Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Commuting (https://www.bikeforums.net/commuting/)
-   -   Light-weight step-through bike (https://www.bikeforums.net/commuting/607548-light-weight-step-through-bike.html)

PlatyPius 12-13-09 06:10 AM


Originally Posted by Mos6502 (Post 10137883)
I would say the obvious and best choice would be to find an old Raleigh. Considering the ladies step through ones are very common, it shouldn't be hard to find one in good shape for south of $100.
http://img1.classistatic.com/cps/po/...99612a_27.jpeg

Not low enough. The OP wants a step-through. The Raleigh is a womens drop-tube frame. Step-through has only a downtube (or a downtube and a small strut tube) and is as close to the same height as the BB as possible.

For instance:
http://www.breezerbikes.com/im/bikes/new/uptown-u.jpg

mike 12-13-09 07:18 AM

First of all, forget about the folding bike idea if you wife rides any kind of distance at all. By that, I mean any distance more than about two miles. I can think of few tortures as hellish as riding a folding bike with those tiny wheels more than a couple of miles.

I am surprised at how heavy some of the city bikes are today. The suggestion to get an old Raleigh 3-speed is not a bad idea. You can bring it to your LBS and have them change the rear wheel and shifter to a seven speed. Otherwise, pick any bike with the geometry and weight you want regardless of the gearing and then have your LBS switch it over to a seven speed internal hub wheel.

Schwinnsta 12-13-09 07:55 AM

I like Raleigh's. The Raliegh will be more comfortable ride than the Breezer. However, Raleigh's have steel rims and little braking power when dry and near none when wet. Also the spokes are steel and as they rust they snap, rendering the bike unreliable. So changing out the rims and spokes is a good idea. Myself, I would keep the 3-speed SA, they are bullet proof, just add a couple of drops of oil now and then. If you add dual caliper brakes, I think you have a superior bike to what you can get new. Still, Raleigh has quirks. The threading of the bottom braket is non standard, the stem is non standard, the handlebar clamp and handle bar is non standard. Still if you find one in good shape and make the changes to rims, spokes and brakes, you have a nice riding bike.

yoder 12-13-09 08:23 AM

http://www.biria.com/images/eb_superlight_8_black.jpg

Biria Superlite 8

g00se 12-13-09 08:41 AM

1 Attachment(s)
Charge Lazy Susan?

http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=128590
http://road.cc/content/news/5690-exc...rge-lazy-susan

PlatyPius 12-13-09 09:11 AM


Originally Posted by yoder (Post 10139938)

^ this.

mike 12-13-09 10:13 AM


Originally Posted by yoder (Post 10139938)

Neat looking bike. $900.00

•Frame: Aluminum 7005, 40cm (15.5") and 46cm (18")
•Rims: Aluminum 26"
•Handlebar: City Cruiser
•Stem: Aluminum
•Brakes: Front and Rear Aluminum V-Brakes
•Fork: Hi-Ten Unicrown
•Tires: 26" x 1.75"
•Gears: 8-speed Nexus Shimano with freewheel and Dynamo Generator light
•Included: Chain Guard and Kickstand Integrated rear carrier, Fenders

alr 12-14-09 11:57 AM


Originally Posted by nwmtnbkr (Post 10132176)
Although I like the look of mixte's, they aren't that different from the bike I currently have. In fact, I'd say the middle bar on a mixte is about the same height as the bar on my bike. I find that I can't get on my bike in a skirt without almost laying it down. Do you ever ride in a skirt or dress? Do you have to tilt your bike much to get on gracefully when dressed in a skirt or dress? I really am limiting my next bike to a true step through because I'd like more flexibility with my riding wardrobe.
http://pic50.picturetrail.com/VOL442.../370628300.jpg

I used to ride a mountain bike with a sloping top tube, I definitely would have had trouble wearing a skirt while riding. On my mixte, I ride all the time in skirts, and the only ones I have trouble with are pencil skirts. But these will be hard to ride in on any bicycle. Where the top tube on a mixte hits the seat tube is only one consideration when pondering whether or not you can step over it in a skirt-- the overall geometry is important too. I have more room to step over the sloping bar on my mixte than I had with my mountain bike. My mixte is a lot lighter than a comfort style bicycle, so I prefer it for my commuting. I actually find it nicer to ride in a skirt, especially when it is raining.

badmother 12-14-09 02:10 PM


Originally Posted by alr (Post 10144516)
I used to ride a mountain bike with a sloping top tube, I definitely would have had trouble wearing a skirt while riding. On my mixte, I ride all the time in skirts, and the only ones I have trouble with are pencil skirts. But these will be hard to ride in on any bicycle. Where the top tube on a mixte hits the seat tube is only one consideration when pondering whether or not you can step over it in a skirt-- the overall geometry is important too. I have more room to step over the sloping bar on my mixte than I had with my mountain bike. My mixte is a lot lighter than a comfort style bicycle, so I prefer it for my commuting. I actually find it nicer to ride in a skirt, especially when it is raining.

+1 :thumb:

DVC45 12-14-09 02:13 PM


Originally Posted by mike (Post 10139831)
First of all, forget about the folding bike idea if you wife rides any kind of distance at all. By that, I mean any distance more than about two miles. I can think of few tortures as hellish as riding a folding bike with those tiny wheels more than a couple of miles.

Words of wisdom. :rolleyes:

Let us not forget, that some, actually do cross country tours on a folding bike.

http://www.crazyguyonabike.com/doc/c...octype=journal

mike 12-14-09 02:30 PM


Originally Posted by DVC45 (Post 10145175)
Words of wisdom. :rolleyes:

Let us not forget, that some, actually do cross country tours on a folding bike.

http://www.crazyguyonabike.com/doc/c...octype=journal

Indeed. And some folks rode across the world in the 1800's on penny-farthings and some guys eat half their weight in hot dogs at contests. Just because people do it doesn't mean it is a good idea - as we all know...

Folding bikes are fun. They seem like a good idea when you hop on them and ride around the campgrounds, but picture a five year old on a tricycle pedalling five miles and realize that the difference in wheel size of a folding bike is closer to a child's tricycle than it is to a road-worthy bicycle.

Rhodabike 12-15-09 09:05 AM

I test-rode a Norco Cityglide 8 ST before the snow fell and was impressed. It didn't seem to flex at all when I sprinted out of the saddle and didn't weigh quite as much as my Rocky Mountain Metropolis. The only thing I didn't like was the chainguard, which rattled and flexed all over the place. If they had extended it back to the seat stays and fixed in in place there, it would have worked a lot better. The other thing that I wasn't crazy about was the twist-grip shifter. Personal preference, I know, but the rapid-fire shifters seem less cumbersome to use.
http://www.norco.com/bikes/urban/cit...ty-glide-8-st/
E.T.A.: I love the look of that Soma Mixte. I've never had one, but now that I'm old and inflexible, it's starting to seem like a idea.

X-LinkedRider 12-15-09 09:13 AM

Here is my stepmothers Specialized Crossroads Sport.

Cost like 350 bucks as a leftover. My father has the matching one. They don't use them as much as they should, but they are great bikes.

http://alphabluetech.com/kj2/fotos/a...al_LB-CRS2.jpg

Hot Potato 12-15-09 10:12 AM


Originally Posted by nwmtnbkr (Post 10135438)
To all the males responding to this thread, I would remind you that the bike is being chosen by a woman who will use it commuting and may be dressed in a skirt and pumps. What you perceive as an acceptable step over height may not be acceptable to her. Mwshook, if your wife can test ride any of the bikes she's interested in, I would encourage her to dress as she normally does when commuting. I know that I'd not ride a mixte in a skirt or dress. My existing bike's middle bar is the same height as a mixte's two middle bars and it's just too high for me to get on in a skirt without almost laying it down. Whether any of the folders are really as low as a step-through, well I'd have to see in person. I don't trust photo comparisons.

I would assume that any bike that has a top tube below the highest pedal height would qualify?

dolbydj 04-04-15 09:02 PM

Hey guys, can you recommend some higher end step through bikes for my girlfriend? I'm thinking of a 2015 Specialized Elite Step Through. A 1 piece carbon bike would be cool too. Thanks in advance!

jade408 04-04-15 11:01 PM

A mid-range-ish options are Public and Linus. I am going to sell my Public C7i soon as the gearing isn't ideal for my neighborhood. If I lived a few blocks over, I would be happier! It is very very stylish, I get compliments all the time when riding! I just need lower gearing and different geometry for the hills. But it is all around a pretty good bike. I am not a "rider" by any means, but easily ride 15 miles in a day around town on it! It is not super light, hard o pick up on the train, not so noticeable on the flats. I haven't ridden the Linus' but they are pretty much the same.

There is also Simcoe, a little blander than Linus and Public, but well featured.

I am building up a Soma Buena Vista frame right now! Something along these lines: Buena Vista (Complete Bicycle) | SOMA Fabrications though I'll have an 8sp IGH, dynamo hub, fenders and a chain case.

I have a thing for 40s styled stuff, so if I was the type to scour craigslist for deals, I'd grab a vintage mixte and make it into my awesome bike. Instead I bought a new frame to do the same. :)

I tried the Swobo step-through, but it looked to mountain-bikey for me. But features/pricing/performance were all pretty good.

I rode Rivendell's Clementine (and Cheviot) today. The Clementine will be her budget model. A full build is ~$1500. The handling was very nice and it was much speedier than the other loop frame step-throughs I have ridden. Definitely a good option if in your budget and you do not want an IGH. It is like half the weight of my current bike! (Ok maybe only 15 pounds lighter. With my rear rack, front rack, dynamo, basket and lock my bike is around 40#)

dolbydj 04-05-15 06:42 AM

Thanks Jade! Something less than 25 lbs would be great. She is a new rider and currently rides my Giant Rapid 2, which is a kinda like a flat bar racing hybrid. Also, I have 2 flights of stairs to carry up. Thanks!

jade408 04-05-15 10:36 PM

One thing I highly recommend to people with step-throughs is Walnut Studilo's frame handle*. A little pricey, but my fave bike accessory. Makes "awkward" to carry bikes easier to handle!


*Wow the price has gone up quite a bit from when I ordered! Mine was ~$44 with mono. Now Mono is an extra $18. Obviously not needed, and you may find a cheaper alternative if you are crafty. This makes stairs so much easier to navigate!

jade408 04-05-15 10:39 PM


Originally Posted by dolbydj (Post 17691487)
Thanks Jade! Something less than 25 lbs would be great. She is a new rider and currently rides my Giant Rapid 2, which is a kinda like a flat bar racing hybrid. Also, I have 2 flights of stairs to carry up. Thanks!

The Public's with internal gears are about 30 pounds. Fairly manageable. My build up Soma should work out to be around 10# lighter than the Public and clock in at around 30#: with in IGH, Dynamo hub and front/rear racks! A derailleur will save around 3 pounds. I also have "heavy" Brooks saddles, too!

dolbydj 04-06-15 03:44 AM

Thanks for the bike holder idea! I did find this Silverback Starke is kinda what I'm looking for: Silverback Starke USB ? City/Hybrid Bike | Silverback

jade408 04-06-15 08:13 AM

The specs of the Silverback are interesting. Could not see a price as it is not available in the US.

Not my style (I like old school looking bikes). I skimmed the geometry. One thing that might be troubling is the top tube length. Not sure if they meant the actual tube or the virtual one, but if it is the virtual one the handlebars in the small are quite far away for a shorter or female rider. For example there is "concern" that the Soma Buena vista top tube is really long, and in the 54cm (medium) the tube is 555m. The small bike above has a top tub of 565!

Sizing might be difficult.

dynaryder 04-06-15 05:38 PM


Originally Posted by jade408 (Post 17693670)
One thing I highly recommend to people with step-throughs is Walnut Studilo's frame handle*. A little pricey, but my fave bike accessory. Makes "awkward" to carry bikes easier to handle!

Jeez,they still haven't fixed their pictures. Carrying your bike by the drive side is pure fail,unless grease stains are fashionable now.

katsrevenge 04-06-15 06:41 PM

My Pap Sommer is a loop frame with an IGH that comes in around 30 pounds standard. It's less if the racks and bags are off it. By putting North Road bars on it (instead of the tall bars it came with) shaved a pound or two as well.
Vintage Bicycles by Papillionaire

It's a great bike for skirts and regular clothes in a way that my mixte is not. FWIW, I'm 5'3" and can get on without fuss.

old's'cool 04-06-15 07:44 PM

Pick any 3
 
  • lightweight
  • stiff/strong
  • cheap
  • step-through

dolbydj 04-06-15 08:57 PM

Yes, mostly light and step through. With the size of bottom brackets and oversize tubes now a days, it doesn't need to be a tank. The Silverback Starke is on sale for $580 US. I think that's a pretty good deal. I think carbon forks and seat post would seal it!


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 07:11 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.