Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Commuting (https://www.bikeforums.net/commuting/)
-   -   Dutch bicycle options?? (https://www.bikeforums.net/commuting/1006765-dutch-bicycle-options.html)

Mailman44 05-11-15 07:26 PM

Take a look at Viva cycles, sounds like they are right up your alley. I have the Viva Kilo and it is a dream to ride.

osric 05-12-15 11:13 AM


Originally Posted by mel2012 (Post 17784605)
The Breezer Uptown 8 LS meets all your criteria other than the coat guard

I'd have to disagree with this recommendation. I found the Breezer's riding position to be less than upright, and the short handlebars made it uncomfortable for me (it doesn't have the swept back handlebars of a proper Dutch bike).

The Breezer was reviewed a few years ago on the Lovely Bike blog, and I'd agree with her assessment; it looks good on paper but it doesn't really compare with a proper Dutch bike.

jade408 05-12-15 11:45 AM

My old bike had flat mtb like bars and I swapped to swept back ones. Way more comfy. If you mostly like the bike that is an easy swap.

jman0war 05-26-15 11:48 AM

Why are these new Dutch bikes so flippin expensive?

harshbarj 07-15-15 12:42 AM

My Workcycles bike came in today. Took about 30 min to assemble. I'd post a photo but it came late and it was dark then I finished. Taking a photo of a black bike at night just does not work well. The looks this bike is going to get. going to be hilarious. I'll post a photo when I get a chance to snap a good photo.

I thought my other bikes were upright. I was shocked at just how upright this bike is. Going to be a relaxing ride to work in the morning.

CrankyOne 07-15-15 05:14 AM


Originally Posted by harshbarj (Post 17980883)
My Workcycles bike came in today.

Glad assembly went well. Which did you get?

CrankyOne 07-15-15 10:22 AM


Originally Posted by mtb_addict (Post 17981535)
Does it cost an arm & leg to ship to USA?

Typically between $100 and $200. More: City Bikes | LocalMile

Avoid Flying Pigeon unless you want it as a novelty item. The parts are non-standard, somewhat low quality and new bikes are often missing some things so getting a working bike can be a challenge and fixing anything that breaks a greater challenge. As a novelty item that you don't rely on to actually work I highly recommend them though.

Matt144 07-15-15 10:37 AM

My wife ended up with a Breezer Uptown, after a couple years of testing upright bikes, and she loves it. I would definitely give it a try if there's a dealer near you.

fietsbob 07-15-15 11:11 AM


Why are these new Dutch bikes so flippin expensive?
the Netherlands has better Health Care and better wages for their factory workers than China.

I-Like-To-Bike 07-15-15 11:23 AM


Originally Posted by fietsbob (Post 17981953)
the Netherlands has better Health Care and better wages for their factory workers than China.

Do you believe that NL manufacturers' assembly labor costs vice Chinese are the major or significant reason for the "expensive" pricing of NL "type" bikes sold in North America?

fietsbob 07-15-15 11:26 AM

What does Your Math of Costs of Manufacturing Overhead calculate To be?

kickstart 07-15-15 11:44 AM


Originally Posted by CrankyOne (Post 17981764)
Typically between $100 and $200. More: City Bikes | LocalMile

Avoid Flying Pigeon unless you want it as a novelty item. The parts are non-standard, somewhat low quality and new bikes are often missing some things so getting a working bike can be a challenge and fixing anything that breaks a greater challenge. As a novelty item that you don't rely on to actually work I highly recommend them though.

It can be turned into a decent bike with some effort. Made mine into a nice a faux path racer for a fraction of the cost of a pashley govner. Its all standard size components so everything can be changed easily and inexpensively if one doesn't keep the rod brakes.

CrankyOne 07-15-15 11:46 AM


Originally Posted by jman0war (Post 17838490)
Why are these new Dutch bikes so flippin expensive?

The biggest factor has been the exchange rate though this has changed dramatically in the past few months.

Second is that the better Dutch bikes like Azor and Workcycles are generally much higher quality than cruisers or english bikes. They are designed and made to be able to withstand the elements, bike racks, and other stuff for three or five decades and to need almost no maintenance. The frames are multi powder coated, many parts are stainless, and spokes, rims, and racks are quite heavy-duty. As well, Azor and Workcycles do things like drill out and taper the spoke holes in hubs so that spokes fit properly and tight. Better bikes also often include Schwalbe Marathon tires and better handgrips (and some include a Brooks leather saddle). Dutch bikes also include as standard many things that are after-market (and don't always fit or work so well) with other bikes like dynamo's, front & rear lights, fenders, racks, spats, full chaincase, etc.

I-Like-To-Bike 07-15-15 11:47 AM


Originally Posted by fietsbob (Post 17982004)
What does Your Math of Costs of Manufacturing Overhead calculate To be?

My back of an envelope guesstimate indicates that the factory labor costs for assembly of a non-custom made bike by a major manufacture is a small if not insignificant portion of the final sales price for any $1000+ bike sold in the U.S. The Dutch labor cost "premium" is a smoke screen for charging what the relative tony US enthusiast traffic will bear.

What I don't have an estimate on is what percentage of a typical Dutch type bike sold in the U.S. was manufactured in NL or any Western country? The tires, the IGH or derailler assemblies, the chain, the tubes or what? Maybe the leather saddles, ya think?

kickstart 07-15-15 12:09 PM


Originally Posted by CrankyOne (Post 17982063)
The biggest factor has been the exchange rate though this has changed dramatically in the past few months.

Second is that the better Dutch bikes like Azor and Workcycles are generally much higher quality than cruisers or english bikes. They are designed and made to be able to withstand the elements, bike racks, and other stuff for three or five decades and to need almost no maintenance. The frames are multi powder coated, many parts are stainless, and spokes, rims, and racks are quite heavy-duty. As well, Azor and Workcycles do things like drill out and taper the spoke holes in hubs so that spokes fit properly and tight. Better bikes also often include Schwalbe Marathon tires and better handgrips (and some include a Brooks leather saddle). Dutch bikes also include as standard many things that are after-market (and don't always fit or work so well) with other bikes like dynamo's, front & rear lights, fenders, racks, spats, full chaincase, etc.

When I got my Gazelle, I was also considering a Breezer Uptown 8. To upgrade the Breezer to match the Gazelles specifications it would have ended up costing just as much.

I-Like-To-Bike 07-15-15 12:36 PM


Originally Posted by fietsbob (Post 17982004)
What does Your Math of Costs of Manufacturing Overhead calculate To be?

I already included labor overhead in my calculations. I calculate the total NL labor costs "premium" on the sales price of Dutch-type bikes sold in the U.S, (because "the Netherlands has better Health Care and better wages for their factory workers than China") to be a small fraction of the percentage attributed to U.S. distributor and retail markup.

Note that the better components (which may or may not be NL sourced) that may be found on some Dutch-type bikes are not necessarily any more labor intensive to assemble at the manufacturer than the lesser type components.

You are of course entitled to believe whatever suits your political agenda.

NormanF 07-15-15 12:40 PM

In the Netherlands, a good Opa/Omafiets bike is expensive but its also heavy, rugged and indestructible.

For people, its as valuable as a car since its considered a workhorse bicycle.

In the Low Countries, a bike takes the place of a car in every day life moreso because commuting distances tend to be short.

CrankyOne 07-15-15 12:48 PM


Originally Posted by kickstart (Post 17982119)
When I got my Gazelle, I was also considering a Breezer Uptown 8. To upgrade the Breezer to match the Gazelles specifications it would have ended up costing just as much.

Even then would you have had Dutch geometry? Heavy-duty rims, spokes, rack, etc.? Stainless nuts & bolts? nearly indestructible paint?

BTW, what mods did you make to your Pigeon?

NormanF 07-15-15 12:51 PM


Originally Posted by CrankyOne (Post 17982244)
Even then would you have had Dutch geometry? Heavy-duty rims, spokes, rack, etc.? Stainless nuts & bolts? nearly indestructible paint?

BTW, what mods did you make to your Pigeon?

If money were no object, a Dutch bike would be my dream commuter bike. They were built to make the demands of every day life easier on people wanting a car-free existence.

Darth Lefty 07-15-15 01:12 PM


Originally Posted by NormanF (Post 17982255)
If money were no object, a Dutch bike would be my dream commuter bike. They were built to make the demands of every day life easier on people wanting a car-free existence.

Easier on Dutch people, maybe. Many other places have a thing called uphill.

harshbarj 07-15-15 01:24 PM


Originally Posted by Darth Lefty (Post 17982309)
Easier on Dutch people, maybe. Many other places have a thing called uphill.

So do I, it was an easy go even up a steep hill. Omaha is one of the most hilly cities in the U.S. It's a myth dutch bikes are hard on hills. Unless you have tried a real dutch bike you really can't comment.

harshbarj 07-15-15 01:27 PM


Originally Posted by CrankyOne (Post 17981005)
Glad assembly went well. Which did you get?

The standard OPA frame bike. I wanted the Workcycles transport, but am too short for the frame. Apparently dutch people are rather tall as I am at to slightly above average height for a person of German ancestry.

harshbarj 07-15-15 01:29 PM


Originally Posted by mtb_addict (Post 17981535)
Does it cost an arm & leg to ship to USA?

Total for shipping was just under $400. Plus I had to pay $128 in tariffs. So the total was around $1600

harshbarj 07-15-15 01:34 PM


Originally Posted by jman0war (Post 17838490)
Why are these new Dutch bikes so flippin expensive?

Mostly because of shipping and tariffs. My bike cost under $1000, but shipping and tariffs boosted that to around $1600 (I bought a few extras as well). If not for the fees, I could have gotten a quality dutch bike for around $700.

kickstart 07-15-15 02:16 PM


Originally Posted by CrankyOne (Post 17982244)
Even then would you have had Dutch geometry? Heavy-duty rims, spokes, rack, etc.? Stainless nuts & bolts? nearly indestructible paint?

BTW, what mods did you make to your Pigeon?

The geometry is that of an English roadster with longer chain stays, rims, spokes, and rack are heavy duty, hardware is bad, paint is typical for inexpensive bikes.

Changed out the crank chainring and crank with a Raleigh to keep it cottered, but the bb is standard size and can take a contemporary crankset. Replaced all the hardware with stainless, new front wheel with SA dyno drum brake, replaced rear hub with SA 3 speed, alloy stem with Lutterwasser bars, vintage SA light set upgraded to LED, Wellgo pinned platform pedals, brooks B135 saddle, removed chaincase, fenders and rack. Weighs in at 31 lbs, and rides as smoothly as a fully suspended MTB. Its surprisingly quick and agile, and inspires confidence on gravel at speeds I wouldn't be comfortable with on any other bike.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:19 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.