Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Commuting (https://www.bikeforums.net/commuting/)
-   -   Fingerless gloves - why? (https://www.bikeforums.net/commuting/421379-fingerless-gloves-why.html)

I-Like-To-Bike 05-23-08 09:42 AM


Originally Posted by Old Dirt Hill (Post 6747493)
Having hamburger for palms really isn't much fun. Seems like the only times I ever go down are those times when I decided not to wear gloves that day.

So for me, gloves seem to help with my balance for some unknown reason. ;)

Training wheels would offer superior protection from boo-boos and not just for your hands.

Do you also wear a mouth guard, knee and elbow pads, steel toed shoes? Gotta protect those body parts, JUST IN CASE! Eh? Or why not full body armor; wouldn't it offer increased protection from nasty boo-boos?

Old Dirt Hill 05-23-08 09:48 AM


Originally Posted by I-Like-To-Bike (Post 6747556)
Training wheels would offer superior protection from boo-boos and not just for your hands.

Do you also wear a mouth guard, knee and elbow pads, steel toed shoes? Gotta protect those body parts, JUST IN CASE! Eh? Or why not full body armor; wouldn't it offer increased protection from nasty boo-boos?

Well, here's a picture of me before my commute in this morning. After all, you can never be too prepared. :D

http://www.fresno6.com/Air%20conditi...%20(Large).jpg

tarwheel 05-23-08 09:51 AM

pix
 

Originally Posted by Old Dirt Hill (Post 6747601)
Well, here's a picture of me before my commute in this morning. After all, you can never be too prepared. :D

http://www.fresno6.com/Air%20conditi...%20(Large).jpg


Where are your gloves?

dalmore 05-23-08 09:58 AM


Originally Posted by tarwheel (Post 6747616)
Where are your gloves?

Today is a fall day - he didn't wear them. ;)

TXChick 05-23-08 10:11 AM

They keep me from getting blisters on my hands.

(And I get those cool tan marks from the hole on top.)

Tabor 05-23-08 10:22 AM


Originally Posted by SirGrant (Post 6745952)
My friend ate it on his unicycle. He had some road rash all over but was wearing gloves. The gloves got all torn up but his hands were ok. If he hadn't been wearing them it would have just been another wound and he wouldn't be able to type (he is a engineer/programmer) so they saved his hands.

More importantly, you need your hands to tend to the wounds on the rest of your body. :lol:

chipcom 05-23-08 10:29 AM


Originally Posted by I-Like-To-Bike (Post 6747015)
Wearing fingerless gloves as an insulation layer over or under mittens/winter gloves makes as much sense as wearing crotchless long johns in cold weather.

You've been peeking!

chipcom 05-23-08 10:31 AM


Originally Posted by Tabor (Post 6747817)
More importantly, you need your hands to tend to the wounds on the rest of your body. :lol:

Why? Dogs don't have hands. :D

hanshananigan 05-23-08 10:40 AM

I see most of the US posters are in the northern states... that's gotta make a difference!

For MTB I prefer 1/2 finger gloves for a few reasons:
1. they are cooler on hot days.
2. my stubby fingers don't fit well in most FF gloves.
3. I like to be able to feel the levers and I don't like the subtle sliding of material between my fingers and levers.

To each, his/her own!

d2create 05-23-08 10:53 AM


Originally Posted by chipcom (Post 6747881)
Why? Dogs don't have hands. :D

Ya, but I can't reach my crotch with my mouth, either. :lol:

ItsJustMe 05-23-08 11:13 AM


Originally Posted by I-Like-To-Bike (Post 6746394)
IMHO you are correct, both items are about equal in capability for significant reduction of bicycling injury risk (i.e. severity x probability.)

Exactly. Gloves protect against injuries that are relatively likely to happen but which are only irritating. Helmets protect against rare injuries that are potentially debilitating.

huhenio 05-23-08 11:16 AM


Originally Posted by stevage (Post 6745871)
At the risk of sounding like a troll, I'd like to start another "why" thread. I've never worn fingerless gloves to ride with, and wondered what's the advantage? Cushioning? Do you really get much benefit from a shortish commute, rather than mountain biking or maybe a long tour?

The only time I ever wear gloves is when it's cold, and then fingerless would be, um, dumb. :)

Steve


I wear whatever i want, regardless of what you think.

That being said, carpenter gloves, full finger, all weather.

I like to rub the fingers over the tires while riding if I accidentally rolled over some glass.

squeakywheel 05-23-08 11:54 AM

You're not supposed to reach out with your hand to cushion your fall. That's a good way to break a wrist or collar bone. Tuck and roll.

I usually wear the half finger padded gloves if I'm riding my road bike with drop bars. Probably don't need them for my 5 mile commute, but I have them and don't feel like leaving them on the shelf at home.

Tabor 05-23-08 11:58 AM


Originally Posted by squeakywheel (Post 6748344)
You're not supposed to reach out with your hand to cushion your fall. That's a good way to break a wrist or collar bone. Tuck and roll.

I agree 100%, but most people will still try to break their fall with their hands.

Loren3 05-23-08 12:07 PM

I mostly commute, and I mostly wear fingerless gloves.
For short rides in nice wx, no gloves are ok.
For almost any rides in cold wx (Minnesota winters), full gloves are mandatory for me.
Fingerless I wear a lot for two reasons. First, the padding does help if I'm biking more than a few miles. As cdotbois points out, hard pavement and thin padding on the handlebars and you'll start to feel it pretty quick. Second, I use a grip shifter, and full gloves are kind of awkward to shift with (over- or under-clicking), so fingerless is the best compromise.

DataJunkie 05-23-08 12:19 PM


Originally Posted by Tabor (Post 6748364)
I agree 100%, but most people will still try to break their fall with their hands.

When in an accident your body tends to react instinctively. Unless you retrain that instinct more often than not crashing will result in putting your hand out. The end result is scraped palms, broken wrists, and broken elbows. Still an improvement over nose diving into the pavement.

Quickbeam 05-23-08 12:20 PM


Originally Posted by huhenio (Post 6748149)
I like to rub the fingers over the tires while riding if I accidentally rolled over some glass.

FYI: you can do that with bare hands too. The only downside is you're likely to cut your fingers open... And you get blood all over your bar tape... And it hurts...

Novakane 05-23-08 12:30 PM


Originally Posted by squeakywheel (Post 6748344)
You're not supposed to reach out with your hand to cushion your fall. That's a good way to break a wrist or collar bone. Tuck and roll.

After years of cycling, I've gotten pretty good at tucking and rolling while flying off a bicycle, however, it really depends on how the bike ejects you. Sometimes things happen too quickly, or at a bad trajectory.

I had a front brake malfunction (1968 style center pulls) where the brake arm snapped and jammed the wheel. It launched me directly into an unexpected superman maneuver over the drops and into a parking lot. Tuck and roll was not an option, but putting my hands out to protect my face was! I didn't have gloves. I eventually healed but it hurt pretty bad for a while, so I wear gloves now.

I also find having the padding under my palms absorbs a bit of road vibration, and mine (the gloves...) have a soft fuzzy part that work well for wiping the sweat off my face on a hard ride/hot day.

AndrewP 05-23-08 12:43 PM

The cyclist tan. Fingerless gloves make it easier to fiddle with downtube shifters, do shoe laces, grab snacks or camera from jersey pocket, and dial cell phone.

Old Dirt Hill 05-23-08 12:43 PM

Alright, I'll admit it. The main reason I wear fingerless gloves is so that I can pick my nose while riding.

Does that make me a bad person?

I-Like-To-Bike 05-23-08 01:37 PM


Originally Posted by ItsJustMe (Post 6748129)
Exactly. Gloves protect against injuries that are relatively likely to happen but which are only irritating. Helmets protect against rare injuries that are potentially debilitating.

That wasn't really what I meant, but let's just say we have an agreement about bicycle helmets and gloves providing about equal value at risk mitigation and leave it at that.

TRaffic Jammer 05-23-08 01:46 PM

http://img389.imageshack.us/img389/6...llfacedmb6.jpg
Great for knocking on a body panels to move 'em over into their lanes.

JoeyBike 05-23-08 03:18 PM

Dang TJ!

I have a pair of Cedric Gracia gloves with the Cabrone (roll the "r" when you say it) knuckles like that! Brown camo. They do make a nice sound on the quarterpanel of a text-messaging motorist's vehicle don't they!

Jonahhobbes 05-23-08 03:25 PM

I have massive Oury grips on my hardtail and without the gloves my hands hurt. I get a little clustrophobic with gloves so only wear full fingers when it gets cold. I love fingerless gloves, the only drawback was losing my manly calluses when I made the switch to gloves years back.

ricohman 05-23-08 03:48 PM

I wear Mechanix gloves.
Light and cool.

alpinist 05-23-08 03:54 PM


Originally Posted by Old Dirt Hill (Post 6748631)
Alright, I'll admit it. The main reason I wear fingerless gloves is so that I can pick my nose while riding.

Does that make me a bad person?

You could do like me, and just cut one finger off of your full finger gloves.

savethekudzu 05-23-08 05:14 PM


Originally Posted by TRaffic Jammer (Post 6748988)
http://img389.imageshack.us/img389/6...llfacedmb6.jpg
Great for knocking on a body panels to move 'em over into their lanes.

Where are the helmet teeth**********?

macteacher 05-23-08 05:22 PM

you were lucky, thats all


Originally Posted by stevage (Post 6745904)
>Most falls usually end up with your palm hitting the ground first.

Oh! Didn't think of that. Strangely, the fall I had earlier this year, I whacked the ground really hard with my hands and expected bruising and grazing. They were fine, it was my legs and arms that were ripped up. My dad (GP) said that's typical: your hands tend to hit the ground and grip it (no grazing), while your legs slide along it and get shredded.

I can see how they would reduce bruising, but I guess for me the risk isn't such a big deal...

Steve


Cheshyre 05-23-08 05:22 PM

i have a set of cold weather gloves (louie garneau windtex eco) which are nice (a little thin) and a set of adidas fingerless gloves. i also wore a set of bell gloves until they totally fell apart.

gloves are good to have in case of a fall and for comfort, and i'm going to say they're absolutely necessary if you ride at a faster pace. someone said earlier that their hands grip on the pavement when they hit the ground, leading to bruised legs. i'm going to say that at a faster pace, what happens is this:
1) fall
2) hands hit first and slide
2.5) elbows hits, slide
3) torso hits, continue sliding, begin barrel roll
4) legs hit, barrel roll continues
5) stop.

upon post crash examination of my bell gloves, i tore cleanly through the leather. the elbows were also bleeding everywhere.

the difference between elbows and hands though, is that hands are very difficult, surgically, to rebuild skin on. the skin may be too tight after healing. also, seriously injuring, or even severing a hand tendon is EXTREMELY bad news, and also very difficult to repair. don't take the risk. gloves are comfortable and useful, especially if they have a nose-wipe patch (i use mine every single ride, haha).

Jonahhobbes 05-23-08 05:29 PM


Originally Posted by Cheshyre (Post 6750124)
gloves are comfortable and useful, especially if they have a nose-wipe patch (i use mine every single ride, haha).


I forgot about this use for gloves, the famous, (by New Zealand standards), mountain biking Kennett Brothers always said of gloves "left for sweat and right for snot".


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 06:19 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.