Strumey Archer FW 4 split indicator for a split personality
 

Finally got it together. When I first removed the unit the planet cage end holding the fourth gear pawls was completely choked with hardened grease and the pawl springs totally mangled. The 1945 manual says two teaspoons of oil after a rebuild and a teaspoon of oil once a year thereafter. I think someone kept putting too much grease on the bearing or started pumping in grease thru the oil filler cap to try and get 4th gear to work. Big time mistake.https://cimg9.ibsrv.net/gimg/bikefor...85ed9f020f.jpg

Only lost two more springs getting the hub together (5 all told!). These two pawls are the same for the 3 speed and are relatively easy to fit.
https://cimg8.ibsrv.net/gimg/bikefor...cfc0c66057.jpg

It is the other two giving the fourth gear that I struggled with - on the left of the planet cage in this foto. Here they are the wrong way round and I had to do it all again! Note the LHS axle end has the indicator showing fourth gear.
https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/bikefor...326c5c6bf3.jpg

The split indicator rod was something I wasn't familair with. It had a expanding compensator spring between the two that you had to compress to screw them together form either end of the assembled hub.
https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/bikefor...17f596a693.jpg

And so it was in the beginning. Interesting for me to learn something new - you fix the RHS (sprocket side) bearing cone first ( quarter turn back from finger tight) and then you do the non drive LHS. For some reason I found this counter-intuitive but there you go.

Finished article
 

https://cimg2.ibsrv.net/gimg/bikefor...5c90f117c7.jpg

Some folks do it in an hour, I take at least a day.Strumey Archer 1945 FW4 hub, 40 Stainless steel spokes, 4 Cross pattern spoke laced under the third spoke and over the forth to give more strength. 1940 stainless Raleigh 26x1 3/8 rim.

Nice post.

You're giving me the determination I need to take my parts-built FW apart again in an effort to to make it work...again.

-Kurt

Strumey Archer FW4 Manual
 

The Strumey Archer heritage site has the complete 1945 FW 4 manual on a PDF download. My pawl spring problem was solved by mounting the pawl, spring and pin into the planet cage with the right-angled catch on the outside of the offending pawl ie without tension. When just so, pull / push the right angled tab around the end of the pawl into its correct tensioning position. Crude to say the least, but I was on my 5th lost spring and desperate.

I've found this same condition in AW hubs I've serviced. I think it may just be dried up oil or maybe too heavy of an oil that gums up the pawls so they don't engage. A note about my experience with pawl springs. They are an "R" shape with a foot that bends either up or down. If the foot is bent up, (or is it down, I forget) it forces you to mount the spring under the pawl which is much harder to do than if it's on top where you can see it through the hole as you slide the pin in place. I found it easier than I thought to fashion pawl springs from a stainless steel .012 guitar string. Just needed needle nose pliers and wire cutters. An advantage is being able to bend the foot in the direction you need for on top of the pawl mounting.

Workshops that employed master wheel builders used to have an old ***** tonk piano on the shop floor to balance the tension on the wheel by matching the harmonics with the a key on the piano .

Tapping each spoke to match a certain pitch to indicate balance around the wheel and whether a customer wanted a B flat, E major or an F minot pitch matching the tension for the wheel to match their road, track, path-racing or touring requirements. I suppose a guitar inspired musical pitch for your sprung pawls striking the planet cage ring gear might be considered a bit OTT by normal people but normal folk don't repair 60 year old IGHs.