Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Bicycle Mechanics (https://www.bikeforums.net/bicycle-mechanics/)
-   -   SRAM Rear Derailleur problem (https://www.bikeforums.net/bicycle-mechanics/1053510-sram-rear-derailleur-problem.html)

xCrazi 03-21-16 11:38 PM

SRAM Rear Derailleur problem
 
Recently i have bought an SRAM X3 Rear Derailleur for my replacement of a Shimano Tourney and i have no luck getting it to shift to my 3 larger cogs on a 7 Speed Shimano Freewheel.

Things i have tried:
Tighten cable on 7th gear
Tighten cable on 1st gear

The X3 does not have a Barrel Adjuster, and my shifter cables are running slightly short ( Will buy some ).
Thanks.

e_guevara 03-22-16 12:17 AM

Welcome to the forums!

SRAM and Shimano shifting systems are incompatible with each other. They have different cable pull ratios which means that one 'click' on the shifter pulls the cable a by different amount to move the RD by the same distance. That being said, the mechanics of the RD is also different to match the cable pull on the shifter. Their cassettes (sprocket spacing) is the same though.

It would be better to stick to matching shifters/derailleurs between SRAM or Shimano.

xCrazi 03-22-16 12:29 AM

Thanks e_guevara, Is the a possible way to way bypass by any chance? Or do i have to buy the X3 Trigger Shifters and Brake levers, Since my shifters are with brakes ( Shimano ).

xCrazi 03-22-16 12:33 AM

Also, Will it affect my front derailleur?, I just need the smallest and middle cog.

e_guevara 03-22-16 01:10 AM

No way to bypass this as this is how the shifters and derailluers are designed to work. No way they will work properly with each other.

Better sell or trade-in your X3 and get an Altus or Alivio (Shimano) RD. Changing your brifters (brakes + shifters - I hate using the term BTW) is the wrong way to go about it.

xCrazi 03-22-16 01:28 AM

Thanks e_guevara, I think i'll just stick with how it works without 6 and 7th gear. I might just get X3 Shifters and brake levers and i can't go about finding someone to buy or trade them.

alcjphil 03-22-16 10:12 AM


Originally Posted by xCrazi (Post 18626974)
Thanks e_guevara, I think i'll just stick with how it works without 6 and 7th gear. I might just get X3 Shifters and brake levers and i can't go about finding someone to buy or trade them.

That makes no sense. Replacing the shifter will cost more than buying a compatible derailleur.

e_guevara 03-22-16 07:02 PM


Originally Posted by alcjphil (Post 18627838)
That makes no sense. Replacing the shifter will cost more than buying a compatible derailleur.

Yup.

xCrazi 03-22-16 09:53 PM

Well, The parts i bought was online and i have no stores around me that have it. Hence why i need to order more parts. Overall the SRAM X3 Runs way better than the Shimano Tourney.

e_guevara 03-23-16 12:52 AM

Was the Tourney broken or was it just not shifting properly? If it was the latter then it may mean it was just improperly adjusted.

I could adjust/tune the Tourney to shift pretty well (I have had several Tourneys on an old MTB and a commuter). Granted it doesn't shift as nice as a Deore or XT, but it does the job.

alcjphil 03-23-16 11:12 AM


Originally Posted by xCrazi (Post 18629766)
Well, The parts i bought was online and i have no stores around me that have it. Hence why i need to order more parts. Overall the SRAM X3 Runs way better than the Shimano Tourney.


A properly adjusted Shimano derailleur will work way better than a SRAM derailleur that cannot get to some of your gears.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 10:52 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.