Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Classic & Vintage (https://www.bikeforums.net/classic-vintage/)
-   -   Fender aesthetic advice needed (https://www.bikeforums.net/classic-vintage/764966-fender-aesthetic-advice-needed.html)

Velognome 09-11-11 09:36 PM

I like the tan, looks almost off white in the photo. Blumelish at first glance. Good job!

mkeller234 09-11-11 11:14 PM

+1, they look great

badger_biker 09-12-11 07:56 AM


Originally Posted by Velognome (Post 13211842)
I like the tan, looks almost off white in the photo. Blumelish at first glance. Good job!

Thanks. They were lighter in color than I was expecting but I'm glad. It looks like they may mar fairly easily since I picked up a couple very slight marks when one slipped and hit my garage floor. I think they should be fine for the use I will give then however.

badger_biker 09-12-11 07:58 AM


Originally Posted by mkeller234 (Post 13212120)
+1, they look great

Thanks! I'm almost hoping for a little shower on my upcoming trip to see how well they perform.

mkeller234 09-12-11 08:27 AM


Originally Posted by badger_biker (Post 13213059)
Thanks! I'm almost hoping for a little shower on my upcoming trip to see how well they perform.

Ha! I remember when I added some DIY mud flaps a while back, I never seemed to get rain while I was on my bike so I ran through as many puddles as I could find.

You shouldn't really get any splashing with fenders like those. The longboards look as long as fenders and mudflap I have on my bike. I do commute though rain, even heavy rain and combined with a cheapie rain cape, myself and the bottom of the bike stay very dry.

http://farm7.static.flickr.com/6077/...b8839d74_b.jpg

badger_biker 10-04-11 07:28 PM


Originally Posted by badger_biker (Post 13213059)
Thanks! I'm almost hoping for a little shower on my upcoming trip to see how well they perform.

Here is a little follow up on my first tour with the fenders.
Well I may have hoped a little too much for a shower - rain on 4 of the 5 days! The fenders worked great when it was just rain on pavement but the front especially sucked up mud like there was no tomorrow on a crushed limestone rail trail. The front got pretty clogged with leaves and mud and managed to throw it on the bags and inner wheels.
http://i114.photobucket.com/albums/n...1/IMG_2518.jpg

As a comparison here is my friends bike sans fenders...
http://i114.photobucket.com/albums/n...1/IMG_2519.jpg

mkeller234 10-04-11 10:08 PM

That has been my experience with fenders and mud too. I bet your pants were cleaner that his after that ride. I always assumed a fenders first job was to keep me clean and dry and the bike was second priority.

4 days of rain sure is a test! Do you think the mudflap is what caught most of the mud? Props to you for the muddy, loaded touring bike photo.

khatfull 10-04-11 10:52 PM

But you kept it off the drivetrain, which is my first reason to have fenders, me dry the second.

I need to ride in the rain more and quit being such a wussy :(

badger_biker 10-05-11 09:02 AM


Originally Posted by mkeller234 (Post 13320289)
That has been my experience with fenders and mud too. I bet your pants were cleaner that his after that ride. I always assumed a fenders first job was to keep me clean and dry and the bike was second priority.

4 days of rain sure is a test! Do you think the mudflap is what caught most of the mud? Props to you for the muddy, loaded touring bike photo.

Funny thing is that my legs and front bags had more mud on them than his. I couldn't figure out why unless the mud was forced out to the sides more and caught my legs.

badger_biker 10-05-11 09:05 AM


Originally Posted by khatfull (Post 13320421)
But you kept it off the drivetrain, which is my first reason to have fenders, me dry the second.

I need to ride in the rain more and quit being such a wussy :(

Keith - hopefully the upcoming Mpls C&V ride you've planned will have dry day but I'm planning on bringing this bike and riding anyway!

jamesj 10-05-11 03:23 PM

I so want to put fenders on my trek I tried velo Orange fenders but had no luck. I wonder if plastic will be easier.

photogravity 10-05-11 04:17 PM


Originally Posted by southpawboston (Post 13168804)
For a rattlecan finish, you did a fantastic job! It looks like the factory finish in those pics.

I think the SKS longboards in tan would look fine on your bike. Tan or brown bar tape may compliment them nicely. I also like the idea of the longboard version because longer coverage really makes a huge difference, IMHO.

Longboards give wonderful coverage, but they can be problematic for two reasons: 1) they are very difficult to deal with if you have to put it on the roof of the car, and 2) if you ride on dirt paths where there are lots of sticks, they WILL catch the bottom of the fender and either lock the rear wheel or rip the front stays off the fork.

For those two reasons alone I suggest the other SKS fenders. (P45 is it?)

shuffer 01-09-12 05:25 AM

Looks fantastic; quite unusual too. I don't think I've ever seen a front 'guard that low, but you're definitely keeping dry on that bike!


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 10:03 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.