Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Bicycle Mechanics (https://www.bikeforums.net/bicycle-mechanics/)
-   -   Please help troubleshoot ticking sound. Maybe BB30 ? *VIDEO* (https://www.bikeforums.net/bicycle-mechanics/933226-please-help-troubleshoot-ticking-sound-maybe-bb30-video.html)

diggy488 02-07-14 10:04 AM

Please help troubleshoot ticking sound. Maybe BB30 ? *VIDEO*
 
I'm getting a ticking/pinging sound when I apply a lot of pressure to the pedals, like when climbing a hill or sprinting. While on the trainer, I can feel the pinging when I grip the frame. I don't think it's a pedal bearing nor is it my cleats. I don't feel it through my feet. I get the same sound if I wear flip flops. Performance otherwise feels normal. Any ideas would be greatly appreciated. Don't know if it's worth getting checked out. Please excuse mess (kids' playroom).

More info:
  • 2012 Cannondale Supersix (1,400 miles)
  • Happens at the same crank position (top peak of right crank)
  • Only happens when applying lots of pressure (climbing/sprinting)
  • Ticking sound may be soft or loud
  • Changed seats and adjusted seat post - no change

.be

cny-bikeman 02-07-14 10:53 AM

The standard procedure is to first tighten both pedals and crank arms. Sounds like too low a pitch to be chainwheel bolts, too high to be in the BB - though I'll admit to very little exposure to BB30's.

If you want to be thorough remove the pedals and crank arms, clean the interface surface between pedal and crank with steel wool, then grease pedal threads, splines, and the face that the cranks fit against.

dsbrantjr 02-07-14 10:57 AM

Do the easiest thing first; remove the pedals, clean and grease the pedal and crank threads, re-install and properly tighten the pedals.

jmess 02-07-14 03:52 PM

You might also check the rear quick release. My "BB30 click" was found to be a rear quick release that didn't have enough clamping force. Greasing the rear drops and replacing the quick release with a heavier duty one made it go away. In my case the noise was transmitted by the chain stays and it sounded like it came from the BB.

Batavus 02-07-14 04:35 PM

+1 on the quick-release.

bikeman715 02-07-14 04:45 PM

+2 on the QR .

hueyhoolihan 02-07-14 04:51 PM

rollers limit troubleshooting in that coasting, standing up, etc. is difficult, if not impossible. i'd take it out, if practicable, and eliminate possibilities by coasting while simultaneously standing, which eliminate many possibilities. there are other tests that can also be made.

i've often had success isolating noises well before my ride has ended. good luck.

for example: assume you have 1 million in stock, and you lose half of it each day. you'd be surprised at how soon you will become a pauper. :)

diggy488 02-07-14 06:57 PM

Thanks for the input thus far. I know it's extremely hard to help without looking at it closer, so thanks again. Any other tips are greatly appreciated.

This has been happening on the road for several rides. The video was taken last night and it was the first time on a trainer with a different skewer, so that can be eliminated. It definitely sounds like it's around the cranks/bb area though.

Batavus 02-08-14 03:52 AM


Originally Posted by diggy488 (Post 16477321)
It definitely sounds like it's around the cranks/bb area though.

If I got a penny everytime someone came in with a noise like that and it WAS the BB or crankset I'd be a millionaire.

All creaks and pings and whatnot sound as if they come from the BB area, especially on carbon frames.

Some causes:

Loose bolt that secures the aluminum dropout to a carbon rear end on some Pinarello.

A dry/corroded bottle cage bolt

The aforementioned rear quick release

Rusted out cartridge headset bearings

Dry carbon headset spacers rubbing against eachother

This one actually in the BB: BB30 bearings mounted without grease ('But I just had the bearings replaced!')

Another one in that area: Undertightened/dry mounted crankset bolt

Chainring bolts

Seatpost dry mounted

Corroded seatpost clamp

Seat rails

Derailer hanger slightly loose and rubbing against dropout.

Broken pawl spring in freewheel body

Destroyed to the point of exploding freewheel body bearings.

This one is my favourite:

Customer comes in with an immaculately cleaned drivetrain and complains about creaking noise.

I test ride and hear this horrible metal against metal screeching sound.

Come back, lube chain and voila problem solved. The look on his face: priceless.

cny-bikeman 02-08-14 05:36 AM


Originally Posted by diggy488 (Post 16477321)
... Thanks for the input thus far. I know it's extremely hard to help without looking at it closer, so thanks again. Any other tips are greatly appreciated...

A longer list is irrelevant until you've tried the primary suggestion of grease and tighten cranks/BB, and if that does not work you needed to focus on causes that would be in response to the stress of crank revs.

diggy488 02-08-14 07:29 AM


Originally Posted by Batavus (Post 16477908)
If I got a penny everytime someone came in with a noise like that and it WAS the BB or crankset I'd be a millionaire.

All creaks and pings and whatnot sound as if they come from the BB area, especially on carbon frames.

Some causes:

Loose bolt that secures the aluminum dropout to a carbon rear end on some Pinarello.

A dry/corroded bottle cage bolt

The aforementioned rear quick release

Rusted out cartridge headset bearings

Dry carbon headset spacers rubbing against eachother

This one actually in the BB: BB30 bearings mounted without grease ('But I just had the bearings replaced!')

Another one in that area: Undertightened/dry mounted crankset bolt

Chainring bolts

Seatpost dry mounted

Corroded seatpost clamp

Seat rails

Derailer hanger slightly loose and rubbing against dropout.

Broken pawl spring in freewheel body

Destroyed to the point of exploding freewheel body bearings.

This one is my favourite:

Customer comes in with an immaculately cleaned drivetrain and complains about creaking noise.

I test ride and hear this horrible metal against metal screeching sound.

Come back, lube chain and voila problem solved. The look on his face: priceless.


Originally Posted by cny-bikeman (Post 16477954)
A longer list is irrelevant until you've tried the primary suggestion of grease and tighten cranks/BB, and if that does not work you needed to focus on causes that would be in response to the stress of crank revs.


Many thanks to you both. I will check out the mentioned items.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 05:01 AM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.