Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Commuting (https://www.bikeforums.net/commuting/)
-   -   Pedal Recomendation (https://www.bikeforums.net/commuting/1146435-pedal-recomendation.html)

noisebeam 06-15-18 10:44 AM

I used Shimano mtb pedal like m510 for a few years, but found I could pop out unexpectedly sometimes. Before that I tried dual flat/clip but found them annoying to clip in.
I switched to Time ATAC many years ago and they retain very well and super easy to clip in.
For shoes I use Shimano touring RT82 and have sneakers at work
Recessed cleat and easy to walk in.
https://cimg7.ibsrv.net/gimg/bikefor...ea0cb26360.jpg

Classtime 06-15-18 08:00 PM

Pic of your bike?
how long is your commute!
do you use the same bike on recreational (faster) rides on weekends?
it matters.

Darth Lefty 06-17-18 01:27 AM

FWIW no more metal pins for me, I have enough scars. The flat pedals that came with my new MTB have some kind of plastic feature instead but I haven't examined them closely.

daihard 06-19-18 11:01 PM


Originally Posted by PaulRivers (Post 20386284)
I personally went with flat pedals with pins and five ten shoes and stopped using clipless entirely. There's a lot of debate over whether clipless might be a hair faster, and in racing a hair is pretty important, but I'm mostly commuting and riding for fun so gaining 30 seconds won't even make up for the time I spent changing shoes (for commuting) or the just the general inconvenience.

How do you deal with the shoestrings? I've been wearing a pair of Five Ten shoes for a few months. The shoes are comfortable and work well, except I always have to tuck in the long shoestring on my right shoe so it doesn't get stuck in the chain. It's usually okay but feels uncomfortable from time to time. Is there a good trick to getting this out of your way?

Thanks.

RubeRad 06-20-18 08:37 AM

I just tuck, and have never felt uncomfortable. It would be interesting to research or invent a new shoestring knot that puts both bows (and both ends?) out to the same side. Or maybe being a different knot there wouldn't even be bows, but all loose bits out to the same side.

PaulRivers 06-20-18 08:57 AM


Originally Posted by daihard (Post 20403070)
How do you deal with the shoestrings? I've been wearing a pair of Five Ten shoes for a few months. The shoes are comfortable and work well, except I always have to tuck in the long shoestring on my right shoe so it doesn't get stuck in the chain. It's usually okay but feels uncomfortable from time to time. Is there a good trick to getting this out of your way? Thanks.

Huh, I never noticed and it just hasn't been a problem for me. I figured they made the shoestrings the right length so they can't get caught in the chain and didn't really think about it.

daihard 06-20-18 10:03 PM


Originally Posted by RubeRad (Post 20403457)
I just tuck, and have never felt uncomfortable. It would be interesting to research or invent a new shoestring knot that puts both bows (and both ends?) out to the same side. Or maybe being a different knot there wouldn't even be bows, but all loose bits out to the same side.

Thanks. It feels a bit uncomfortable when the plastic tip of the shoestring ends up between the shoes and the "bony" part of my foot, rubbing it the wrong way. I wish the Five Ten shoes came with the same type of elastic band to bind the shoestring under it that comes with some Shimano shoes.

daihard 06-20-18 10:04 PM


Originally Posted by PaulRivers (Post 20403513)
Huh, I never noticed and it just hasn't been a problem for me. I figured they made the shoestrings the right length so they can't get caught in the chain and didn't really think about it.

Thanks. For some reason, my shoestrings are extremely long. Your reply has given me an idea, though. Maybe I should replace mine with shorter ones.

LesterOfPuppets 06-20-18 10:12 PM

I keep shoes at work also.

If I worked a desk job, or other minimal standing/walking job, I'd probably just wear some casual clipless shoes all day long.

https://media.performancebike.com/im...-BRN-ANGLE.JPG

PaulRivers 06-21-18 09:18 AM


Originally Posted by LesterOfPuppets (Post 20404844)
I keep shoes at work also. If I worked a desk job, or other minimal standing/walking job, I'd probably just wear some casual clipless shoes all day long.

I work a desk job. I can't say what would work for everyone, but for me when I was using clipless I once forgot to bring my shoes and had to wear my clipless shoes around all day. By the time I got home my feet felt awful. I was just out of college at the time (younger) so I can only imagine how much worse it would be now that I'm older. I bought a 2nd pair of shoes just to leave at work because of that. At some point I tried the softer soled clipless as well but they still weren't great for walking around in and they gave me knee pain when riding (the hard soled clipless did not in the same way).

Just one persons experience, but it was pretty awful to wear clipless all day at work for me.

fietsbob 06-21-18 11:17 AM

MKS 3000R is a quality rubber block pedal that can be taken apart, cleaned, adjusted and regreased..

RubeRad 06-21-18 11:20 AM

I don't even use clipless and my 'bike' shoes are a dilapidated pair of running shoes, and I keep 'work' shoes at work full time in my locker. (They are also running shoes, but more presentable). I also keep jeans and towel at work, and bring them home for laundering occasionally. Daily I bring just a shirt, socks, and underwear. And in case I forget those, I even have emergency backup shirt and underwear at work.

Keiffith 06-21-18 09:02 PM

I was genuinely considering getting clipless, but after this thread it seams a good pair of "studded" pedals is more than enough for a commuter

RubeRad 06-22-18 08:18 AM

Definitely. Don't let the bike kit nazis boss you around.

https://www.rivbike.com/pages/the-shoes-ruse

Keiffith 06-22-18 11:17 PM


Originally Posted by RubeRad (Post 20406880)
Definitely. Don't let the bike kit nazis boss you around.

https://www.rivbike.com/pages/the-shoes-ruse

That's a great read.

Reinforced what I was thinking since I am a noob to pedal machines

RubeRad 06-25-18 08:49 AM

Clipless has its place, but that place is not as big as a lot of people think. Guess what: you also don't have to wear spandex.

1nterceptor 06-25-18 10:19 PM

I like the logic of a website that says I don't need clipless pedals to have a nice ride.
At the same time selling US$3,500 frames(yes just a frame). :)
https://www.rivbike.com/collections/framesets

RubeRad 06-26-18 08:58 AM

This is true. I was listening just last night to an interview with GP and he was saying their demographic is basically 40-50-year-olds with kids out of the house, disposable income to buy nice stuff, but they've gotten 'beyond' the notion that cycling = racing.

OutspokenCyclist | Show
#401 ? May 19, 2018

And besides, $3500 is the price for a custom frame. Prebuilt are mostly in the mid $1000's, and they're beautiful.

Keiffith 06-26-18 09:06 AM


Originally Posted by 1nterceptor (Post 20412786)
I like the logic of a website that says I don't need clipless pedals to have a nice ride.
At the same time selling US$3,500 frames(yes just a frame). :)
https://www.rivbike.com/collections/framesets


​​​​​​It isn't about expense.

Is about practicality. Regardless of what your riding style is, a frame that fits you perfectly is very practical.

mojojojo 07-05-18 06:40 AM

Forte Pedals work for me.

Khb 07-05-18 04:10 PM

Personally I like having a variety of shoe options, so I use https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B0...?ie=UTF8&psc=1 partly old school (grew up with classic clips, so already had the muscle memory....).


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 07:58 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.