Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Commuting (https://www.bikeforums.net/commuting/)
-   -   Commuting Too Dangerous? (https://www.bikeforums.net/commuting/320961-commuting-too-dangerous.html)

ActionJeans 07-15-07 09:30 AM


Originally Posted by Tickledivory
I work at the Hyundai test track in California City, CA. Its in the Mojave Desert north of Lancaster and near the town of Mojave. I could bypass the problem road, California City Blvd, on a sandy dirt road that goes in the same direction. I tried to take it with my fat-tired comfort bike, but wound up having to walk it through the sand. As it is it takes me an hour and forty minutes to get to work because of the afternoon winds. The dirt road would take longer--even with a good cross country bike.

So, my choices really are to either take the car to work and save the bike for the weekends, or give up my night shift--with its cool (but dangerous) ride and extra pay. I used to be on day shift. At least with that shift I'd miss most of the dangerous traffic as I'd be on that road between 3:00 and 3:30 for my trip home. The wind is in my favor too.

What woke me up and freeked me a little about this ride was a lady pulled her car alongside me on my trip home on friday and told me I'd be killed If I kept riding on this road. I need the input from other riders because I usually just tough my way through difficult situations. But you can't tough your way through a speeding car.

Yikes... I used to have really dangerous commute at my previous job; very close calls, getting blown off the road by CCT buses passing me at 55mph, missing me by inches... I was just lucky.

Dress like a freaking martian, is all I can say. If you ride at night, believe it or not, that's probably better for your visibility. Get an orange vest, get the brightest, nastiest rear light you can afford, get a set of HID lights for up front, put that invisible reflector tape in key areas that you think might get you the most notice (handlebars, front of your forks, back of your frame, top tube, down tube, etc).

Get reflectors also to put around your ankles, or shoes that have reflectors built in; the reason being is this; people might see your headlights, might see the reflectors, but still might be confused as to what it is for a second. With ankle reflectors, your cadence will instantly make you recognizable to other motorist as a bicycle, and hopefully take the appropriate steps.

Commuting is dangerous, no doubt about it. I tell people at work the hardest part about getting used to commuting by bike is being comfortable, and therefore predictable, around heavy, tight, fast moving traffic. I think your situation can be overcome with a copious amount of lighting/reflecting.

Raiyn 07-16-07 12:24 PM


Originally Posted by donnamb
In the end, you may make the personal choice to stop bike commuting, and if so, no one would blame you. However, I'm wondering if you've equipped yourself with the standard active and passive lighting/visibility equipment. Are you riding with one of those (admittedly dorky) ANSI orange/yellow vests or bought road worker shirts to wear on the commute? Do you have a super-duper lighting set-up that increases your visibility even in the daylight? Do you have the high-visibility truck tape on key locations of your bike?

I know there are some members who regularly post here who have some pretty dangerous/hair-raising stretches on their commute routes. I'm hoping they will find this thread and share their experiences with you.

Since Donna asked me to throw my two cents in here. Here's a couple of examples of what reflective tape can add to a bike.

These are pictures of what I call the "Stealth Reflector" concept. For more information please visit this thread or click the pics
http://img156.imageshack.us/img156/6...conceptnv0.jpg
http://img339.imageshack.us/img339/7...conceptjk4.jpg
Basically the idea behind the "Stealth Reflector" is to use the same color (or reasonably close) tape as the frame so that it blends during the day, yet provides reflective properties at night.
http://img227.imageshack.us/img227/8...flectordg9.gif

Please keep in mind that reflectors or reflective tape is no substitute for lights and are to be viewed and used as supplements to a lighting system not in place of one. I also have a link to most of the bicycle laws in the 50 States and Canada in that thread.

I was asked to provide these pics so you can get an idea what reflective tape would add to your visibility issue. Using High Visibility Reflexite Prismatic striping
http://us.st11.yimg.com/us.st.yimg.c...re_1945_185513
would work even better than what I've shown, but wouldn't give you the same "Stealth" effect that I was after.

truman 07-16-07 01:02 PM

Before I started riding my bike, I took the commuter rail to a station near my office. From there I boarded a crowded van for a 13 minute roundabout stop and go ride before the thing would drop me at my office <two miles away from the station. Once i started riding, I never looked back.


This morning, I rode past the commuter van at the end of the block from my office. There were two firetrucks, an ambulance and multiple PD cars on scene & it looked as if the van had been t-boned by a fast-moving Dodge Ram (appropriately enough) pickup truck.

Glad I was riding today at least— but yeah, your commute DOES sound like punishment for a crime you didn't commit.

littlewaywelt 07-16-07 01:21 PM

Find an alternate. If someone hits you at that speed there won't be any question as to the probable outcome. Bike commuting isn't worth dying over.

acroy 07-16-07 02:39 PM


Originally Posted by Tickledivory
Have you ever had to deal with traffic that was so dangerous you gave up bicycle commuting and went back to driving?. Part of my 18 mile trip to work involves 10 miles of two lane road rated at 55 MPH. Few people drive under 65 MPH and there is no paved shoulder to ride on.

I ride with the flow of traffic and don't even mind the people whizzing by so much. They usually give me a lot of room when they pass. The problem is the oncoming traffic. These people are going to work when I'm going home, and they use my lane as a passing lane. Every day I have to get off the road to allow these people to pass each other with out nailing me head on.

The road is straight and I should be very visible. But its still dangerous. Are any of you so gung ho that you let nothing stop you?

I had that same thought this am - my ride might not be as dangerous as yours sounds but it's in a town where cyclists are rare and drivers are unsure how to deal with them, and often belligerant. I have a wife and child and can easily afford to drive the 12 mile r/t. what is "right" thing to do?? :(

acroy 07-16-07 02:40 PM

Hey Raiyn, nice washer :):)

Denny Koll 07-16-07 02:49 PM

I would not do it. Just not worth the risk. I'd think about relocating or getting a new job that would provide a better commute.

Raiyn 07-16-07 02:52 PM


Originally Posted by acroy
Hey Raiyn, nice washer :):)

That's the dryer.

Kumicho 07-16-07 03:46 PM

brightest HID mounted to the handlebars? if cars think that you're another car (moto?) they'll be less likely to come over... those HIDs are *bright*.

shortbus901 07-17-07 08:27 AM

I have bad sections of road around here too though the speed limit is only 45 (55 effective :rolleyes:). No shoulder (even the white line is eroded away in some places), no bike lanes and many of the vehicles on them are jacked up wannabe monster trucks & SUVs that take up most of what lane there is. I tried the ride a few times and realized that I want to be around to enjoy the environment I'm trying to preserve so I'm back to driving. Someone else said it best, it's all about the acceptable level of risk.

knobster 07-17-07 09:42 AM

Where is this road in relation to your route? If it's in the beginning or the end, how about driving that part and biking the rest? I do that on my commute. I don't like riding through the city and I work in the next town, so I drive just outside the city and stage at a park and ride from there. Might work in your situation.

sam21fire 07-17-07 11:52 PM

Hey, Tickle, I know where you're at (I work at a FD East of Barstow), and other than taking some of the dirt trails/roads out there I doubt there's any alternatives unless you can drive part way and ride the rest. The drivers out in that part of the desert are insane! Good luck!
Sam

sam21fire 07-17-07 11:56 PM

Raiyn- is that dryer a sidecar mount or do you tow it in a trailor? I'm thinking that with the added visibility of carrying it along with you it might make Tickle's ride a little safer....

Sam

Raiyn 07-18-07 02:34 PM


Originally Posted by sam21fire (Post 4875768)
Raiyn- is that dryer a sidecar mount or do you tow it in a trailor? I'm thinking that with the added visibility of carrying it along with you it might make Tickle's ride a little safer....

Sam

http://img196.echo.cx/img196/2974/354crackpipe5oy.jpg

Raleighroader 07-18-07 04:49 PM

Too risky
 
Some bicycle commutes just aren't worth the risk, and this sound like one of those.

I have commuted for five years, and used to accept some of those kinds of risks, but I was foolish to do so. After a couple of cycle commuters were killed here in those kinds of conditions, I reevaluated, and came up with a different route. However, I was fortunate that I had a different route available.

In most cities, you cannot always safely commute from point A to point B. That has to be accepted.

If an arterial road (as opposed to a residential street) has two lanes and no shoulder, or is four lanes with no shoulder and a lot of traffic, I consider that too risky for a bicycle commute. My rule of thumb is, "can traffic smoothly slide past me without the drivers having to take evasive action, or is my presence going to force drivers to alter their behavior a lot, such as slowing down to my speed, or changing lanes? If it is the latter, I know that eventually I will get hit by a driver who is too distracted on a cell phone to notice me.

Even if you have only a marginally dangerous situation in broad daylight, the situation is even dicier if it is dark or if it is raining. Drivers tend to not see as much when their windshield wipers are going.

LittleBigMan 07-18-07 07:08 PM

You have to call 'em as you seem 'em. It's your neck out there.

My situation is very different. I don't use a lot of bike lanes and such, but I don't really need them either.

I'm not sure how I'd handle those high-speed two-lane rural highways. It's not in my experience handbook.

Is it possible to avoid oncoming passers by going off-road for a moment, until they pass? Does "super-lighting" seem like an option? What about rigging an independent, high-power yellow strobe on the front, and switch it on when someone's headed your way? Give them something more to think about.

workingbike 07-18-07 07:37 PM


Originally Posted by Cyclaholic (Post 4856188)
Why does a POS builder like Hyundai even bother with a test track? :rolleyes:

Driven one lately? Did you here what Toyota said? "We're not watching Honda, the ones to watch are Hyundai."

Sorry about your commute, the only suggestion I have is automatic Phaser Cannons. :p

Allister 07-19-07 02:42 AM


Originally Posted by Tickledivory (Post 4855243)
What woke me up and freeked me a little about this ride was a lady pulled her car alongside me on my trip home on friday and told me I'd be killed If I kept riding on this road.

To which the correct response is: "Well you'd better drive carefully then."

From your description of that road, I'd look for another job. I've quit/declined jobs because I didn't like the bike commute, and not even because they were dangerous.

That said...


Originally Posted by Raleighroader (Post 4880703)
In most cities, you cannot always safely commute from point A to point B. That has to be accepted.

No it doesn't. There's absolutely no reason any particular route can't be cycled safely. It may require changes to driver attitudes, road configuration, law enforcement, or all of the above, but the idea of cyclists being scared off the road is deeply offensive to me. The only thing that 'has to be accepted' is how hard you're prepared to fight the battle.

Roads aren't dangerous, only the people using them are. If a road design is such that it 'encourages' dangerous driving practice, it's up to everyone to resist their impatient urges and drive with everyone's safety in mind. It staggers me that drivers don't get this. Why is it in this day and age of obsessing over safety, that driving gets a free pass?

ragboy 07-19-07 01:03 PM

This is a no-brainer: Screw the reflective tape and lighting -- don't bike commute in your present situation.

evblazer 07-19-07 01:19 PM

Unfortunately unless you can change your hours or get a nice flying bicycle like they had on Futurama I'd cave and say MaxiScooter or drive it in unless your fortunate like some to pick your jobs as you wish. At least you’ll have to do that until you get all the government departments and road users to change. Adjusting the transportation facilities, their attitude and enforcement.
I hit the same wall this weekend. My wife and I tried to go to the Doggie Park to check it out. It was about 10 miles away along route 1830 here in North Texas. We'd just moved here recently so what did we know.

Argh.. The first 500ft were ok but then it's 2 lanes with a 60mph speed limit, blind corners, rolling blind hills with barely enough road for vehicle traffic and lots of dangerous road/bridge interfaces. We made the ride hoping it would get better around the next bend but overall it was horrible. The dog park is nice and unless we take the interstate the only other road is under a foot or so of water.
The ride back was probably worse because we knew it didn't get better. Mind you this was on a Sunday afternoon so traffic wasn't very busy. I imagine during rush hour it would be completely impassable. :(

Raleighroader 07-19-07 02:12 PM

Acceptance?
 
Originally Posted by Raleighroader In most cities, you cannot always safely commute from point A to point B. That has to be accepted.

No it doesn't. There's absolutely no reason any particular route can't be cycled safely. It may require changes to driver attitudes, road configuration, law enforcement, or all of the above, but the idea of cyclists being scared off the road is deeply offensive to me. The only thing that 'has to be accepted' is how hard you're prepared to fight the battle.

Roads aren't dangerous, only the people using them are. If a road design is such that it 'encourages' dangerous driving practice, it's up to everyone to resist their impatient urges and drive with everyone's safety in mind. It staggers me that drivers don't get this. Why is it in this day and age of obsessing over safety, that driving gets a free pass?


Well sure, it doesn't need to be accepted in the long run, as you work to change the roads, drivers' attitudes, etc. I just meant that for now, for a potential ride to work tomorrow or next week, there are some routes in every city that are just too dangerous to cycle.

I subscribe to the laws of probability. If you commute 100 days a year, for ten years, that is 1,000 round trips, all during rush hour. A "dangerous" route may still be safe enough to survive one year of commuting without getting hit, maybe even two or three. But ten years? That's why I say that any route that requires drivers to do something special to avoid you, is a route where eventually a driver will fail to do that.

The route described to start this thread sure did not sound like one where you could count on surviving 1,000 round trips on a bike.

biknbrian 07-19-07 07:22 PM

I'm fourtunate to have a 4 mile one way back road commute with almost no traffic. People wave and I'm kind of known as "that guy on the bike." However, the novelty of being a cyclist translates into an unexpected rarity on the fast, no shoulder two lanes when I'm out for a longer ride. What I see happen is that people don't even hesitate to pass me. They never look ahead, or slow down at all. I'm convinced that one day an oncoming car is going to force one of them back into their lane and right into me.

I do wear a helmet longer rides (not commuting). I try to wear bright colors and I'll even put lights on any bike I ride after dark. I'm not going to start putting reflective tape and lights on my road bike all the time.

I know that I have a good chance of being hit if I continue to ride for a long period of time. I accept this and hope that if it does happen I won't get hurt that badly and I'll get to buy a new bike. Infact I joke that if I get killed before I can complete a Century I want someone to put my ashes in a water botle and ride one with me on board.

I'd also like to think that my being out on the road is making people more aware of bikes in general. Perhaps I've even convinced some people of what I now realize. Most of the places a person needs to go, you can get to by bike.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:24 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.