Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Commuting (https://www.bikeforums.net/commuting/)
-   -   The Safety of Commuting.... (https://www.bikeforums.net/commuting/399791-safety-commuting.html)

ItsJustMe 03-24-08 05:55 AM


Originally Posted by JoeyBike (Post 6392165)
I don't have a link for you, but the equivalent of 10 Boeing 747 jets full to capacity die on US highways ever single day in auto crashes. Seems high to me and I may stand corrected. Google for yourself.[/URL]

The well known figure is something like 45000 deaths per year in the US. Divide by 365 to get 124 deaths per day. If you look at individual days, it's likely that some weekdays, or holidays, might have 3 747s full. I don't know if I've ever even seen a 747, so I'm off googling...416 passengers in the minimum configuration, so that's around 4160 people. Nope, no way it's that many even on something like new year's day. I'd be surprised if even one 747 full died in the US on any given day.

That could be close worldwide. Looks like the worldwide road fatality number is in the range of 1.17 million. That's 3200 a day. That's at least within spitting distance.

anielsen 03-24-08 06:32 AM


Originally Posted by cyccommute (Post 6384575)
Here's a nice graphic that illustrates how poorly people gauge risk

http://www.clinicalanswers.nhs.uk/re...munication.GIF

This is a really nicely designed chart. It's very visually appealing Do you have a link to the article in which is appeared?

macteacher 03-24-08 07:02 AM


Originally Posted by tsl (Post 6387848)
There's no rational, intellectual way to respond to people who send you bike crash links.

So I retaliate in kind.

Every time there's a car crash--especially if it's an SUV rollover (We've had at least one a week of those lately)--I retaliate by sending the link to the article to the person trying to get me off my bike. After a few of those, they quit hassling me.

Here's one from today's Star. Not the best example since there's a question of speed and intoxication, but you get the idea. I can't figure out why The Star makes you pay for any article other than today's paper...

Just took your advice and forwarded him the link, advising him not to drive as that might happen. lol
I figure i can find more car accident links articles than he can bike ones... lol

treebound 03-24-08 07:25 AM

A life lived in fear is not a life lived. Be aware and be safe but also be bold in what you do.

On my drive in the car I commute on a roadway, divided highway, where there have been regular vehicle crossovers resulting in head-on collisions. The state then put in a cable barrier, but the vehicle crossovers continue with some cars managing to get past the cables and still getting to the other side. There is little to nothing I can do about it apart from avoiding that portion of freeway while in my car. So instead I just continue to use that roadway.

I can't control what other people do. I also ride motorcycles and have had people nearly hit me in broad daylight in plain sight while I was right in front of their face but their mind was focused on something else. Real interesting to be able to actually see them "wake up" when they come to realize that something just magically appeared into their consciousness (sp?). And there ain't a dang thing you can really do about it.

I've nearly been hit while walking in a crosswalk crossing a street with the light, or have had cars buzz me close enough that I could bang their fender with my fist. There ain't a dang thing you can do to prevent an aggressing impatient driver from acting rudely or irresponsibly.

I just picked up a copy of the book "Bicycling and the law" (ISBN-13: 978-1-931382-99-1) which looks to be a good book. The book won't do a thing to help me control what other people do, but will give me some additional tools and perspectives relative to the various situations I will encounter as my bicycle commuting and riding pics up once the weather breaks here.

You do what you gotta do, nothing is 100% safe, don't be stupid, but also don't live in fear. The more of us that ride, the more awareness that the car driving public will be forced to have. Ride responsibly and hope that the drivers drive responsibly as well. And then invite the co-worker on a bicycle ride and suggest that they look into cycle commuting as well.

Bdaisies 03-24-08 07:51 AM


Originally Posted by wild animals (Post 6386378)
hey, did you ever see the movie 28 days later? that guy got in a bike accident, and he lived, but everyone else turned into zombies while he was in a coma. i don't think your friend is taking that into consideration.

Exactly!

colo. 3spd man 03-24-08 07:56 AM

Who was it that said ( Life is a sexually transmitted fatal disease.) :D So enjoy the inevitable.

mci021 03-24-08 09:13 AM

Well, yes, your friend is right. Logically, there is a higher risk to riding on busier streets. But you could just as easily not see debris on a bike path, hit it, go flying over your handle bars and break your neck slamming into a tree. I'd venture to say that in any riding situation, the more you pay attention to your surroundings, the safer you'll be.
It's true, drivers don't see things unless they're huge and have flashing lights. Even then, they miss a lot. But if you're smaller, lighter and more manuverable and paying attention, you could most likely get yourself out of trouble without much if any damage. Accidents happen. It's a part of life. But they shouldn't stop you from living your life.

timmhaan 03-24-08 09:22 AM

everyone's greatest fear is other drivers. at least we all have that in common.

harleyfrog 03-24-08 10:23 AM


Originally Posted by wild animals (Post 6386378)
hey, did you ever see the movie 28 days later? that guy got in a bike accident, and he lived, but everyone else turned into zombies while he was in a coma. i don't think your friend is taking that into consideration.

That's why you should always pack a Zombie Defense Kit with you.

cyccommute 03-24-08 11:55 AM


Originally Posted by anielsen (Post 6393610)
This is a really nicely designed chart. It's very visually appealing Do you have a link to the article in which is appeared?

I linked to it in another post on this thread.

ragboy 03-24-08 08:24 PM


Originally Posted by motor (Post 6383718)
you run the risk of getting hit by a horrible or drunk driver just walking down the street on the sidewalk.

that doesn't mean we should never go out for a walk.

http://moronland.net/media/pictures/pic1784.jpg

lemme guess -- the ****** didn't want to walk down the stairs?

ghettocruiser 03-24-08 08:33 PM

It's often said that "anti-motoring cyclists" smear the reputation of drivers by exaggerating the lawlessness and risks on the road.

But as the OP suggests, I have found it is other drivers, through paranoid ramblings such as that one, who have the lowest opinions of their fellow motorists.

AlmostTrick 03-24-08 09:07 PM


Originally Posted by timmhaan (Post 6394341)
everyone's greatest fear is other drivers.

After zombies of course. Can zombies balance on a bike? If so they'd be a lot faster I bet.

cristina 03-24-08 10:01 PM

i find it a bummer when my coworkers try to point out how unsafe it is to ride to work like i do - total buzzkill. i am usually the most aware and awake person out there! if only they knew how happy it makes me... thankfully i am very stubborn and refuse to give up the things i love doing based on other people's ******** opinions of what they think is safe.

Allister 03-24-08 10:42 PM


Originally Posted by macteacher (Post 6383286)
How do you guys respond to comments like these?

"I'm not dead yet."

charly17201 03-25-08 08:39 AM


Originally Posted by chephy (Post 6386184)
On a somewhat unrelated note... it's another truck! The last five or six of Toronto's cycling fatalities involved trucks as I recall, and here is a pretty-close-to-fatal accident again. This definitely has some statistical significance, especially given that there are far fewer trucks on the roads than other vehicles. If you want to increase your safety on the road, be especially vigilant when trucks are around.

I'm sorry, but I have to disagree with this uninformed statement. And yes, I am a truck driver.

What you fail to consider is the massive number of miles a truck travels in a year in comparison with a car. Average for most truckers is 100-130k miles per year. When you compare average mileage vs. accidents, trucks are MUCH safer than cars. Just when we crash..... it is very serious.

Licensing for driving a truck is much more stringent.

You MUST pass a physical examination a minimum of once every 2 years to ensure that you are physically capable of driving (with special emphasis on high blood pressure and diabetes). Injury or sick and have to take drugs that can impare you - you have to be cleared by a doctor to drive afterwards. Other than being able to see - what other physical does a car driver have to do? And then only once every 3-6 years when they renew their license.

You are limited by LAW how much you can drive/work. Get a part time job? That counts against your time too.

You are subject to random drug and alcohol testing just for driving. If you are involved in an accident and any vehicle has to be towed - you must take a drug/alcohol test. Have an accident or get a ticket in your car and it counts against your truck driving record.

Besides, the DOTs are always pulling trucks in and inspecting them and issuing tickets/fines if anything is wrong with the vehicle or driver or paperwork. DOT can and WILL shut down a truck or driver. Cars only get inspected once a year - or less depending on where you live.

ItsJustMe 03-25-08 09:39 AM

I'd take issue on him saying you're risking your life for "no logical reason" - Enjoying your life and the world instead of hiding in a metal cage is a damn good reason. He will not see this because he's acclimated to living in a cage and thinks it's "normal."

ItsJustMe 03-25-08 09:41 AM


Originally Posted by charly17201 (Post 6400506)
Cars only get inspected once a year - or less depending on where you live.

Inspected? I live in Michigan. Anything that can still move and I can duct tape a license plate to can be taken on the road. Nobody official has EVER looked at any of my cars.

Personally, I wish they would inspect. There are some real crapboxes on the road here, spewing some vile crud. I'd LOVE to see them off the road.

ghettocruiser 03-25-08 08:15 PM


Originally Posted by charly17201 (Post 6400506)
I'm sorry, but I have to disagree with this uninformed statement. And yes, I am a truck driver.

What you fail to consider is the massive number of miles a truck travels in a year in comparison with a car. Average for most truckers is 100-130k miles per year. When you compare average mileage vs. accidents, trucks are MUCH safer than cars. Just when we crash..... it is very serious.

Licensing for driving a truck is much more stringent.

You MUST pass a physical examination a minimum of once every 2 years to ensure that you are physically capable of driving (with special emphasis on high blood pressure and diabetes). Injury or sick and have to take drugs that can impare you - you have to be cleared by a doctor to drive afterwards. Other than being able to see - what other physical does a car driver have to do? And then only once every 3-6 years when they renew their license.

You are limited by LAW how much you can drive/work. Get a part time job? That counts against your time too.

You are subject to random drug and alcohol testing just for driving. If you are involved in an accident and any vehicle has to be towed - you must take a drug/alcohol test. Have an accident or get a ticket in your car and it counts against your truck driving record.

Besides, the DOTs are always pulling trucks in and inspecting them and issuing tickets/fines if anything is wrong with the vehicle or driver or paperwork. DOT can and WILL shut down a truck or driver. Cars only get inspected once a year - or less depending on where you live.

Uninformed?

Inform me of this: What does the licensing requirements for tractor-trailers in Pennsylvania have to do with cube trucks in Toronto?

There is no special licensing required for cube trucks in Ontario. I used to drive one. Anyone can go rent one.

They are one of the worst-driven vehicles on the road... two years ago I had one brush past me, and when I told the driver not to get so close (without gestures or profanity) he chased me through a subdivision for five minutes in a fit of rage (with gestures and profanity).

Unsurprisingly, these trucks are heavily over-represented in cyclist fatalities in Toronto. I regard them accordingly.

crhilton 03-25-08 08:40 PM

You're probably more likely to die on the way to work on your bike than in your car, assuming all city roads (nothing greater than 40mph). But it's a small risk. Your odds of dying on a bike ride are still very low.

You'd probably be better off cutting much more dangerous activities like: bars, smoking, eating out, tennis, swimming. I mention "eating out" because it's very unlikely you'll eat healthy food when you do, and well heart disease is still the number one killer isn't it? Bars because they're a good place to get in a fight, and smoking for obvious reasons. Tennis, for some reason, a lot of people die playing tennis (I'm not sure why). And swimming is actually a somewhat dangerous form of exercise.

Drivers are very unlikely to be in a you or them situation. The speed of traffic on arterial roads doesn't often present a threat of death in a reasonably constructed car. Still, it's more likely most drivers would choose to endanger themselves over a cyclist. Not that they like us, but in that instant no thought will pass through their head. They'll be on pure instinct, and you'll be the most obvious thing on the road to not hit because you're the oddest thing on the road. Just like a driver swerving into a semi to miss a dog.

I ride arterial roads for part of my commute. I must admit I'm a lot braver in traffic than I used to be, but really it's not that horribly dangerous. Just don't get too reliant on being "lit up like a Christmas tree" because the driver who can't see you still won't see you. Don't feel hurt though, he wouldn't have seen a semi truck.

cooker 03-25-08 08:41 PM


Originally Posted by charly17201 (Post 6400506)
I'm sorry, but I have to disagree with this uninformed statement. And yes, I am a truck driver.

Professional truck drivers are among the best drivers on the road. But the design of a truck still makes it dangerous to cyclists. Obviously it is bigger and harder to avoid. It has more blind spots. You can't flop onto its hood. Worst of all, and this is how many cyclists have died, as it turns right, the rear wheels cut inside the front wheel tracks, sweeping any parallel cyclists under the side of the truck and under the rear wheels. The excellent driving skills of many truckers may prevent many accidents, but the design of the truck can cause them.

In Europe many large trucks have baffles between the front and rear wheels to stop cyclists or pedestrians being caught in the gap.

crhilton 03-25-08 09:00 PM

Ken Kifer's page on this is great. It's a ton of information, some of which he admits isn't very conclusive. But he basically just says: It's pretty much about as dangerous as everything else, but it won't give you clogged arteries or a bad mood.
http://www.kenkifer.com/bikepages/health/risks.htm

Unfortunately, Mr. Kifer was killed by a drunk driver 5 years ago while on his bike.

ghettocruiser 03-25-08 09:47 PM


Originally Posted by cooker (Post 6404826)
In Europe many large trucks have baffles between the front and rear wheels to stop cyclists or pedestrians being caught in the gap.

In China, all large and medium trucks are required to have sideguards. Makes me laugh when the industry here says it is "too expensive to implement".

chephy 03-26-08 07:30 AM


Originally Posted by charly17201 (Post 6400506)
I'm sorry, but I have to disagree with this uninformed statement.

Hardly uninformed. I do have the stats. And I wonder why the City of Toronto is paying such special attention to dealing with large vehicles on the road. :rolleyes: The greatest majority of Toronto cycling fatalities in recent years were due to collisions with trucks. That's a cold hard fact that's impossible to deny.


What you fail to consider is the massive number of miles a truck travels in a year in comparison with a car.
Umm... in central Toronto?.. Doubt it somehow. When I look on a busy Toronto road, cars far outnumber trucks. I don't care if those trucks dominate on a superhighway - that's not where cyclists ride.

Look, my statement was not criticizing the abilities of truck drivers per se, and I am not sure why you took it as such. It was a mere statement that a cyclist in Toronto is more likely to be killed by a truck than by something else. In part that's because trucks are just bigger, and some cyclists don't ride around them with enough respect (failing to consider blind spots, crunch spots etc.) It's also that when a collision with a truck does occur, regardless of who's at fault, the results tend to be more serious than colliding with a car. It's also that SOME truck drivers (and I am counting smaller trucks here like, say, UHaul trucks for which you don't need any addicional licensing) are driven by people who aren't used to driving that type of vehicle or people who drive particularly aggressively (which tends to be even more dangerous than aggressive car drivers, because of a truck's larger size).

timmhaan 03-26-08 08:11 AM


Originally Posted by cooker (Post 6404826)
Professional truck drivers are among the best drivers on the road. But the design of a truck still makes it dangerous to cyclists. Obviously it is bigger and harder to avoid. It has more blind spots. You can't flop onto its hood. Worst of all, and this is how many cyclists have died, as it turns right, the rear wheels cut inside the front wheel tracks, sweeping any parallel cyclists under the side of the truck and under the rear wheels. The excellent driving skills of many truckers may prevent many accidents, but the design of the truck can cause them.

In Europe many large trucks have baffles between the front and rear wheels to stop cyclists or pedestrians being caught in the gap.

yeah, the thing about trucks are that they can actually kill people and the driver sometimes has no idea what happened, despite the fact that he\she may be driving safely. this has happened many times in NYC both with cyclists and pedestrians.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 03:36 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.