![]() |
Headset woes...
I have a 1987 Schwinn Cimarron LE that was outfitted with a Tange G Master JIS size (30.0mm/27.0mm) headset for some silly reason. Why Schwinn would do this on a bike of this caliber (nice in its day) is a little strange I guess. My question is this. I bought a couple of Tange Passage headsets from Harris Cyclery that were listed as 30.0mm/27.0mm on their website, but when I got them yesterday they were 30.2mm/27.0mm. I promptly emailed Sheldon Brown and asked him about this and he said that in his experience the .2mm difference is not a problem on a steel frame. I respect his opinion but I guess I need a second or third opinion before I install this headset on my bike because I really don't want to damage the head tube since I cannot easily replace this frame, which I like. Has any one else run into this and had success installing a similar headset? I apologize if this has already been addressed in another thread, but I couldn't find it if it was. Thanks.
|
Well... I've never tried to install a wrong-size headset in a frame. On the other hand, I've found all of Sheldon's mechanical advice ever to be correct :)
|
You question a guy who has done many of the thing that he recommends? :) I'm too lazy to look up tensile strength of steel right now, but given the circumference of the headtube C=2*Pi*r=2*Pi*D/2=Pi*D, it's a difference of Pi*30mm and Pi*30.2mm, which is less than 1% difference, which I'm definite is still well within steel's elastic region. IOW's should be safe to do so. Maybe those with better memory of materials science can confirm.
|
And, Sheldon, if you happen to view this post, I mean no disrespect. I refer to your website on a regular basis and find the information very helpful. I guess I am looking at this like I would with a medical question. I have the opinion of a well respected physician and want to confirm that with another physician before going under the knife.
|
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 06:45 PM. |
Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.