Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Bicycle Mechanics (https://www.bikeforums.net/bicycle-mechanics/)
-   -   Anyone use a windshield? (https://www.bikeforums.net/bicycle-mechanics/1167651-anyone-use-windshield.html)

flik9999 03-04-19 03:02 PM

Anyone use a windshield?
 
Heya so I know they are apparantly banned from races but for day to day use would a motorcycle windshield help by either improving aerodynamics so that you need to use less energy to go at a certain speed or allow you to go faster on your day to day journeys, eg working as a courier or going long distances.

I ride a motorbike as well as a push bike and with them fairing help a lot with directing the wind around you so wondering if they could be useful on a pushbike as well.

I found this windscreen that weights 1.2 kg which would move my bike up from 9kg to 10kg so still fairly lightweight. But would redirecting the wind make a noticable difference?


https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Universal...bmy:rk:27:pf:0

https://www.notechmagazine.com/2013/...l-fairing.html

fietsbob 03-04-19 03:15 PM

I used to Zzipper 'thriller' a long bubble of flexible clear poly-carbonate plastic.. I did it for weather more than speed ,around rather than through my jacket..

+ I could hear my cheap earbuds for Books on Tape , played on long rural trips home..

Like Jeff's in post 13, but wheel cut out longer and the brackets to the handlebars differed..






....

Iride01 03-04-19 06:17 PM

If I'm riding fast enough for a fairing to benefit me, then I'm thinking I'm generating so much heat that I need the air flow to cool my body, especially during the 95F plus days that will be here when my miles per week peaks in the early summer. Also would have to wonder about gusty winds. Sometimes the winds coming off the reservoir here can catch my wheel and make me pay attention, would a fairing catch more and turn that into a scare or accident?

Maybe not. Or maybe a plus for cold weather riding?

AlmostTrick 03-04-19 06:19 PM

I know @hotbike has/does.

delbiker1 03-04-19 06:26 PM

I have used a windshield. Every car and truck I have ever owned had one.

hotbike 03-04-19 06:37 PM


hotbike 03-04-19 06:39 PM


JanMM 03-04-19 06:40 PM

No aero effect/benefit from a fairing unless you are going at least 15-20mph.

TiHabanero 03-04-19 06:56 PM

Have a hard time believing aero benefits come into play in any significant way below 20mph. Dork factor at any speed will be way, way up there.

hotbike 03-04-19 07:04 PM

There is no measurable wind resistance below 18 mph ( according to an MIT study ), but the fairing on my bike keeps me moving without slowing whenever I encounter a head wind. Also the fairing reduces wind-chill .
From the cargo standpoint, if I had a square , right angled box on the handlebars, it would increase wind resistance.

A tapered tail box also increases top speed .https://cimg2.ibsrv.net/gimg/bikefor...55b9cfa18b.jpg
Tapered \"Kamm Tail" tail box
​​​​​​​

hotbike 03-04-19 07:11 PM


nfmisso 03-04-19 09:13 PM

I tried a windshield on my Trek 720 converted to an e-bike, and removed it after one ride. It helped with reducing drag in a straight line. It made the handling in a cross wind TERRIFYING.

Jeff Wills 03-04-19 10:12 PM


Originally Posted by nfmisso (Post 20822984)
I tried a windshield on my Trek 720 converted to an e-bike, and removed it after one ride. It helped with reducing drag in a straight line. It made the handling in a cross wind TERRIFYING.

Interesting. I've ridden with front fairings on my Easy Racer recumbents for the last 17 years. While cross winds were noticeable, they weren't terrifying. I've been hit by 25mph gusts and been kicked sideways, but it doesn't affect the steering that much. Maybe having all of the fairing in front of the steering axis makes it unstable.

FWIW: I find that airflow around the fairing allows for normal cooling on hot days. My friends who use fabric body socks for additional streamlining wet the sock down for extra evaporative cooling.

https://cimg2.ibsrv.net/gimg/bikefor...c842092533.jpg

Jeff Wills 03-04-19 10:14 PM


Originally Posted by TiHabanero (Post 20822822)
Have a hard time believing aero benefits come into play in any significant way below 20mph. Dork factor at any speed will be way, way up there.

That's "MISTER Dork" to you! :)

Notso_fastLane 03-05-19 07:42 AM

They do help for aerodynamics if you're going fast enough. My experience is that it starts 'feeling' faster between 12-15 mph, and the net speed increase (on my recumbent) was about 2 mph.

I'm currently saving up for a velomobile. :) Although it's mostly for the wind/cold protection for my winter commute, since my current route is fairly flat, I suspect it will be a bit faster, even though it weighs about 25 lbs more.

The Windcheetah is a very fast machine:
https://media.treehugger.com/assets/...tah_021705.jpg

wphamilton 03-05-19 08:05 AM

I use a motorcycle windshield for my faired bike. I'd been curving polycarbonate sheets for it but this was dirt cheap ordered from overseas so why not. It's a windscreen, Yamaha or Kawasaki or something like that, and was around $25.

A handlebar mounted windscreen on your diamond frame bike will help you a little bit aerodynamically but not so much that you'd really see it. If it's really large, like beyond your bar ends, you could get a net loss because of the larger area. It's more advantageous on a recumbent because (main reason of several) we're sitting more vertical on road bikes and we sit shoulders forward which is bigger than feet forward. So it takes a larger windscreen. Also if your surface has edges and angles it will eliminate the aero benefit.

wphamilton 03-05-19 08:16 AM


Originally Posted by Jeff Wills (Post 20823053)
Interesting. I've ridden with front fairings on my Easy Racer recumbents for the last 17 years. While cross winds were noticeable, they weren't terrifying. I've been hit by 25mph gusts and been kicked sideways, but it doesn't affect the steering that much. Maybe having all of the fairing in front of the steering axis makes it unstable.

That nails it. Even if it's not on the steering axis and frame mounted, if it's in front of the turning axis you'll get some instability. In my home designs it could get a little squirrelly if I made it too compact with not enough surface rearward.

I think I've seen photos of your velo, a beautiful bike.

hotbike 03-05-19 09:28 AM

https://cimg6.ibsrv.net/gimg/bikefor...060e5dd5a0.jpg
https://cimg8.ibsrv.net/gimg/bikefor...3911ccd09c.jpg
You might need a fork with more trail angle, lower head tube angle, for better stability, or get a recumbent. Or get longer handlebars, learn to heel into the wind , pilots land in cross winds, sailboats go faster in strong wind , but those sailors lean way over the rail...
Now the charts and graphs , from Douglas Malewicki, ©1983

TiHabanero 03-05-19 12:19 PM

"That's "MISTER Dork" to you! https://www.bikeforums.net/images/smilies/smile.gif "

Haha. Thanks for making my day!

JanMM 03-05-19 12:43 PM

Saw this team at the Hilly Hundred a decade or so ago - they were blazing fast but maybe that was because of the skeleton garments.

https://i189.photobucket.com/albums/...MG_0150b-1.jpg

tcs 03-06-19 12:01 PM

Once, long ago, in a galaxy far away...

https://cimg3.ibsrv.net/gimg/bikefor...9ad952e909.png

fietsbob 03-06-19 01:43 PM

AM Zzipper http://www.zzipper.com/images/prod_df/Untitled-5.jpg film era, when you could flip negatives & print them..


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 10:24 PM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.