Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Commuting (https://www.bikeforums.net/commuting/)
-   -   So I really need a decent backpack.... (https://www.bikeforums.net/commuting/1110881-so-i-really-need-decent-backpack.html)

blakcloud 06-13-17 02:08 AM


Originally Posted by specialmonkey (Post 19644423)
I bought this one not too long ago in large ...

wiggle.com | Osprey Radial 26 | Backpacks

I think you just showed me my next back pack. I have been using a PAC Messenger back and I really like it but it doesn't have protection for my laptop. The Osprey looks good in this regard.

DTG 06-13-17 02:28 AM


Originally Posted by steve-in-kville (Post 19644384)
I've used a Chrome messenger bag before. I've used a military surplus pack for many years, off and on. Hiking/hydration packs as well. I am looking for something specifically for commuting: carry my lunch to work, bring stuff home, small grocery runs, get the mail, library stuff, etc.

I am avoiding racks and bags on my SS/FG. So we can omit that option.

I welcome ideas and suggestions.

Did you ever mention a budget for said backpack? I ask because I'm a backpack connoisseur. I have so many different types. You tell me your budget and I can point you in the right direction based on what you mentioned using it for.

blue192 06-13-17 04:38 AM


Originally Posted by CliffordK (Post 19646140)
http://images.gearjunkie.com/uploads...ash-Bags-1.jpg
http://images.gearjunkie.com/uploads...ash-Bags-2.jpg

Just what I need, to carry an armoire on my back :thumb:

Are those even designed to be filled up?

Oh boy, think of how much beer you can fit into that thing.... xD

Amitoj 06-13-17 07:14 AM

I am using this currently:

https://www.rei.com/rei-garage/produ...r-cycling-pack

Got it in a clearance sale on REI. Probably that's why it is not available any more.

noglider 06-13-17 07:37 AM


Originally Posted by Amitoj (Post 19650140)
I am using this currently:

https://www.rei.com/rei-garage/produ...r-cycling-pack

Got it in a clearance sale on REI. Probably that's why it is not available any more.

Aha, that's the one I got. Thanks for jarring my memory. I've only worn it a few times now, but I like it. It is small, so it has room for less stuff than other bags, but it will be fine most of the time. If I need to carry more stuff, I can put it on the bike. My intention was to have something for when I ride my racing bike which has no provision for luggage, and I plan to keep it that way. I have a bike with a rack for when I have more than will fit in the small backpack.

Whynot1999 06-13-17 08:00 AM


Originally Posted by High Fist Shin (Post 19644550)
I have had this bag for years:

Large Commuter Backpack | Banjo Brothers

Waterproof, bombproof, replaceable inner liner and it still looks like new. If anything ever happened to it, I'd buy another one in a heartbeat but I just can't seem to wear it out.

-Shin

I have the pannier backpack and it's not what you're looking for (although it's a great backpack-sits very well above your waist, very comfortable on your back), but I second the banjo brother recommendation. They're great bags and not terribly priced either.

RifterAD 06-13-17 01:17 PM


Originally Posted by Motolegs (Post 19644835)
I'm putting in another vote for Osprey as well, in this case an Escapist 32. I ordered it online from REI after reading an article from Bicycle Times. It has tons of room, and can be cinched down when you don't need all of it. I use it for everyday commuting, and on the weekends load it up full with gear (helmet, shoes, sunscreen, snacks, ect) for roadbiking trips. Just toss it in the van and everything is right there. It comes with a waterproof hi vis cover too.

Another vote for Osprey!!!

I've got an Osprey Escapist 32 too! I absolutely love it and I use it everyday (usually only weekdays unless I'm on a trip). I have been using it for a couple years now and it is not showing any wear/tear!

I use everything (all pockets/compartments/mesh areas), but surprisingly, I don't use the external helmet holder that is built in. I usually just leave my helmet on my head if my hands are full. :p

The Osprey packs are water resistant, but some of them (like my Escapist) comes with a built-in rain cover that is hiding in a bottom pocket. If it's a major downpour and I'm on my bike, I do have to use it. When it's just a light rain (or even a heavy rain but you are just running to your car), it has never been enough to soak through.

Amitoj 06-13-17 05:22 PM


Originally Posted by noglider (Post 19650197)
Aha, that's the one I got. Thanks for jarring my memory. I've only worn it a few times now, but I like it. It is small, so it has room for less stuff than other bags, but it will be fine most of the time. If I need to carry more stuff, I can put it on the bike. My intention was to have something for when I ride my racing bike which has no provision for luggage, and I plan to keep it that way. I have a bike with a rack for when I have more than will fit in the small backpack.

No problem!
I have been using it for my commute without fail. The rides back home in 95 degrees weather do make me wish i had a bike rack though.

a1penguin 06-14-17 12:51 AM


Originally Posted by GeneO (Post 19648181)
I don't mind the sweat. I do have a shower at work though.

If you have a shorter commute, a backpack with an air system will probably make a difference. But after an hour of commuting only the socks will be dry, backpack or no backpack. My bike does not have rack mounts or I would consider a rack.

noglider 06-14-17 07:03 AM

[MENTION=167216]a1penguin[/MENTION] there are various ways to mount a rack to a frame that doesn't have provisions.

GeneO 06-14-17 07:58 AM


Originally Posted by a1penguin (Post 19652090)
If you have a shorter commute, a backpack with an air system will probably make a difference. But after an hour of commuting only the socks will be dry, backpack or no backpack. My bike does not have rack mounts or I would consider a rack.

Yeah, my commute is 30+ mi RT, so I sweat no matter what.

shinybike 06-15-17 11:11 AM

The lightest one you could get the better. I had a heavy duty one for a while and while all great, having a lighter load on the back made a huge difference

09box 06-15-17 07:15 PM

I don't commute to work on my bike but I use a backpack from Green Guru Gear for work. I've used it as a vacation bag as well.

GeneO 06-20-17 06:49 PM


Originally Posted by specialmonkey (Post 19648733)
Some packs have systems that will keep it off your back, along with ventilated straps, it can reduce the sweat factor.

The one I bought has such a system called Airspeed. I bought the pack at Wiggle (cheaper), based on the following youtube review:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uN1v4HuL3JE

The Airspeed system does seem to work. I'm much less sweaty than when I used a Crumpler pack that didn't have a suspension system.

I'm still a little sweaty after an hour commute, especially as temperatures start to rise.

My shoulders seem most affected, as that's where the pack rests, and doesn't ventilate well.

Just got one of these Radial 26. Will commute with it tomorrow. It packs nicely. Need to compare it to my mission workshop sanction. :D

spencewine 06-20-17 08:09 PM

These guys make awesome bags: https://roadrunnerbags.us/

I've got the medium roll-top with all the options and use it daily. Waterproof as well.

acidfast7 06-21-17 02:52 AM

I roll with an ARC'TERYX SPEAR 20 that I bought in Frankfurt about 6 years ago. Was about €90 but has been used every single day for work.

Did about 6000km on the bike and every other day on the subway/car/tram/boat/foot/hovercraft that I have commuted.

Very nice and hope to get a few more years out of it. There is a little wear on the corners and in the liner where I add the computer, but otherwise it should last a very long time.

https://www.google.co.uk/search?q=ar...w=1281&bih=595

specialmonkey 06-21-17 07:44 AM


Originally Posted by GeneO (Post 19666577)
Just got one of these Radial 26. Will commute with it tomorrow. It packs nicely. Need to compare it to my mission workshop sanction. :D



Congrats! I hope you like it. I find it very comfortable but still sometimes wish it could hold more, there's always the 34.

https://c1.staticflickr.com/5/4288/3...3edcc734_b.jpg

GeneO 06-21-17 09:36 AM


Originally Posted by specialmonkey (Post 19667496)
Congrats! I hope you like it. I find it very comfortable but still sometimes wish it could hold more, there's always the 34.

https://c1.staticflickr.com/5/4288/3...3edcc734_b.jpg

Plenty of capacity for me. My sanction is 2 litre. I rode in with a 14lb load today (short 12 mi in) and it was pretty comfortable. I thought the "kickstand" would be a gimmick, but it is really useful.

JagR 06-21-17 09:47 AM

Arcteryx makes some great packs. For those that wear their gear...it is that deal!

acidfast7 06-21-17 09:57 AM


Originally Posted by JagR (Post 19667783)
Arcteryx makes some great packs. For those that wear their gear...it is that deal!

I agree. The durability has shocked me. The bag has been used to carry items 5-6 days/week every week for 6-7 years and the only visible wear is that the grey text is slightly darker and it's become dirty.

I'm extremely impressed and I don't impress easy, I'm very cheap and use everything up to completion.

This bag impresses me.

One huge advantage is that the top is a roll top and thus a zipper can't break.

Very nice piece of kit.

JagR 06-21-17 10:26 AM


Originally Posted by acidfast7 (Post 19667809)
I agree. The durability has shocked me. The bag has been used to carry items 5-6 days/week every week for 6-7 years and the only visible wear is that the grey text is slightly darker and it's become dirty.

I'm extremely impressed and I don't impress easy, I'm very cheap and use everything up to completion.

This bag impresses me.

One huge advantage is that the top is a roll top and thus a zipper can't break.

Very nice piece of kit.

+1. Apologies...I overlooked your original post.

msquared22 06-21-17 10:43 AM

I actually prefer commuting with a backpack rather than panniers. I'm using an older Osprey Talon 22 that has held up really well through the years.

JagR 06-21-17 11:23 AM


Originally Posted by msquared22 (Post 19667940)
I actually prefer commuting with a backpack rather than panniers. I'm using an older Osprey Talon 22 that has held up really well through the years.

+1. The only problem I have is the amount of heat between my back and the pack = SWEAT

BikeLite 06-21-17 08:28 PM

specialmonkey, where can a person get that safety triangle to go on a backpack?

Motolegs 06-22-17 04:40 AM


Originally Posted by RifterAD (Post 19650959)
Another vote for Osprey!!!

I've got an Osprey Escapist 32 too! I absolutely love it and I use it everyday (usually only weekdays unless I'm on a trip). I have been using it for a couple years now and it is not showing any wear/tear!

I use everything (all pockets/compartments/mesh areas), but surprisingly, I don't use the external helmet holder that is built in. I usually just leave my helmet on my head if my hands are full. :p

The Osprey packs are water resistant, but some of them (like my Escapist) comes with a built-in rain cover that is hiding in a bottom pocket. If it's a major downpour and I'm on my bike, I do have to use it. When it's just a light rain (or even a heavy rain but you are just running to your car), it has never been enough to soak through.

I'm with you on the helmet clip thingy. My hands are full enough if I'm using the pack for a shopping expedition,it's just a hassle using it..

GeneO 06-22-17 06:47 AM


Originally Posted by JagR (Post 19668053)
+1. The only problem I have is the amount of heat between my back and the pack = SWEAT

The airspeed system available on select Osprey packs, like the radial series, does do a good job of eliminating sweat on the back from the pack. It has a mesh that sits against your back and a gap between the mesh and the pack where air can flow. It is very comfortable even loaded.

I too used every feature of the pack sans the helmet holder, which doubt I'll ever use.

JagR 06-22-17 07:05 AM


Originally Posted by GeneO (Post 19669700)
The airspeed system available on select Osprey packs, like the radial series, does do a good job of eliminating sweat on the back from the pack. It has a mesh that sits against your back and a gap between the mesh and the pack where air can flow. It is very comfortable even loaded.

I too used every feature of the pack sans the helmet holder, which doubt I'll ever use.

I have used packs like that in the past...doesn't work for me. Maybe I sweat more?...lol

fietsbob 06-22-17 08:02 AM

Klick Fix offers a way to put a back pack, they make, on a seat post mounted adapter for their handle bar bag mount.

so you don't have to wear it , riding. the clip is all that stays on the bike when you lock it up.

HardyWeinberg 06-22-17 09:15 AM

Another thing that's nice about the backpack vs panniers in addition to the relative lack of sweat from what is advertised (at least in a pretty arid place like PNW) is that it's a lot easier to pick up the ass end of the bike one-handed and center the rear wheel on a traffic light sensor without actually stepping off the bike.

GeneO 06-22-17 02:46 PM


Originally Posted by JagR (Post 19669732)
I have used packs like that in the past...doesn't work for me. Maybe I sweat more?...lol

Maybe lol. I am comparing it to a pack without such a system and it was a significant difference for me.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 03:39 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.