Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Bicycle Mechanics (https://www.bikeforums.net/bicycle-mechanics/)
-   -   BB cross threaded (https://www.bikeforums.net/bicycle-mechanics/1187774-bb-cross-threaded.html)

Ben clegg 11-11-19 01:29 AM

BB cross threaded
 
Hi
Does anyone have any tips on how to rethread the BB?
I've had the frame resprayed and the thread is now clogged with paint, i've managed to get the right side in but am struggling getting a straight start to the thread on the left (none drive side).
The frame is aluminum .
Any ideas out there?

CliffordK 11-11-19 01:48 AM

Paint or powdercoat?

Many older bike shops should have thread taps, and chasing the threads should be relatively easy if there is enough to catch the original threads.

You can also "face" the bottom bracket which will clean any paint off of the outside edges, and get yourself a nice square face to work with.

Unca_Sam 11-11-19 02:27 AM

Clifford has the best choice. If you're strapped for cash, try a brass brush rotated along the threads to expose more of them, then chase with a well lubricated cup a few times.

AnkleWork 11-11-19 09:43 AM

Paint stripper, carefully applied.

ign1te 11-11-19 09:52 AM

Use a power drill + wire brush wheel of appropriate size inserted directly into BB shell. If your drill is even moderately powerful, the paint will come off.

Crankycrank 11-11-19 01:44 PM


Originally Posted by ign1te (Post 21204046)
Use a power drill + wire brush wheel of appropriate size inserted directly into BB shell. If your drill is even moderately powerful, the paint will come off.

I would avoid any power tools on aluminum threads. It will destroy them pretty quickly.

Reynolds 11-11-19 01:59 PM

You can make thread cleaning taps with old steel cups and a Dremel.

CliffordK 11-11-19 02:02 PM


Originally Posted by Reynolds (Post 21204432)
You can make thread cleaning taps with old steel cups and a Dremel.

Probably.

Although a real tap kit will hold the tap into alignment as long as it can catch the first thread.

Bill Kapaun 11-11-19 02:25 PM


Originally Posted by Reynolds (Post 21204432)
You can make thread cleaning taps with old steel cups and a Dremel.

And use them as "plugs" before painting-

Unca_Sam 11-11-19 03:27 PM


Originally Posted by Bill Kapaun (Post 21204477)
And use them as "plugs" before painting-

Yeah, masking off important threads shouldn't be overlooked. An ounce of prevention...

dedhed 11-11-19 03:36 PM

Are you first turning it in the wrong direction and feeling for it to "drop" and align? I realize with the fine threads of a BB feeling the drop isn't like coarse threads.

CliffordK 11-11-19 05:07 PM


Originally Posted by dedhed (Post 21204572)
Are you first turning it in the wrong direction and feeling for it to "drop" and align? I realize with the fine threads of a BB feeling the drop isn't like coarse threads.

The other point, of course, is that:

For standard English/ISO threading, pedals are right/right, left/left

Bottom brackets are just the opposite.

Right hand side, left threads.
Left hand side, right threads.

So, if the OP has already gotten the right hand side in, then that shouldn't be an issue. But, it is always worth considering.

3alarmer 11-11-19 05:45 PM

.
...find someone with a set of piloted taps. Takes 5 minutes with the right tool, and the repair costs if you genuinely cross thread it the entire length of one side will far exceed whatever someone charges you to do it. We have a set of piloted taps at the bike co-op here, (both English and Italian). See if there's a similar bicycle co-op near you. If you already have one side working well, the pilot shaft will make short work of getting the other side started properly.

https://cimg0.ibsrv.net/gimg/bikefor...ac1acf556e.jpg

squirtdad 11-11-19 06:06 PM


Originally Posted by CliffordK (Post 21203696)
Paint or powdercoat?

Many older bike shops should have thread taps, and chasing the threads should be relatively easy if there is enough to catch the original threads.

You can also "face" the bottom bracket which will clean any paint off of the outside edges, and get yourself a nice square face to work with.

+1 for the win

Mad Honk 11-11-19 07:32 PM

Triple alarmer,
Those taps aren't cheap! the last set I bought were $160, so any bike shop doing thread chasing is gonna want some compensation for the tools and the job.
But the best way to do a thread cleaning is with the piloted threading tools. I have a number of vintage bikes that were sent out for recovering with powder coatings and the best option was to use the piloted taps for cleaning the threads after the painting. My advice to anyone with this problem is to look to a professional for help. The cost are just too high for the home mechanic. Smiles, MH

3alarmer 11-11-19 09:52 PM

.
...I bought some Cyclus ones through an online Dutch website about 8-10 years ago (for about 100 bucks a set, with the handles) when I got tired of always dragging my projects over to the co-op. In my case, they've more than paid for themselves, but I have a lot of projects. :)

I see they're up to 118 bucks American now. But unless you have some other stuff to order at the same time, the shipping costs are another 30 bucks. Nonetheless, they seem to be pretty solid tools based on my experience with them. I wish I could get a set of French threaded ones somewhere, instead of using my trusty single tapered tap in that size, one side very carefully at a time.

Gresp15C 11-11-19 10:10 PM

Sometimes, if just one or two threads are dinged up, you can use a hand tap of the same pitch but a smaller diameter, as a scraper to clean internal threads. An old machinist taught me that.

79pmooney 11-11-19 10:21 PM

If these are English taps and they cannot be saved and you want to keep this frame there is always the Italian thread option. Italian BBs are enough bigger that any English, French or Swiss BB shell threads at any state of disrepair can be drilled and tapped to Italian and basically be like new. (But care for them. There is no place to go if you mess them up.) You will have to find the shop that has the taps and they will want real money to do this.

I've never had to do this but have known of this for the past 40 somethng years.

Ben

wheelreason 11-12-19 07:00 AM


Originally Posted by Mad Honk (Post 21204854)
...any bike shop doing thread chasing is gonna want some compensation for the tools and the job...
MH

Greedy LBS! I live for roadies coming in with stuff where they bit off too much, the algorithm says CHARGE!
And yes, it takes longer to take the tool out of the case, clean it, and put it away that the job itself, but hey, the only tool I like more than taps (grinder doesn't count) is my Abbey HAG.

Ronsonic 11-12-19 09:29 AM

On a recent build my favorite shop gave the new-to-me frame a full inspection and did a needed "chase and face" on the BB shell for $35.

I cannot tell you how much better a build goes together with this sort of treatment. I used to just work with what I got and then after a couple of builds with properly serviced Headtubes and Bottom Brackets and aligned Drop-Outs, etc. I am not going to skip this stuff again.

I am cheap, would rather DIY whenever I can, but ...

Really, it's worth it.

hokiefyd 11-12-19 09:30 AM


Originally Posted by Reynolds (Post 21204432)
You can make thread cleaning taps with old steel cups and a Dremel.

I have done this, and it's worked great on a few occasions. This video should help you (or anyone) out, if all you truly have to do is clean paint or other garbage out of otherwise good threads:


AnkleWork 11-12-19 12:14 PM

OP: Is it cross-threaded or just clogged with paint?
Some in this forum default to the most destructive methods first and forget that taps only remove metal, not "restore" it. Using a tap should follow after some other (nondestructive) methods have been tried, and only when proven necessary. Also as mentioned above, even brass wire brushing will damage aluminum threads if not done gently. Excessive brushing work-hardens and distorts the surface making subsequent remediation much more difficult.

Ben clegg 11-19-19 01:27 AM

Hi People
Thanks for all the advice , I didn't want to take it to the shop nor buy a special tool that I would only use once in a blue moon, as I wanted to see if I could do this myself. So this is what I eventually ended up doing.

Faced the edge with a packing knife blade, this made it easier for me to see what I was up against.
I then used the packing knife in the grooves of the thread, I was surprised how easy this was to get out a lot of the paint.
Eventually I used the "RJ guys" method (thanks hokiefyd) of using an old square type bottom bracket to re-cut the rest of the threads . Did this on both sides and now I can screw the new bottom bracket all the way in and out with my fingers.

Thanks to everyone for all the suggestions, really appreciated :giver:


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:25 PM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.