Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Bicycle Mechanics (https://www.bikeforums.net/bicycle-mechanics/)
-   -   Bottom Bracket Problem (https://www.bikeforums.net/bicycle-mechanics/312409-bottom-bracket-problem.html)

dang133 06-21-07 07:14 PM

Bottom Bracket Problem
 
Hi everyone. I just got back from a CA to FL coast to coast tour (which was awesome) on my Trek 540. Around Destin,FL, my bottom bracket totally went out. I managed to limp the bike over to a bike shop to get it repaired and basically the internal threads went out (completely mashed and mangled). The mechanic at the shop managed to clean out the threads and put in a square style bracket, but its only hanging on by 3 1/4 threads. Any ideas on how long this bottom bracket is gonna last? Is there anyway to repair the damage to my frame or find a work around solution?


Thanks!

vpiuva 06-21-07 07:32 PM

Mavic and YST made some BB that don't require threads, but do require other machining so it's far from perfect. If you started with English you can tap it out to the larger Italian (I have one bike retapped from French). My suggestion for now is Loctite - maybe even the permanent red stuff. Hopefully someone on here has a better solution.

And great trip!

DieselDan 06-21-07 08:00 PM

Is the bike new enough to have the frame warrantied?

dang133 06-21-07 08:03 PM

I was told that Italian wasn't any bigger by one mechanic and the opposite by another. Help? Whats loctite?

dang133 06-21-07 08:04 PM

Alas, I tried the warranty. I'm not the original owner so it won't work.

dang133 06-21-07 08:10 PM

I looked into Loctite. Thats probably my best option. Any ideas on what is the longest lasting bottom bracket ever made (cause its the only one this bike is ever gonna have).

vpiuva 06-21-07 08:31 PM


Originally Posted by dang133
I was told that Italian wasn't any bigger by one mechanic and the opposite by another. Help? Whats loctite?

Don't go back to that first mechanic. The outside thread diameter (assuming English) of your BB is 34.8mm (1.37"), and the inside thread diameter of an Italian BB shell is about 35.2mm (outside 36mm), so there's room to retap if need be.

Long lasting - Phil Wood, but not cheap.

dang133 06-21-07 08:41 PM

I dont have the extra .4mm of metal, I'll go with the Phil Wood. Any idea how many miles it will last. I understand your typical shimano square style will last 10-15k.

dang133 06-23-07 09:49 AM

Any idea where I can find these bottom brackets that dont require threads?



Originally Posted by vpiuva
Mavic and YST made some BB that don't require threads, but do require other machining so it's far from perfect. If you started with English you can tap it out to the larger Italian (I have one bike retapped from French). My suggestion for now is Loctite - maybe even the permanent red stuff. Hopefully someone on here has a better solution.

And great trip!


dang133 06-23-07 12:28 PM

I looked for YST and couldn't find anything, help?

vpiuva 06-23-07 12:33 PM


Originally Posted by dang133
I looked for YST and couldn't find anything, help?

I know Harris Cyclery carried these at one time, look at their site.

dang133 06-23-07 12:39 PM

They stopped carrying them. But the site gave me some hints on other places to look. I found a cannondale r300 (mint condition) for sale in a bike shop for 200 bucks yesterday. I just bought it (the guy who owned it never paid his service bill and the bill was 200 bucks) and figured if all else fails i'll throw all my touring stuff on that bike. Who knows, it could work.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 05:18 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.