Bike Forums

Bike Forums (
-   Classic & Vintage (
-   -   Best Model from the Best Brands Opinions! (

simvase 09-30-13 11:27 PM

Best Model from the Best Brands Opinions!
Hello everyone. I'm a vintage bike newbie looking for some opinions from bikers like you.
What are some of the best models from some of the "best" brand in terms of road bikes?
Like Nishiki, Univega, Miyata, Bianchi, Schwinn, Peugeot, Centurion, Raleigh, Motobecane, etc ....
What are some of the best model made by these companies? Feel free to add more to the list!
Which of these models have the best frame (i.e. Cr-Moly) and what was the year?

Is there any good website that have a list of vintage bikes that provides details and information about the bike models/years/frame materials?

Thanks for your help! :)

Kactus 10-01-13 12:21 AM

Wow... your question could take a book to answer! Every make will have different models that are "best"; a lot depends on what you want, a light weight sprint bike, road bike, touring, etc. I think the easiest thing would be to determine what frame material a particular bike has. As a general rule, better vintage bikes from the '60s, '70s and '80s will be made using Columbus SL, SLX; Reynolds 531 double butted, Tange No.1 or No.2 for the main triangle, stays and fork.

Also, different nationalities of bikes have their own "style". Italian bikes are different than French bikes, are different than British bikes, etc. For a first bike, narrow it down to a make that appeals to you and then look for the differences in their models.

eschlwc 10-01-13 01:14 AM

my favorite brand (so far) is motobecane, from '75 through '81 or so. here's a catalog link, by year:

i prefer the mid- and upper-level models with pretty cotterless cranks, on-frame derailleur hangers and down tube shifters. these three characteristics often lead to nice framesets (531 and vitus).

the bikes i've owned have just kinda come to me through luck, in the following order:

'76 moto grand record *
'73 falcon san remo *
'81 univega gran rally
'83 nishiki international
'84 club fuji
'89 miyata 312
'80 moto grand jubilé *
'80 peugeot pkn10 *

* i've kept these (so far).

they've all been a joy to own and restore, even though a few have had their idiosyncrasies.

one of these days i'll own an italian...

Zinger 10-01-13 01:36 AM

1 Attachment(s)
There were higher range bikes in Univega's line than the Gran Rally but that's the model that I had and liked it very well. Responsive bike with Shimano 600 parts and they did well......This one isn't mine but that's the color I had and I keep the photo to remind me not to sell my bikes anymore just because I build a new one.

rando_couche 10-01-13 08:07 AM

All of the names you mentioned are factory bikes. For the "best of the best", my short list is: Rene Herse custom randonneuse, Alex Singer custom randonneuse, Eisentraut custom and Eddy Merckx Corsa or Corsa Extra. Failing any of those, I suppose a DeRosa Professional would do...


jimmuller 10-01-13 08:20 AM

The best bike is the one that fits you, matches your riding style and the roads you generally encounter, and on which all the componentes work well. Really.

Or the best bike is the one that fits your budget. Are you looking to spend tens or hundreds or thousands?

Most manufacturers have produced very good bikes, or they wouldn't stay in existence very long. The question is always which model for what kind of riding and at what cost. That's why you got all the answers above. Until you can 'splain yourself and your expectations we can't help!

rootboy 10-01-13 08:23 AM

The French Connection:

Peugeot PX-10
Motobecane Le Champion
Gitane Super Corsa or Tour de France

mechanicmatt 10-01-13 01:59 PM

Lugged Trek's, basically all of them. Then like other's have said, tubing is a good way to go Reynolds, Columbus, True Temper, Tange.

orangeology 10-01-13 03:23 PM

best build quality. best price. best ride quality. best looking. best brand affinity. best reputation. best collectible. best seller. best accessibility. best overpriced. best understated. best resale value. best loved. best hated. best what else... even a book will not be sufficient, i'm afraid. :)

randyjawa 10-01-13 05:28 PM

There are, in my opinion, no best brands or best models. There is, however, poor quality and good quality. I prefer to focus on the quality level of a bicycle, rather than its name. For example...

Many people would argue that Raleigh is a great brand - I would not. Some would swear by the Bianchi, or Peugeot, or what ever, not knowing that those are, often times, mass produced cleverly marketed bicycles.

The point is this. There is no short cut to finding out what brand is better. Nor is there a short cut to learning with model is best in a brand line-up. To me, it is all about the quality of the bicycle and that is a product of caring craftsmanship applied to high quality materials - something that does not come off of an assembly line, in my opinion.

zukahn1 10-01-13 06:48 PM


Originally Posted by rootboy (Post 16120706)
The French Connection:

Peugeot PX-10
Motobecane Le Champion
Gitane Super Corsa or Tour de France

I would also add a Jeunet 640 to this list but they are bit hard to find.

simvase 10-04-13 03:32 AM

Thanks everyone for your inputs! I know it's nearly impossible to choose what's best cause everyone has a different opinion. But I'm glad to hear some inputs and new names. I will definitely check those bikes out. :)

jimmuller 10-04-13 04:03 AM


Originally Posted by simvase (Post 16130758)
I know it's nearly impossible to choose what's best cause everyone has a different opinion.

It's not because everyone has a different opinion. It's because there is no answer.

In the end the "best" bike is the one you find that works for you, regardless of the name.

mechanicmatt 10-04-13 08:39 AM

Also the "best" bike is the one that fits your body geometry, a bike can be awesome but if it doesn't fit, it won't be comfortable...

Good luck.

due ruote 10-04-13 08:48 AM

If you follow that link (from post #3 ) you can work back to the home page and see that lots of brands are listed. If you spend a bunch of time perusing the catalogs, you can figure out which models were top of the line. But, like others said, top of the line doesn't always equate with the "best" bike for a given individual. The top models often are race-oriented bikes with stiffer, more responsive frames. That's great if you race, but for spirited recreational and long distance riding, many people would rather be on something a bit more forgiving - typically the models a step or two down from the top. That said, it's also nice to own "the best." This is but one of the many reasons that one bicycle simply isn't enough. It's an empirical fact.

noglider 10-04-13 08:49 AM

"Best" is a vague word, without a context.

oddjob2 10-04-13 08:50 AM has been around since at least 2005, and although I've been a member only about 1.5 years, this very same question is asked every other month. If you know how to use google or the search engine here, you can read up on 8 years of opinions. Since your asking about C&V bikes, generally 20 years or older and pre-grifter, the list won't have changed at all.

Most vintage catalogs are available on line too.

Read up on too, a site published by Randyjawa.

IthaDan 10-04-13 09:21 PM

Usually the best bike a manufacturer makes is the one with the best parts. There are only a handful of component manufacturers, much more economical to learn those instead of memorizing every model name.

All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:57 AM.