Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Bicycle Mechanics (https://www.bikeforums.net/bicycle-mechanics/)
-   -   Bar-end shifter cabe routing and DT shifter issue (https://www.bikeforums.net/bicycle-mechanics/384023-bar-end-shifter-cabe-routing-dt-shifter-issue.html)

rodri9o 01-31-08 05:50 AM

Bar-end shifter cabe routing and DT shifter issue
 
I ended up getting a set of Campagnolo 10sp bar-end shifters and they came with some long Campagnolo cables...enough to route the cables and housing under the bar tape from the bar-end shifter plug all the way up to the flat portion of the bar by the stem clamp.

Anyone experience any issues with shifting by running such a long, contorted cable housing?

Also, even though I was intending on using the bar-end shifters as downtube shifters, I'm not sure I can do that...I need to get a shifter boss stop for both levers, otherwise the levers will spin 360degrees around.

Any suggestion for that?

Soil_Sampler 01-31-08 07:52 AM


Originally Posted by rodri9o (Post 6082778)
I need to get a shifter boss stop for both levers, otherwise the levers will spin 360degrees around.

who told you that?

anti.team 01-31-08 09:46 AM


Originally Posted by rodri9o (Post 6082778)
Anyone experience any issues with shifting by running such a long, contorted cable housing?

I wondered the same thing, and if you do a search for it the consensus seems to be that under the bar routing is probably fine. Most people were talking about friction shifters being fine, but indexed should probably work too. Just make sure the housing is nice and tight against the bars and it shouldn't give you much trouble.

Unfortunately I routed my cables the conventional way before I realized you could route the cables under the tape. Oh well, next time I guess.

roadfix 01-31-08 11:12 AM

I've got my bar end shifters routed ergo style. Shifts perfectly fine. The only thing is that you may find the rear cable barely long enough in which case a slightly longer cable or a tandem cable may be required.

Ergo routing on my Long Haul Trucker

http://i31.photobucket.com/albums/c3...rontMedium.jpg

cachehiker 01-31-08 11:42 AM


Originally Posted by roadfix (Post 6083992)
I've got my bar end shifters routed ergo style. Shifts perfectly fine. The only thing is that you may find the rear cable barely long enough in which case a slightly longer cable or a tandem cable may be required.

Even on a small 50cm frame, my RD inner wire came up about 4cm too short. Heading into the shop for a tandem cable in an hour or so.

tellyho 01-31-08 01:54 PM

I couldn't even get ergo routing with a tandem cable in my wife's bike's case. But you should be fine.

rodri9o 01-31-08 07:59 PM

We'll see if there is enough cable for it...I'm sure I can get a longer cable at the shop if I need to. This is all getting mounted on a 53cm frame.




Originally Posted by Soil_Sampler (Post 6083009)
who told you that?

well...I took the indexed (right side) shift lever off the bar-end pod and installed it on the boss...it kept spinning around....so I put it back on the bar-end pod.





Love those brake levers, roadfix.

cmdr 01-31-08 08:42 PM

I've done it on two 56cm bikes. I still had just enough cable to get the RD adjusted. I used the double ended cable, maybe that's a little longer.

Soil_Sampler 01-31-08 08:47 PM


Originally Posted by rodri9o (Post 6086997)
well...I took the indexed (right side) shift lever off the bar-end pod and installed it on the boss...it kept spinning around....so I put it back on the bar-end pod.

according to this dude, it is supposed to fit.
http://www.bikeforums.net/showpost.p...5&postcount=81
mine will be here in a couple days, I'll see whats up?

poprad 01-31-08 09:04 PM


Originally Posted by roadfix (Post 6083992)
I've got my bar end shifters routed ergo style. Shifts perfectly fine. The only thing is that you may find the rear cable barely long enough in which case a slightly longer cable or a tandem cable may be required.

Ergo routing on my Long Haul Trucker

http://i31.photobucket.com/albums/c3...rontMedium.jpg

Post some more of this bike! Nice build!

rodri9o 01-31-08 09:08 PM


Originally Posted by Soil_Sampler (Post 6087258)
according to this dude, it is supposed to fit.
mine will be here in a couple days, I'll see whats up?

I'm going to take it apart again....

rodri9o 02-01-08 06:40 AM


Originally Posted by rodri9o (Post 6087373)
I'm going to take it apart again....

I took it apart again last night and the lever, although indexing, was spinning all around...
I think the bar-end levers will look pretty cool though:

http://i177.photobucket.com/albums/w...a/P2010004.jpg

Soil_Sampler 02-01-08 07:56 AM


Originally Posted by rodri9o (Post 6088658)
I took it apart again last night and the lever, although indexing, was spinning all around...

without a cable hooked-up to a derailleur...?

edit

I see said the blind man...looks like he was full of schit! you have to use the barend stops!

http://www.branfordbike.com/images/b...o/barendpt.jpg

markjenn 02-01-08 01:39 PM

On trick is to cross the cables under the downtube by running the right-side shifter cable to the left boss and vice versa. This greatly lessens how sharp you have to make the bend between where the cable housing exits under the tape down to the boss. This might allow you to cut the housing shorter or use a housing that would be too short otherwise.

This also lessens or elminates abrasion of the housing against the side of the head tube.

The cables may touch under the downtube but the angle is so oblique, it causes no problem or wear.

- Mark

tpelle 02-01-08 01:46 PM


Originally Posted by roadfix (Post 6083992)
I've got my bar end shifters routed ergo style. Shifts perfectly fine. The only thing is that you may find the rear cable barely long enough in which case a slightly longer cable or a tandem cable may be required.

Ergo routing on my Long Haul Trucker

http://i31.photobucket.com/albums/c3...rontMedium.jpg


That's a good looking bike. My LHT has the shifter cables exiting straight from the bar bottoms and making a big loop out front, but the brake cables are done like like yours.

Here's mine:

http://i31.photobucket.com/albums/c3...T/DSCN0412.jpg

http://i31.photobucket.com/albums/c3...rly_LHT008.jpg

http://i31.photobucket.com/albums/c3...rly_LHT016.jpg

roadfix 02-01-08 02:04 PM


Originally Posted by poprad (Post 6087347)
Post some more of this bike! Nice build!

Thanks!

http://i31.photobucket.com/albums/c3...n/VegaRack.jpg

relyt 02-01-08 04:02 PM


Originally Posted by tpelle (Post 6090946)
That's a good looking bike. My LHT has the shifter cables exiting straight from the bar bottoms and making a big loop out front, but the brake cables are done like like yours.

Do you find that this kind of routing gets in the way of your hands when in the drops?

anti.team 02-01-08 05:50 PM


Originally Posted by relyt (Post 6091886)
Do you find that this kind of routing gets in the way of your hands when in the drops?

Mine are set up the same way, and it does get in the way in the drops a little. I think it would be pretty easy to get used to; I just got mine set up that way so I'm not sure yet. I would rather have routed fully under the bars.

I saw another alternate routing too, where the shifter cable runs under the tape up to the hood, then exits and loops back to the stops. I would have done it this way if I still had enough cable/housing length. It looks like it wouldn't get in the way if you did it right. Check it out:


Originally Posted by Scooper (Post 3770894)
Mine is sort of a compromise between the standard lowest friction Cascade 168 routing and carrying the housings in the bar tape all the way to the stem like The Fixer and Top506. Frankly, I was afraid to try routing the housings in the bar tape all the way to the stem.

Shifting is flawless.

http://i32.photobucket.com/albums/d7...CIMG2337sm.jpg


thechamp 02-01-08 06:39 PM

I've routed the cables under the bartape on several different bikes/handlebars with no issue. So long as you don't use those cubist modolo handlebars you should be fine.
But isn't it time someone turned this into a barend vs sti thread? It's been a week or so and I feel it might be revisited. Maybe someone has some new important information to share.

rodri9o 02-01-08 09:37 PM


Originally Posted by thechamp (Post 6092899)
But isn't it time someone turned this into a barend vs ergo thread? It's been a week or so and I feel it might be revisited. Maybe someone has some new important information to share.

I already have ergo's on a few bikes. :p

Soil_Sampler 02-02-08 01:58 AM


Originally Posted by thechamp (Post 6092899)
But isn't it time someone turned this into a barend vs sti thread? It's been a week or so and I feel it might be revisited.
Maybe someone has some new important information to share.

eff that! it's going 2b a dt vs bar end shifter thread!

ridethecliche 02-02-08 12:37 PM

This thread makes me wonder if I'd rather have indexed DT or indexed Bar ends instead of STI when if and when I upgrade my trek...

roadfix 02-02-08 12:42 PM

If you take your coffee black, or ride a fixed gear, your next road bike upgrade should naturally be either bar end or down tube shifters.

rodri9o 02-02-08 04:46 PM


Originally Posted by roadfix (Post 6096344)
...take your coffee black...

does espresso count?

rodri9o 02-03-08 07:55 AM

DONE!
needs to be cleaned up so it will come apart again next weekend if I can get a stand at the shop for personal use, but ti is essentially all there and working.

http://i177.photobucket.com/albums/w...a/P2030001.jpg


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 06:43 AM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.