Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Commuting (https://www.bikeforums.net/commuting/)
-   -   How much to spend for a helmet? (https://www.bikeforums.net/commuting/466676-how-much-spend-helmet.html)

slloth 09-17-08 09:41 PM

When I bought my helmet I went for comfort not price. I never wore a helmet growing up so it took a while to get used to and comfort was a big issue for me. Actually that is usually the biggest issue for everything I wear especially shoes. Now I couldn't imagine not wearing a helmet and it doesn't bother me a bit.

The helmet I ended up getting wasn't the most expensive but it was the most comfortable for me.

If you go to cheap it might not hold up. My stuff has to be able to take a beating. Dropped on the ground thrown in the trunk etc.

brokenknee 09-17-08 11:07 PM


Originally Posted by 10 Wheels (Post 7493022)
I just bought a helmet from Goodwill for $2.99. It had never been used.

Photo: $00.99 Red Bell Helmet from Goodwill.
Makes the Corvette Look Good.

http://i256.photobucket.com/albums/h...heels/YC19.jpg

Or maybe those who have a Corvette. :)

Fleetdog 09-17-08 11:28 PM

I had a hard time finding a helmet I liked. I had a skate helmet (for skating) and thought the look was OK but the venting was pretty much non-existent. I like the look of this one better than anything else I've found and it fits me very well. It does have a plastic piece in the rear that has a chord through it and a ratcheting knob to tighten it (you can just see it in the pic). You dial it in to fit for you.

I couldn't find this helmet locally so I called Protec and they suggested an online dealer (no one I could find had black in the US) as well as telling me that the sizing was almost identical to their skate lids as far as you needing a S/M/L even though those don't have the knob adjustment.

The downside: it was $80.

http://www.pro-tec.net/bike/cyphon/2.jpg

bragi 09-18-08 12:00 AM

With helmets, as with everything else, you get what you pay for. Cheap helmets meet safety standards, but they won't fit well, be comfortable, or look as good (or rather, will look even more stupid). Pricier helmets tend to have adjustable headbands, have more vents, and look way less dorky, unless, as has been said already, you get the "Alien"-looking time trial helmets.

I have a Bell Variant. It was about $100 a year ago, which is outrageous, but it fits well on my gigantic head and is comfortable in hot weather due to its venting, it looks slightly less stupid than most helmets, and I wear the thing at least a few times a day, so I consider it money well spent.

ZombieButcher 09-18-08 12:02 AM

Get what fits. I was looking at a Giro that was a lil more expensive then the Trek model and I liked the style but when I put it on the fitting dial on the back hit my head wrong and was uncomfortable. So I tried the Trek version and it was very comfy and snug. Although it does give me the Mushroom look I don't care. Plus before hand I was just using a ball cap which as we all know is really comfortable but offers no protection.

tekknoschtev 09-18-08 06:42 AM


Originally Posted by BA Commuter (Post 7491876)
There are various helmets in the $20-$50 range that have a little style and fit very well.

I have a Bell Solar, which was a bargain on sale for $20...

At $20, that is about the same price as the generic adult helmets at WalMart/Meijer/Target. I paid $35 for my Bell Solar after having the opportunity to use my old cheapy Bell that I bought from Walmart at the beginning of summer. It fits so much better, and I feel like I'd be safer in the unlikely situation that I had to use it.

pathdoc 09-18-08 07:01 AM

How much is your head worth?

DataJunkie 09-18-08 07:35 AM

A couple million dollars but I can't find the funding or a helmet for that price.

stevage 09-18-08 07:36 AM

Jeez, they're more expensive here - the range was like $40AUD to $280AUD (specialized 2D).

>How much is your head worth?

According to that logic, very few people could afford to ride a bike.

Steve

pathdoc 09-18-08 08:13 AM

Point is, your head is very important. Don't settle for a cheap helmet.

ItsJustMe 09-18-08 10:27 AM

I would NOT buy a used helmet. There's no way to tell how they were treated. You can't tell if the foam has been fractured without breaking it.

fbwill 09-18-08 11:44 AM


Originally Posted by ItsJustMe (Post 7495669)
I would NOT buy a used helmet. There's no way to tell how they were treated. You can't tell if the foam has been fractured without breaking it.

+1. Just like used motorcycle helmets, just cant tell what condition the foam is in and I wouldn't want to need the helmet to find out there was a problem. One drop from waist height and it damages the foam protection. Just my $.02.

TheatreME 09-18-08 12:24 PM

I usually wear skate helmets. They usually meet the same standards, and dont have funny shaped vents to get caught on things if I go down, and are usually under 30 bucks. The down side is they look like a skateboard helmet and have mostly no venting.

cyccommute 09-18-08 01:04 PM


Originally Posted by DataJunkie (Post 7487295)
If looks are not a consideration (god knows they are not for many commuters) then pick the cheapest helmet with a good safety rating.

All helmets sold in the US have to pass the same safety test. $20, $250: it doesn't matter. The rest is all fashion;)

JanMM 09-18-08 02:08 PM


Originally Posted by steve-in-kville (Post 7487232)
So the LBS has 'em for $20 all the way to $100+. I want to have two, one for night time riding (install head lamp) and another for day time (mirror).

Why would you not use a mirror at night?

funkydrum 09-18-08 03:54 PM


Originally Posted by edbikebabe (Post 7487395)
The one that fits & you like... Try on several different brands & see what feels good. Then try on several models @ different prices & see if you can tell the difference. If not, buy the cheaper ones.

+1

If the $20 fits good and has good venting, roll with it. But let fit and venting drive your decision...

PDXaero 09-18-08 04:09 PM

What I have always felt is that you should buy the helmet that is most going to make you want to wear it.

For me its a balance of looks, comfort, ventilation and weight.
I just bought a great LIMAR helmet from italy, and i love how adjustable it is. Plus the more money you spend on a helmet just reminds me i better wear it to get my moneys worth.

RogerB 09-19-08 10:36 AM


Originally Posted by pathdoc (Post 7494733)
Point is, your head is very important. Don't settle for a cheap helmet.


OK. Third time somebody tried to push this idea, so I had to respond. I've seen this argument all over motorcycle and auto racing forums, and it is mostly useless.

Alright, don't be so cheap as get a "vintage" helmet off of E-Bay and think you're good to go. But as long as you're comparing two "NIB" helmets that are reasonably freshly manufactured, and meet the same safety standard, the only things left to compare are fit, ventilation, looks, color, features, and so on. You cannot guarantee better protection by spending more, nor does spending less mean getting less protection (to a point).

pathdoc 09-19-08 10:39 AM

My main concern was purchasing a used helmet.

sHANDRIL105 09-19-08 11:32 AM

They all have to meet safety standards. The only real considerations after that are your comfort, fashion sense and brand snobbery level.:thumb:

I have a $15 youth helmet from Target. I like it because it fits (adult helmets are too big), that it allows me to ride a bike during triathlons (the only time I ever wear a helmet) and because it has blue flames on it. But I admit I'm silly like that.:D

alanbikehouston 09-19-08 11:36 AM

There are three things to look for in a helmet: fit...fit...and fit. If a $20 helmet from Target is a "perfect" fit for your head, you are good to go. I like helmets with lots of sweat pads around the forehead area...so I'm willing to pay a little more for the extra padding...say....$30 or so.

I-Like-To-Bike 09-19-08 12:02 PM


Originally Posted by Lizzylou (Post 7491451)
My LBS used to have a sign... "If you have a $5 head, buy a $5 helmet.":lol:

HA HA!:rolleyes: Did he also have a sign that said "LBS owner likes Johnny Walker Black, buy a $150 helmet."

Almost all the bicycle helmets on the U.S. market meet the same safety standard, the helmet buyer does not get more "safety" by spending more money.

ItsJustMe 09-19-08 12:14 PM

I wish I could wear the Target helmets. I'd love a Scooby Doo helmet. My head is big though (60cm) and I can't get any department store helmet to fit. I've been using Bell Citi and Metros, though I think Giro has some that will fit fine for < $50 too. Luckily I've been finding my Bells on "last year's model" sales.

Sammiches 09-20-08 06:46 AM

Tried it and the cheepo $20 Bell Adrenaline at WalMart was a good fit. I got the black and silver model. It saved my melon from a hard smack onto the pavement just this morning. It only looks scratched to me, but conventional wisdom says I should replace it. 'sides, it's only 20 bucks.

CCrew 09-20-08 09:49 AM


Originally Posted by RogerB (Post 7502644)
I've seen this argument all over motorcycle and auto racing forums, and it is mostly useless.

FWIW, sanctioning bodies in motorcycle and auto racing won't allow helmets, restraints, etc that are over 5 years old, so that takes a lot of older spec stuff off the markets.

-R


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:27 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.