anybody know the pros and cons?

Thanks!

Captain Mike

2004 Santana Noventa Stowaway

Shimano instructions say grease the spindle.You can't go wrong with grease on them, so what's the issue? If they have self extractors,remove them and the bolts so the splines can be lined up before torquing them.

phantomcow2 04-21-05 04:18 PM

grease them

DocF 04-21-05 06:57 PM

Grease gets my vote, too.

Doc

Dirtbike 04-21-05 08:20 PM

If in doubt, grease it. (Unless you are working on brake parts :p)

Raiyn 04-21-05 11:02 PM

Grease them

phantomcow2 04-22-05 04:15 AM

theres just no reason not to, it can only help you

DieselDan 04-22-05 06:20 AM

You can grease Shimano Octalink and ISIS splined BB splindles, but NEVER grease any square taper BB spindles. Greasing those can lead to over tourquing.

sydney 04-22-05 06:57 AM


Originally Posted by DieselDan
You can grease Shimano Octalink and ISIS splined BB splindles, but NEVER grease any square taper BB spindles. Greasing those can lead to over tourquing.

Nonsense!!.

jinx_removing 04-22-05 07:31 AM


Originally Posted by DieselDan
You can grease Shimano Octalink and ISIS splined BB splindles, but NEVER grease any square taper BB spindles. Greasing those can lead to over tourquing.

Whaaa? Man am I in trouble :D

sydney 04-22-05 07:37 AM


Originally Posted by jinx_removing
Whaaa? Man am I in trouble :D

Funny that shimano ships current square taper BB with the spindle pre greased. Must be a conspiracy to sell more cranks dut to overtorquing.... ;) :p

jinx_removing 04-22-05 07:43 AM


Originally Posted by sydney
Funny that shimano ships current square taper BB with the spindle pre greased. Must be a conspiracy to sell more cranks dut to overtorquing.... ;) :p

I was acutally going to say the same thing as I had a similar discussion in the FG/SS forum.

edit: About the pregreased spindle not the conspiracy(but I wouldn't put it past Shimano)

Weasel 04-22-05 08:33 AM

Grease it. But not spoon fulls. :)

Raiyn 04-22-05 03:33 PM


Originally Posted by DieselDan
. Greasing those can lead to over tourquing.

Not using a torque wrench leads to over tourqing

sydney 04-22-05 03:52 PM


Originally Posted by Raiyn
Not using a torque wrench leads to over tourqing

Well said.

caloso 04-22-05 05:25 PM

Grease is the word!


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:38 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.