Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Classic & Vintage (https://www.bikeforums.net/classic-vintage/)
-   -   CO2 inflator. Which one? (https://www.bikeforums.net/classic-vintage/1237174-co2-inflator-one.html)

ThermionicScott 08-23-21 01:39 PM


Originally Posted by SJX426 (Post 22195913)
See that grey container with the black top? Tools, rag, 3 Co2 cartridges with head, tire levers, Expired ID, patch kit.

I'll bite: what's the expired ID for? :)

SJX426 08-23-21 01:59 PM

[MENTION=93580]Therm[/MENTION]ioniicScott - Expired DL to Identify me if I get in an accident, which has happened. I don't carry a wallet on rides.

ThermionicScott 08-23-21 02:33 PM


Originally Posted by SJX426 (Post 22197116)
[MENTION=93580]Therm[/MENTION]ioniicScott - Expired DL to Identify me if I get in an accident, which has happened. I don't carry a wallet on rides.

Good thinking, thanks. :)

rumrunn6 08-23-21 05:19 PM

https://cimg6.ibsrv.net/gimg/bikefor...9a92a58930.jpg

Genuine Innovations G2673, Air Chuck

John E 08-23-21 07:23 PM


Originally Posted by SurferRosa (Post 22195671)
In summary

Use a portable/frame pump if you ...
- dislike paying for air
- are He-Man
- can show off a sweet matching frame pump
- ride on fat tires
- stop to help the helpless
- like criticizing those who use CO2.
- care about the environment and single use throwaway containers

use a CO2 if you ...
- ride when it's hot
- are weak
- are in an age appropriate triathlon
- have no mo room
- ride 23-25mm tires
- don't flat much
- know what you're doing
- are into firearms
- need a good reason to keep riding when someone asks if you have a frame pump.

:lol:

I have tried minipumps, but I normally use a full size frame-fit pump. I have a Zefal Mtn pump on the Schwinn, a Blackburn on the UO-8, and Zefals on the other bikes.
https://cimg1.ibsrv.net/gimg/bikefor...9a2540b0b0.jpg
1973 Brooks Pro on the 1959 Capo. Still serviceable, plan to put on a different bike. Campag. crankset shown
Zefal HP-X: best frame pump ever, and size 3 fits my 55cm frames (Bianchi, Carlton, and this Capo) perfectly. The Capo Siegers and the Peugeot have downtube frame pump pegs and take a shorter pump.

davester 08-23-21 07:53 PM

Full size frame pump for me, either Silca with Campy metal head or Zefal HPX. Like Gugie, I have rescued a number of folks sitting by the side of the road when their CO2 cartridges misfired. Also useful for discouraging errant canines.

I could get a tire up to about 110 psi with one of those, but that seems pointless these days since all of my bikes are running 28 mm tires at a minimum and that is never going to change.

I'm not at all keen on CO2 cartridges, due to waste, low reliability, and the small contribution to global warming. Plus, what's yer hurry?

steelbikeguy 08-23-21 08:16 PM

as much as I feel like a Silca frame pump is the one true and pure way to put air into tires, I feel obliged to mention that racers were carrying compressed gas for inflating spare tires a long time ago.

These cylinders of compressed gas (just air, I think) were larger than modern CO2 cartridges, and the French term is "gonfleur". A search for this term pulls up various images, such as this one from Flickr..
https://live.staticflickr.com/2853/1...f1fb10_c_d.jpg
https://www.flickr.com/photos/95176013@N08/11910725105/

Gonfleur can also refer to a pump, so some confusion is possible.

I seem to recall various discussions of these in the past on bikeforums, so if someone wants to find out more, it shouldn't be too hard.

Steve in Peoria (still a Silca Impero fan)

curbtender 08-23-21 08:27 PM

https://www.thebikesmiths.com/produc...EaAopOEALw_wcB

scarlson 08-23-21 08:36 PM


Originally Posted by steelbikeguy (Post 22197718)
as much as I feel like a Silca frame pump is the one true and pure way to put air into tires, I feel obliged to mention that racers were carrying compressed gas for inflating spare tires a long time ago.

These cylinders of compressed gas (just air, I think) were larger than modern CO2 cartridges, and the French term is "gonfleur". A search for this term pulls up various images, such as this one from Flickr..
https://www.flickr.com/photos/95176013@N08/11910725105/

Gonfleur can also refer to a pump, so some confusion is possible.

I seem to recall various discussions of these in the past on bikeforums, so if someone wants to find out more, it shouldn't be too hard.

Steve in Peoria (still a Silca Impero fan)

Interesting!!
BTW, those size CO2 cartridges have been around for a while. The ones that fit the old seltzer bottles from the '60s are very similar in size and shape, although they are unthreaded. Makes me wonder if some machinist wouldn't have made some inflator back in the day for the "Sparklets" cartridge.

canklecat 08-23-21 10:18 PM

I got one of those for my Lezyne Road Caddy bag. It's the only type that would fit, along with the CO2 cartridge, tube, lever, etc. Haven't used it yet, no idea how well it works.

gugie 08-23-21 11:05 PM


Originally Posted by Drillium Dude (Post 22195877)

Again, my only issue with frame pumps is they can't come close to the psi levels I require. Oh, and the reason I run high pressures: sick of snakebite flats, I began running higher pressures and experienced a massive reduction in flats. Don't have to tell me twice...

DD

Another good reason to use CO2, can't get to 120psi
Another good reason to run much lower than 120psi.
Another good way to get away from snakebite flats: run fatter tires.
:D

Drillium Dude 08-23-21 11:12 PM

Different spokes for different folks, that's what I say :)

DD

cyccommute 08-24-21 11:03 AM


Originally Posted by ShannonM (Post 22196102)
There is not now, was not then, and will not be in the future a better device for putting air into a bicycle tire that can be carried on the bicycle than the Zefal HPx "HoundPounder" frame pump. Nothing else works anywhere near as well.

I disagree. The Zefal HPx is a good pump but it pales in comparison to the Topeak Morphs. Pushing the plunger down into the ground is far easier than trying to pump at 90° to the wheel.

gugie 08-24-21 11:03 AM


Originally Posted by Drillium Dude (Post 22197880)
Different spokes for different folks, that's what I say :)
DD

That's why I carry a large selection.

https://cimg5.ibsrv.net/gimg/bikefor...a2d31c6d21.jpg

cyccommute 08-24-21 11:09 AM

I have a couple of CO2 inflators (come in handy for night riding) and one of them is like this one. Don’t like it. The spring is stiff and you have to push on the head while the liquid flashes to gas which gets really, really cold. The Genuine Innovation Ultraflate is better insulated.

tricky 08-24-21 11:13 AM


Originally Posted by gugie (Post 22195495)
Insignificant compared to the total time removing the wheel, removing the tire, finding the source of the flat, replacing the tube, mounting the tire, then under a minute to inflate (typical for me), put the wheel back on, check the brakes...

Unless you're trying to place in your age group in a triathlon or more competitive than that, I don't see the point. I've pulled over to help out people that screwed up inflating with a CO2 cartridge maybe half a dozen times. You get one shot with a cartridge to get it right.

CO2 cartridges and bottled water, solutions in search of a problem. Air and water are free for the taking.

This, a million times this! CO2 inflators are so wasteful and you are just so much more self sufficient when you have a pump. I have a ~4" long pump that fits in my small saddle bag. I think it's a Bontrager that I bought for $5 from the co-op. I wouldn't carry it when mountain biking since it can't push much volume but it's totally fine for all emergency situations with road tires. I might get a frame pump or a slightly bigger pump now that I've converted to 650b on my primary rider.

CO2 inflators are out of the question except for MAYBE in a race where contending for the podium, but that hasn't been a consideration for me yet. :P

gugie 08-24-21 12:00 PM


Originally Posted by Spaghetti Legs (Post 22195614)
My most recent flat was at a busy intersection, 90+ degrees and humid in the direct sun.

After my experiment riding in Virginia heat and humidity, I have decided my solution to the pump problem is not to ride in Virginia when it's hot and humid.

https://cimg4.ibsrv.net/gimg/bikefor...3b0540b7f5.jpg

canklecat 08-24-21 12:38 PM

Regarding waste, I doubt cyclists use more than a tiny fraction of the CO2 used by paintball and pellet guns. When I shot pellet gun silhouettes and other targets I went through a few a day. In three years of carrying CO2 inflation kits for bikes I've never used even one. And the handful of CO2 cartridges I've seen carelessly discarded along the MUP or roadside by cyclists doesn't begin to compare to the dozens or hundreds of discarded cartridges I've seen from target shooters. Although there are relatively fewer airgunners using CO2 now, as compressed air PCP pellet guns are better overall and less temperature-sensitive.

scarlson 08-24-21 12:47 PM

Didn't it use to be, you could get cartridges of "compressed air" that was actually R12 freon? Wonder if those were ever used as tire inflators. Talk about ecocide! :twitchy:

OkFine 08-24-21 12:58 PM

I use this one.

https://www.amazon.com/Pro-Bike-Tool...xpY2s9dHJ1ZQ==


Originally Posted by SJX426 (Post 22196464)
Competition pellet guns are hand pumped.

Some competition pellet guns are hand pumped, but almost always are springers in some sort of sporter class. Single stroke pneumatic rifles aren't very prevalent. PCP reigns king. Where are you seeing hand pumped competition pellet guns? Hardly any ever at any matches I shoot across my region for sure.

ThermionicScott 08-24-21 01:13 PM


Originally Posted by gugie (Post 22198602)
After my experiment riding in Virginia heat and humidity, I have decided my solution to the pump problem is not to ride in Virginia when it's hot and humid.

https://cimg4.ibsrv.net/gimg/bikefor...3b0540b7f5.jpg

I bet a cold CO2 cartridge would have felt nice. :)

SurferRosa 08-24-21 01:36 PM


Originally Posted by Drillium Dude (Post 22195877)
My only issue with frame pumps is they can't come close to the psi levels I require.

What about size? I never see you riding with a bag big enough, and I don't really see you putting a pump in your jersey. Would you add a frame pump in your main triangle on every ride if it easily reached full inflation?

Me? I simply don't flat much. My last flat, I saw after I got home. My last flat on the road was like two years ago.

Drillium Dude 08-24-21 01:58 PM


Originally Posted by SurferRosa (Post 22198735)
What about size? I never see you riding with a bag big enough, and I don't really see you putting a pump in your jersey. Would you add a frame pump in your main triangle on every ride if it easily reached full inflation?

Me? I simply don't flat much. My last flat, I saw after I got home. My last flat on the road was like two years ago.

Size isn't an issue with me. Is it with you?

;)

Sure, I'd ad a frame-fit pump if I could find one that could give me 110-120psi.

DD

SurferRosa 08-24-21 02:10 PM


Originally Posted by Drillium Dude (Post 22198774)
Size isn't an issue with me. Is it with you?

Yes. Like you, I ride with a tiny saddle bag, which is full with my CO2 patch kit and wallet. My middle jersey pocket is spoken for (phone). My right pocket during the summer/pandemic is spoken for (bandana). It's nice to have the left pocket free for whatever.

Ex Pres 08-24-21 02:21 PM

I like my inflator that uses NON-threaded cartridges because the cartridges are cheap as chips.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:02 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.