Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Bicycle Mechanics (https://www.bikeforums.net/bicycle-mechanics/)
-   -   Problem with front derailleur (https://www.bikeforums.net/bicycle-mechanics/1180700-problem-front-derailleur.html)

matlev 08-10-19 08:12 AM

Problem with front derailleur
 
Hi,

I've got this weird issue when the chain is brushing against the front derailleur when I'm set to either lowest or highest rear gear. This started happening after my wheels got nicked and I had to buy new ones along with a freewheel casette.
Any ideas why this might've started happening?

Cheers!

trailangel 08-10-19 08:27 AM


Originally Posted by matlev (Post 21068868)
Hi,

I've got this weird issue when the chain is bruising against the front derailleur when I'm set to either lowest or highest rear gear. This started happening after my wheels got nicked and I had to buy new ones along with a freewheel casette.
Any ideas why this might've started happening?

Cheers!

Yes. It started because your wheels got nicked and you had to buy new wheels and a freewheel cassette.

matlev 08-10-19 08:29 AM


Originally Posted by trailangel (Post 21068877)
Yes. It started because your wheels got nicked and you had to buy new wheels and a freewheel cassette.

Very helpful indeed.
But seriously, ideas on fixing the issue?
Thanks

trailangel 08-10-19 08:32 AM

Anytime you put different wheels on or a different freewheel cassette (**********) you need to re-adjust your derailleurs. Have you done this?

ridelikeaturtle 08-10-19 08:33 AM

Must be a slightly different hub spacing on the new wheels causing a change in the chain line. Try adjusting your upper and lower limit screws on the FD a quarter turn, not enough to throw your chain either way, but enough to stop it rubbing as you approach the limits.

matlev 08-10-19 08:35 AM


Originally Posted by ridelikeaturtle (Post 21068886)
Must be a slightly different hub spacing on the new wheels causing a change in the chain line. Try adjusting your upper and lower limit screws on the FD a quarter turn, not enough to throw your chain either way, but enough to stop it rubbing as you approach the limits.

Hi, thanks. The thing is, I've tried adjusting this. I am thinking of actually replacing the derailleur maybe?

trailangel 08-10-19 08:39 AM

Did you release the cable tension and start completely new?

ridelikeaturtle 08-10-19 08:39 AM


Originally Posted by matlev (Post 21068891)
Hi, thanks. The thing is, I've tried adjusting this. I am thinking of actually replacing the derailleur maybe?

Before you go to that extreme, try disconnecting everything and starting from scratch. (You'd have to do this anyway with any new FD.) Realign it w/the cranks, make sure it's all the correct angle & height, re-check your limit screws, clean & lube everything really good... and why not, make sure the rear wheel is correctly seated in the dropouts... and go from there.

matlev 08-10-19 08:42 AM


Originally Posted by ridelikeaturtle (Post 21068898)
Before you go to that extreme, try disconnecting everything and starting from scratch. (You'd have to do this anyway with any new FD.) Realign it w/the cranks, make sure it's all the correct angle & height, re-check your limit screws, clean & lube everything really good... and why not, make sure the rear wheel is correctly seated in the dropouts... and go from there.

Yes I have released the cable tension. Well, if that's what you think I need to do, then I'll probably start there. The only thing that baffles me is that it brushes on both highest and lowest gear?

ridelikeaturtle 08-10-19 08:47 AM

If it's misaligned, it can be touching / rubbing in different places at the extremes.

It worked before you changed wheels, logically it should be able to work again.

matlev 08-10-19 08:51 AM

Logically, yes it should.
Thanks, will try it!

ronin4740 08-12-19 01:58 PM

Most front derailleurs have screws which adjust the lower and upper travel limits. If other posters are correct and the chain line has changed you may need to adjust these so that both allow a little more travel along with adjusting cable tension.

Eggman84 08-12-19 06:04 PM

Not to be difficult but it seems we are missing lots of information. First is are the shifters friction or indexed? With the old wheel did you have to trim the FD to keep itfrom rubbbing? Are you able to trim the FD with the new wheel? How many speeds front and rear?

AeroGut 08-12-19 06:16 PM

I would also check that the FD is lined up straight. If it got turned a bit so it's at an angle relative the the chain, that can cause rubbing on both ends. And I agree with Eggman84 - a bit more info on the type of derailleur, levers and gear setup would be helpful.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:58 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.