Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Bicycle Mechanics (https://www.bikeforums.net/bicycle-mechanics/)
-   -   Butyl Tubes? (https://www.bikeforums.net/bicycle-mechanics/813539-butyl-tubes.html)

WickedThump 04-25-12 01:47 AM

Butyl Tubes?
 
I saw some on ebay. What're the pros/cons of butyl rubber tubes?

zukahn1 04-25-12 02:18 AM

Cost a lot more a little tuffer and litter but will not do anything against the evil goat heads on the trails and streats of Denver They will go through almost any tire tube combo they are slowed down a bit by Mister Tuffy's but not by much.

ben4345 04-25-12 04:34 AM

seriously?

They been around for a long time now, chances are, you already have them. :P

cyccommute 04-25-12 06:38 AM

Like ben4345 said, you probably already have them. Butyl rubber is the most common rubber used for inner tubes. Latex (natural rubber) tubes are rate because it is delicate and difficult to patch. It's not worth buying them off Fleabay. Go to your local shop.

Kimmo 04-25-12 07:22 AM

LOL. I hear ferrous alloy frames are the next big thing...

FBinNY 04-25-12 08:40 AM

As others have said most inner tubes are butyl, whether they make a claim about it or not. Butyl is used because it's more impervious to air molecules and so holds air better than other materials while still being strong and stretchy.

Don't let the tone of some of the other responses get to you. None of us, even the most expert, was born with this knowledge and had to learn it at some point in our lives.

fietsbob 04-25-12 10:03 AM

Butyl is an (oil) butane product.. it is the norm for tubes.. latex loses air too fast ..
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Butyl

all tires are mostly butyl rubber

gmt13 04-25-12 10:33 AM

With latex tubes, you need to pump up every ride. With butyl tubes you do it once a week (but could probably go much longer). Butyl tubes are quite a bit heavier than latex, but for a given thickness, latex is stretchier and therefore resists punctures better. Basically if it's black, it's probably butyl rubber.

-G

cyccommute 04-25-12 11:36 AM


Originally Posted by fietsbob (Post 14142991)
Butyl is an (oil) butane product

Um...not really. Butyl rubber is a polymer of 2-methylpropene. While this is a 4 carbon hydrocarbon, it's not really considered a 'butane' because a butane is a saturated hydrocarbon. In the polymer form, it's called polyisobutylene and contains some isoprene.


Originally Posted by fietsbob (Post 14142991)
.. it is the norm for tubes.. latex loses air too fast ..

all tires are mostly butyl rubber

This is correct.

fietsbob 04-25-12 11:44 AM

Guess you too can correct Wikipedia, as I understand it..

cyccommute 04-25-12 01:24 PM


Originally Posted by fietsbob (Post 14143500)
Guess you too can correct Wikipedia, as I understand it..

You used it incorrectly. Wikipedia is a little wrong because the IUPAC name for the 'isobutyl' group is the 2-methylpropyl group but they did list it correctly under the "Systematic Name". The "System" is the IUPAC system.

ben4345 04-25-12 02:07 PM


Originally Posted by FBinNY (Post 14142573)
As others have said most inner tubes are butyl, whether they make a claim about it or not. Butyl is used because it's more impervious to air molecules and so holds air better than other materials while still being strong and stretchy.

Don't let the tone of some of the other responses get to you. None of us, even the most expert, was born with this knowledge and had to learn it at some point in our lives.

I wasn't trying to mean, rude or anything. Just good forum fun!

Al1943 04-25-12 03:42 PM


Originally Posted by gmt13 (Post 14143135)
With latex tubes, you need to pump up every ride. With butyl tubes you do it once a week (but could probably go much longer).

Can't agree with that at all. Especially with high pressure road tires. I pump mine up before each ride. They can lose 5 psi or even more overnight.

fr333zin 04-25-12 04:16 PM

Latex tubes have lower rolling resistance (although tyre choice has more influence) and are lighter than equivalent butyl. But don't hold pressure very long, and puncture more easily. It's really a race-oriented product IMHO. For a while you could get polythene tubes from Nutrak but there wasn't much advantage that I found. So it's butyl tubes for me these days, Continental or Schwalbe usually.

WickedThump 04-25-12 06:48 PM

Wow. OK. Got it.
What were the tubes I saw advertised in the mid 90's where they were streching it over a big shard of glass?

fietsbob 04-25-12 07:00 PM

Yea the Air-pressure in the tire wants to equalize with the ambient air pressure outside.

Whiteknight 04-25-12 07:12 PM


Originally Posted by cyccommute (Post 14143464)
Um...not really. Butyl rubber is a polymer of 2-methylpropene. While this is a 4 carbon hydrocarbon, it's not really considered a 'butane' because a butane is a saturated hydrocarbon. In the polymer form, it's called polyisobutylene and contains some isoprene.



This is correct.

This thread takes me back about 20 years.
I used to QC batches of butadiene rubber and styrene-butadiene rubbers. My job was gum dip latex for tire cord coating. Checked the bd going into the reaction vessels and the final latex going into the rail cars.

JanMM 04-25-12 07:49 PM

Another good thing about butyl rubber tubes: If you have latex allergy, no problem.
Bad thing about latex tubes: If you have latex allergy --> problem.
Latex allergy is more common than it used to be.

gmt13 04-26-12 10:40 AM


Originally Posted by Al1943 (Post 14144784)
Can't agree with that at all. Especially with high pressure road tires. I pump mine up before each ride. They can lose 5 psi or even more overnight.

Yep, I agree with you disagreeing - YMMV. It depends on your tire and your tolerance for lower pressures. I generally pump up the tires on my commuter every weekend to about 80 psi. By the end of the next week, they may be down to 65-70 psi. but that's ok since they are 32s and quite comfortable as low as 50 psi. I actually like the ride at the end of the week a bit better than earlier (some roads are a bit rough).

Pressure loss rate is a function of starting pressure so the higher the pressure the faster the tire will bleed down.

-G

LVRider 04-27-12 03:54 PM


Originally Posted by JanMM (Post 14145759)
Another good thing about butyl rubber tubes: If you have latex allergy, no problem.
Bad thing about latex tubes: If you have latex allergy --> problem.
Latex allergy is more common than it used to be.

I have a latex allergy. It sucks. You likely already have butyl tubes.

JanMM 04-27-12 08:08 PM


Originally Posted by LVRider (Post 14153429)
I have a latex allergy. It sucks. You likely already have butyl tubes.

Have never used a latex tube in several decades of cycling - not sure if I've seen one. Have used many latex gloves and tourniquets, etc. in hospitals. Those are much, much less common than they used to be. Have not developed latex allergy thankfully.

Chesha Neko 04-27-12 08:27 PM


Originally Posted by JanMM (Post 14154078)
Have never used a latex tube in several decades of cycling - not sure if I've seen one. Have used many latex gloves and tourniquets, etc. in hospitals. Those are much, much less common than they used to be. Have not developed latex allergy thankfully.

I'm curious to try latex tubes, but at $15 a tube it's not that urgent. ;)

JanMM 04-27-12 08:50 PM


Originally Posted by Chesha Neko (Post 14154132)
I'm curious to try latex tubes, but at $15 a tube it's not that urgent. ;)

Yes, that's another good reason to stick with butyl.

fr333zin 04-28-12 01:07 AM

You can simulate owning latex tubes without any expense - just let your tyres down by about half at the end of each day and then pump them up again in the morning before you go for a ride. I owned some when I was time-trialling every weekend but they did not appear to offer any benefit in reduced times at all, not even a placebo effect!

Seve 04-28-12 02:06 AM

Latex tubes are often sewn into high end tubulars for a reason.

I have used them with certain 320 TPI tires and the ride with Latex tubes in that scenario was as good as it gets for a layperson @ 700 x 23 ride IMHO.
Bear in mind everything is subjective and I have no empirical data to present.

No doubt the standard butyl inner tube is the way to go. Less care needed, cheaper and easily available.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:48 PM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.