Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Bicycle Mechanics (https://www.bikeforums.net/bicycle-mechanics/)
-   -   Vittoria hyper tires weigh a lot more than advertised? (https://www.bikeforums.net/bicycle-mechanics/1028718-vittoria-hyper-tires-weigh-lot-more-than-advertised.html)

Wressen 09-07-15 06:45 AM

Vittoria hyper tires weigh a lot more than advertised?
 
2 Attachment(s)
So I have had Vittoria randonneur hyper before and bought some new ones under the voyager hyper label. Difference is that these are now clinchers instead of folding. But i looked on Vittorias homepage, and it states 395 gram, seems quite ok for a 35mm tire.

This turned out to be a huge exaggeration, i know the stated weight might differ some times, but this it ridiculous.

Stated 395 grams for clincher: Voyager Hyper - Vittoria.com

Reality(weighed on a kitchen scale as well with same result):
http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=475768

Reference weight on the same scale, san marco regal:
http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=475770


This is almost 50% more than stated!!!??

Bill Kapaun 09-07-15 07:03 AM

How much does 2 of them weigh?
Your scale is best used when weighing items that are about 1/2 of the max range.
At lower weights, you may be getting some "stiction".

Wressen 09-07-15 07:18 AM

2 Attachment(s)
http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=475773http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=475774


First with 2 tires, second with 3 tires. So no the scale is perfect. As I wrote in the first post, i tried this on a kitchen scale with same result.

Crankycrank 09-07-15 07:29 AM

You mentioned these are non-folding so I'm assuming these are steel bead rather than the lighter Kevlar. Does this size come in both Kevlar and steel? If so they may be listing the Kevlar weight but even so this wouldn't account for the extra heft. An email to Vittoria might get some answers.

Wressen 09-07-15 07:33 AM

No folding version: Voyager Hyper - Vittoria.com

I will contact vittoria to see what they say.

jyl 09-07-15 08:50 AM

Considering they are advertised as "ultra light", I think Vittoria owes you an explanation.

Maybe return them and get a different tire.

Andrew R Stewart 09-07-15 10:46 AM

Tire and rim weights are well known to vary by at least 10% and not be considered "wrong". Molds and dies wear and material density varies. But 570 VS 395 is a lot of difference. I suspect that the problem lies with the spec list being wrong. This also happens all the time. The people responsible for the document writing don't get/ask for the right data from the manufacturer side (which is also often a bit different then what the design side intended too. ) Andy.

dsaul 09-08-15 04:19 AM

The Hyper is a "folding" tire. They also make a wire bead that they call the "rigid" version of the Voyager without the Hyper designation that weighs 575g. Where did you get the tires? Perhaps they are counterfeit. In looking around at various retailers, I only find them in Black.

Wressen 09-08-15 04:21 AM

They are bought at planetX bikes, so I doubt they are counterfeit.

Crankycrank 09-08-15 07:25 AM


Originally Posted by Wressen (Post 18146470)
They are bought at planetX bikes, so I doubt they are counterfeit.

Well, this is getting interesting. As "dsaul" noted the wire bead, non-hyper version is the same weight and color as your tires so possibly a labeling error. I know Planet X is very reputable but they do tend to buy some of their products in batches and sell at very low prices until their stock is gone. Possibly Vittoria realized they made the labeling mistake and gave PX a special deal. Still no excuse for selling mis-represented tires so you may also want to let PX know about it.

fietsbob 09-08-15 08:38 AM

You got steel bead and wonder why they weigh more than the folding Kevlar bead tires?


convert to sew-ups if weight really matters , then keep spare wheels in the pits for when you puncture .

Wressen 09-08-15 09:03 AM


Originally Posted by Crankycrank (Post 18146774)
Well, this is getting interesting. As "dsaul" noted the wire bead, non-hyper version is the same weight and color as your tires so possibly a labeling error. I know Planet X is very reputable but they do tend to buy some of their products in batches and sell at very low prices until their stock is gone. Possibly Vittoria realized they made the labeling mistake and gave PX a special deal. Still no excuse for selling mis-represented tires so you may also want to let PX know about it.

Emailed planetX today. To ship the tires back from Sweden to England would probably cost as much as the tires costs. :(

SquidPuppet 09-08-15 11:42 AM

You shouldn't have to pay the shipping if it is their error.

Marc40a 12-02-15 01:32 PM


Originally Posted by dsaul (Post 18146468)
The Hyper is a "folding" tire. They also make a wire bead that they call the "rigid" version of the Voyager without the Hyper designation that weighs 575g. Where did you get the tires? Perhaps they are counterfeit. In looking around at various retailers, I only find them in Black.


Both versions have the hyper label. He clearly bought the wired version. It's a totally different tire than the folding version.


Vittoria Voyager Hyper Wired Tyre | Planet X

Wressen 12-02-15 01:39 PM


Originally Posted by Marc40a (Post 18360846)
Both versions have the hyper label. He clearly bought the wired version. It's a totally different tire than the folding version.


Vittoria Voyager Hyper Wired Tyre | Planet X

No, only the folding one i supposed to be labeled as "Hyper". The other is just called voyager. Voyager - Vittoria.com


And by the way, planetx was of NO HELP!!! They just blamed vittoria for changing the specs.

fietsbob 12-02-15 01:45 PM

Sell them locally get something Else ..

Jamminatrix 12-02-15 01:52 PM


Originally Posted by Wressen (Post 18360864)
No, only the folding one i supposed to be labeled as "Hyper".

If that's the PlanetBike link you bought from, it clearly says wire bead in the title. The wire bead version still says Hyper.

You should be able to tell the difference by trying to fold/bend the tire bead.

Andy_K 12-02-15 03:05 PM


Originally Posted by Wressen (Post 18360864)
No, only the folding one i supposed to be labeled as "Hyper". The other is just called voyager. Voyager - Vittoria.com

It's not that uncommon to find products (especially heavily discounted products) that appear not to exist on the manufacturer's website. Often the manufacturer will produce a SKU for OEM's and then through the overstock process those items find their way onto the discount online market. I don't know if that's what happened here, but it is the kind of thing that happens.

So, basically, you've inadvertently wandered into uncharted territory.

rmfnla 12-02-15 03:18 PM


Originally Posted by Wressen (Post 18144099)
So I have had Vittoria randonneur hyper before and bought some new ones under the voyager hyper label. Difference is that these are now clinchers instead of folding. But i looked on Vittorias homepage, and it states 395 gram, seems quite ok for a 35mm tire.

This turned out to be a huge exaggeration, i know the stated weight might differ some times, but this it ridiculous.

Stated 395 grams for clincher: Voyager Hyper - Vittoria.com

This is almost 50% more than stated!!!??

I think this is where he went wrong....

Wressen 12-02-15 03:24 PM


Originally Posted by rmfnla (Post 18361212)
I think this is where he went wrong....

Yes, clincher is both rigid and folding. But never the less, the vittoria page states that the voyager hyper weighs 395g and my tires are labeled "hyper". And as far as I can see vittoria does not write if the hypers are rigid or folding, just that they are clincher tires.

Leebo 12-02-15 03:39 PM

So you got a great internet deal on some black/ gray/ closeout/ aftermarket tires. Worked out well for you?

hueyhoolihan 12-02-15 03:40 PM

i think i would weigh a pint, or litre, of water with that scale, just to make sure of it's accuracy. then if all is ok, chalk it up to a learning experience and then next time pay an arm and a leg for them at the LBS and take your scale with you.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 10:34 AM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.