Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Classic & Vintage (https://www.bikeforums.net/classic-vintage/)
-   -   Can we talk titanium? (https://www.bikeforums.net/classic-vintage/974084-can-we-talk-titanium.html)

KonAaron Snake 09-29-14 07:36 PM


Originally Posted by tommyblair22 (Post 17173486)
Does this make picking a group difficult? Any major compatibility issues?

Yes and no - phil wood still makes them. It does limit you if you want a latest/greatest crank, but pretty much all systems and chains work fine with older cranks, or newer square taper. There are instructions out there, easy to find, on servicing the bearings. I just have my lbs do it.

kylarr 09-29-14 08:08 PM

I rode a Merlin as my only road bike for eight years. It was amazing, they are super stable and responsive bikes. I have bombed hills at ~50 m.p.h and done 100 mile days, I never gave the bike a second thought. I would get another Tom Kellogg designed bike in a heartbeat. Especially one of those really hot Spectrum anniversary steel bikes.

The only reason I moved on is because eight years is a long time with the same bike for me and I wanted to check out vintage steel. I still have the frame and will probably never sell it, I might just want to ride it again someday.

Unfortunately I could not find any pictures of the bike built up. They must be on an old computer in my storage unit.

Here is the frame:

https://farm3.staticflickr.com/2945/...5712710c7d.jpgIMG_0700 by lelandgibson, on Flickr


I think it is from about 2000 or so because of the early campy carbon bits that were on it. I have seen other painted frames from the same era as well. They go pretty reasonably. The one thing I don't like about it is the integrated headset. Its just really hard to find parts for. you should watch for that as well as the BB.

Wildwood 09-29-14 08:12 PM


Originally Posted by KonAaron Snake (Post 17169484)
Simple - and it should be in budget - Cambridge Merlin. I'm not sure exactly what it is about these bikes, but they're my favorite production rides, hands down. My advice with ti is to stick with builders who work with ti almost exclusively, and to avoid subcontracted frames. Another option, though likely slightly higher than budget, is a Serotta legend. At your budget - it's Merlin.


Not to disagree with KA Snake, but there may be exceptions.

I have a Ti subcontracted frame from Merlin through Excel Sports in Boulder, CO. They were the USA West's largest distributor of Merlin in the 90's, and had a history of running private label frames from steel to Al to Ti models. My Macalu Cirrus is from a mixed tubeset of the early 2000s Extralight. I've never gotten a first hand story regarding the details of the Macalu line. Mine was from the years when the Merlin Mass team was transitioning production to Litespeed TN. Naturally, the seller of my frameset told the story of a frame from Mass. It has the curved seat&chainstay rear-end with thick chainstays. This model has a relatively short headtube for the 59cm size. It rides small and lightning fast with a light-weight wheelset.

I will update with pics when I can find them.

Wildwood 09-29-14 08:50 PM

3 Attachment(s)
Here is the Macalu mentioned above. If anyone knows the detailed history of the Ti Macalu line in the early 2000s, please PM me.

This has been my go-to bike as the curved chainstays allow a triple, even with relatively short cs length. It took me across WA state a few years back. Stiff frame for its' time. There was another Macalu model that was more touring oriented and whippy in the larger sizes.
http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=409104http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=409105http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=409107

On the road = Olympic Peninsula in the summer daisy season.
http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=409111
Or across WA in Hwy 20
http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=409114

agchopz 09-30-14 11:51 PM

saw a guy walking around the flee market with a vintage titanium merlin with dura ace, i asked him how much he paid, he said 90 dollars.

DVC45 10-01-14 12:01 AM


Originally Posted by agchopz (Post 17176949)
saw a guy walking around the flee market with a vintage titanium merlin with dura ace, i asked him how much he paid, he said 90 dollars.

I don't know why, but that makes me wanna cry.

KonAaron Snake 10-01-14 05:21 AM

This might be a good time to mention that people lie...especially about money.

RobbieTunes 10-01-14 05:30 AM


Originally Posted by Wildwood (Post 17173654)
Not to disagree with KA Snake, but there may be exceptions.

I have a Ti subcontracted frame from Merlin through Excel Sports in Boulder, CO. They were the USA West's largest distributor of Merlin in the 90's, and had a history of running private label frames from steel to Al to Ti models. My Macalu Cirrus is from a mixed tubeset of the early 2000s Extralight. I've never gotten a first hand story regarding the details of the Macalu line. Mine was from the years when the Merlin Mass team was transitioning production to Litespeed TN. Naturally, the seller of my frameset told the story of a frame from Mass. It has the curved seat&chainstay rear-end with thick chainstays. This model has a relatively short headtube for the 59cm size. It rides small and lightning fast with a light-weight wheelset.

I will update with pics when I can find them.

By any chance, did it have "hooded" rear dropouts and a 7 o'clock rear brake cable routing, with braze-on DT bosses?

Italuminium 10-01-14 05:33 AM


Originally Posted by KonAaron Snake (Post 17177147)
This might be a good time to mention that people lie...especially about money.

Maybe the guy let a 0 slip with is significant other within earshot :)

KonAaron Snake 10-01-14 05:42 AM


Originally Posted by Italuminium (Post 17177160)
Maybe the guy let a 0 slip with is significant other within earshot :)

:roflmao:

Wildwood 10-01-14 02:46 PM


Originally Posted by RobbieTunes (Post 17177157)
... did it have "hooded" rear dropouts and a 7 o'clock rear brake cable routing, with braze-on DT bosses?

I added 3 photos a couple of days ago to my above post.
Rear dropouts are not hooded
Rear brake cable routing is via 2 braze-ons at about 7 o'clock (left side, lower portion of top tube)
No downtube bosses. Cable routing has head tube braze-ons.

Does that add to the understanding of this frame?

IIRC from my search years ago the 2002 Extralight had similar dropouts and HT cable routing braze-ons. The HT was appropriate for an integrated headset, while my Macalu has a traditional headtube for 1 1/8 headset. The bike also came with a Real Design fork, which was a Litespeed product (i think).

Here's a link to Velospace and a 2002 Extralight - with exception of headtube, mine 'looks' similar. Same fork, too.
http://velospace.org/node/31819
By th way, I've never said my bike is an exact copy of the Extralight, just similar in many ways.

agchopz 10-01-14 11:29 PM


Originally Posted by DVC45 (Post 17176958)
I don't know why, but that makes me wanna cry.

It was seriously all i could think about for at least a week, why didnt i get to the flee market an hour sooner!!!!! it haunted me in the shower

Narhay 10-02-14 01:00 AM

I've had a mega tube Bianchi road bike and a Merlin Titanium mountain bike. I much preferred the Merlin and sold the Bianchi.

Both Craigslist steals.

FlatSix911 10-02-14 09:36 AM

Any interest in building your bike with a new Ti frame?

Frameset 3AL/2.5V Butted Titanium Frameset $999
High Modulus Carbon Fiber fork with Carbon Steerer
Save Up to 60% Off Road Titanium framesets - Motobecane Le Champion Team Ti

http://www.bikesdirect.com/products/...ameset_600.jpg

KonAaron Snake 10-02-14 10:17 AM

^^^ That is exactly the kind of ti frame I would not go near. Ti isn't something to do on a budget (unless used), if it's out of budget (and it's out of mine) I think you're best off buying used, or going with a different material. Ti frames are, in my experience, more variable in ride quality and build quality than other materials. I have ridden some truly uninspiring ti frames and I don't think many really design well with the material. Tom Kellogg has the voodoo, Serotta had the voodoo. Folks I trust say Moots, Firefly, and Hollands have the voodoo, though I haven't ridden one. A lot of really good frame makers don't - my De Rosa Primato is a much better ride than the titanio.

I look at it this way - you're really buying the builder, and some like to work in ti. Don't buy something just because it's titanium, or SLX, or 531, etc. A good builder can make a good frame with nearly any material - and a bad frame can be made with any material too. Just because it's ti doesn't make it special.

A bikes direct ti frame? No thanks.

jr59 10-02-14 10:52 AM

1 Attachment(s)
http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=409517

Originally Posted by KonAaron Snake (Post 17169697)
What's funny is that I recently passed up a Merlin at your budget because I have one. They really are exceptional bikes...it's nice to see someone as knowledgeable as nlerner...and GMG...concur. I have been disappointed with the other ti roadies I've ridden - but my Merlin sings. The Merlin isn't the lightest ti I've had (the main difference being build, not frame), but it's the most comfortable and the best handling.

Mine is nothing much to look at, but its beauty comes when it's being ridden.

http://i936.photobucket.com/albums/a.../Photo0586.jpg

I am planning on converting it over to campy 10 soon - with a cook bros. crank. Honestly - I am shocked that these aren't more desirable given how desired they were at the time and how well they hold up.

I'm pretty sure why these bikes ride so well is who designed them. Tom Kellogg is VERY well respected designer, fitter, and bike builder and painter. He is also pretty darn quick riding a bike as well. I sold my Merlin when I broke my back and it looked as if I would never ride again. I recovered and could not find the Merlin I wanted, so after looking at all the new Ti bikes being built. I called TK and had him build a Spectrum for me. VERY GLAD I DID!
http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=409517

5matt 10-02-14 11:21 AM

I ride a 2002 Colnago CT1 (CarbonFiber rear triangle and fork/Titanium main); and it is the most comfortable riding bike I've ever owned-ridden up to 214 miles in a day on it. I don't know if the production was out-sourced, but I've never had any issues with the frame.

big_heineken 10-02-14 01:07 PM

I have and Eddy Merckx titanium bike that was built by Litespeed. Here are a few pics of the bare frame. I will try to get some built up pics tonite.
http://i649.photobucket.com/albums/u...ps2acf5a92.jpg

http://i649.photobucket.com/albums/u...ps6206357d.jpg

http://i649.photobucket.com/albums/u...ps1c9eccc6.jpg

link0 10-02-14 01:34 PM

I agree, get a Merlin! It's my favorite bike.

http://www.pedalroom.com/p/2011-merl...um-14825_4.jpg



I would also look into GT (this one is not mine):

http://www.pedalroom.com/p/1998-gt-e...ium-2329_1.jpg

FlatSix911 10-02-14 07:07 PM

Funny thing, how is the OP going to build a custom Ti frame from Serotta, Moots, Firefly, or Hollands at the $1,200 price point ... :lol::roflmao2:


Originally Posted by tommyblair22 (Post 17169454)
I'm interested in buying a titanium road bike for faster rides. I've got about $1200 as my budget.
Any recommendations or words of wisdom as to preferred brands or things to keep an eye out for? Thanks in advance!


Originally Posted by KonAaron Snake (Post 17181138)
^^^ That is exactly the kind of ti frame I would not go near. Ti isn't something to do on a budget (unless used), if it's out of budget (and it's out of mine) I think you're best off buying used, or going with a different material. Ti frames are, in my experience, more variable in ride quality and build quality than other materials. I have ridden some truly uninspiring ti frames and I don't think many really design well with the material. Tom Kellogg has the voodoo, Serotta had the voodoo. Folks I trust say Moots, Firefly, and Hollands have the voodoo, though I haven't ridden one. A lot of really good frame makers don't - my De Rosa Primato is a much better ride than the titanio.

I look at it this way - you're really buying the builder, and some like to work in ti. Don't buy something just because it's titanium, or SLX, or 531, etc. A good builder can make a good frame with nearly any material - and a bad frame can be made with any material too. Just because it's ti doesn't make it special. A bikes direct ti frame? No thanks.


KonAaron Snake 10-02-14 07:10 PM


Originally Posted by FlatSix911 (Post 17182627)
Funny thing, how is the OP going to build a custom Ti frame from Serotta, Moots, Firefly, or Hollands at the $1,200 price point ... :lol::roflmao2:

Which is why everyone recommended Merlin, which you can get around that number. You might want to read the post again - I don't think you understood it.

FlatSix911 10-02-14 07:21 PM

Can you post a link to a new Merlin frameset for $1,200?

streetdude 10-02-14 07:27 PM


Originally Posted by FlatSix911 (Post 17182662)
Can you post a link to a new Merlin frameset for $1,200?

I'm not sure people were recommending he get a new one...this is C&V after all.

gomango 10-02-14 07:47 PM


Originally Posted by KonAaron Snake (Post 17169484)
Simple - and it should be in budget - Cambridge Merlin. At your budget - it's Merlin.

This set the tone for the thread. The op never asked for a recommendation for a new frameset. I inferred from the beginning he was looking for help on suitable brands in the used category, as it is C&V.

Let's not crap on the op's thread. A Bike Direct frameset may be suitable fodder for the road cycling forum, but let's keep the info stream relevant for the op.

Scooper 10-02-14 07:57 PM


Originally Posted by FlatSix911 (Post 17180997)
Any interest in building your bike with a new Ti frame?

Frameset 3AL/2.5V Butted Titanium Frameset $999
High Modulus Carbon Fiber fork with Carbon Steerer
Save Up to 60% Off Road Titanium framesets - Motobecane Le Champion Team Ti

http://www.bikesdirect.com/products/...ameset_600.jpg


Originally Posted by KonAaron Snake (Post 17181138)
^^^ That is exactly the kind of ti frame I would not go near. Ti isn't something to do on a budget (unless used), if it's out of budget (and it's out of mine) I think you're best off buying used, or going with a different material. Ti frames are, in my experience, more variable in ride quality and build quality than other materials. I have ridden some truly uninspiring ti frames and I don't think many really design well with the material. Tom Kellogg has the voodoo, Serotta had the voodoo. Folks I trust say Moots, Firefly, and Hollands have the voodoo, though I haven't ridden one. A lot of really good frame makers don't - my De Rosa Primato is a much better ride than the titanio.

I look at it this way - you're really buying the builder, and some like to work in ti. Don't buy something just because it's titanium, or SLX, or 531, etc. A good builder can make a good frame with nearly any material - and a bad frame can be made with any material too. Just because it's ti doesn't make it special.

A bikes direct ti frame? No thanks.

The BD Motobecane Le Champion titanium frames are reportedly built by ORA Engineering, Taiwan, which has a two decades long history of building quality OEM Ti frames for others. Knowing how susceptible Ti welds are to contamination and the necessity of using argon shielding gas on both sides of the weld to prevent contamination, I wouldn't have any reservations buying one of the BD frames based on ORAs experience and overwhelmingly positive reviews (very few negative ones that I could find).

While they might lack the cachet of a Moots, by most accounts they're competent and a great value.

scozim 10-02-14 08:17 PM

For C&V bikes stay away from this - mines a wall hanger because I don't want to break it

http://i104.photobucket.com/albums/m...f/IMGP3869.jpg

But definitely look at this if you can find one (I do see them on Craigslist once in awhile):

http://i104.photobucket.com/albums/m...m/IMGP6341.jpg

Tom Kellogg built, Merlin frame, fantastic finish and ride. This Spectrum is a 1989 model that probably had close to 25,000 or more miles on it before my dad passed it on to me. I would easily own another - no questions asked.

KonAaron Snake 10-02-14 08:25 PM

I'd rather have an excellent steel bike for the same money as a competent ti one. I'd rather have an excellent used ti frame than a competent new one. As far as positive reviews - people also rave about lots of other bikes I don't like. So much of this is taste.


I also suspect that what ORA calls a flagship ti bike might not be one I think of as flag ship ti. I think I read they built the old Panasonic ti frames - I did own one of those...it doesn't change my perspective.

Scooper - you are hands down one of the most knowledgeable here, but I think there's a reason that a dozen people have spoken about Serotta and Spectrum/Merlin and why not many are attesting to subcontracted ones. Tom Kellogg and Ben Serotta understood how to use ti.

Chrome Molly 10-02-14 09:22 PM

I wouldn't hesitate to buy a BD ti bike. With as many frames as BD sells, if anything about their construction were marginal you would know it.

Ti seems to have fewer variables to work with (non butted tubing, fewer grades, consistent means of joinery, etc). Even with fewer variables, if you know exactly what you want in terms of how it rides, then there may be offerings more closely suited to your wants than the moto.

gomango 10-03-14 07:29 PM

Check this thread.

Absolutely loaded.

http://www.bikeforums.net/road-cycli...titaniums.html

RobbieTunes 10-04-14 05:11 PM


Originally Posted by agchopz (Post 17180076)
it haunted me in the shower

...I have yet to think more about a bike than Sophia Loren.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:49 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.