Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Commuting (https://www.bikeforums.net/commuting/)
-   -   Are you concerned about air pollution during commute? (https://www.bikeforums.net/commuting/629939-you-concerned-about-air-pollution-during-commute.html)

mustang1 03-19-10 10:40 PM

Are you concerned about air pollution during commute?
 
I commute during peak traffic hours. I guess most commuters do. Are you bothered about the pollution?

I am considering going back to training rides after work in the back roads of the woodland area I live in. I'm quitting bike-commuting.

electrik 03-19-10 10:43 PM

Actually i do hear car-drivers breathe more pollution in.. but, there are cars out there like **** diesels and 1994 jobs without catalytic converters.

The pollution is gonna get you somehow.

mustang1 03-19-10 10:50 PM

^ yeah of course, the pollution will get you. The thing is, on a bike, you're so breathing a lot deeper, a lot faster. In a car you;re just sitting down in a relaxed pose. Also, in the UK at least, diesel has become REALLY smelly. I dont know if they've just added something to the diesel mix.

electrik 03-19-10 10:56 PM


Originally Posted by mustang1 (Post 10551422)
^ yeah of course, the pollution will get you. The thing is, on a bike, you're so breathing a lot deeper, a lot faster. In a car you;re just sitting down in a relaxed pose. Also, in the UK at least, diesel has become REALLY smelly. I dont know if they've just added something to the diesel mix.

Urea is now injected into the exhaust to neutralize some harmful chemicals. NO2 maybe.

It varies a lot - the amount of pollution you encounter everyday. Around here in the winter and the colder morning, cold engines pollute horrible since the catalytic converter isn't warmed up. I would be worried about asthma if you're breathing in that much.

Have you tried a good filter mask, not a cyclist one but a commercial one.

GriddleCakes 03-19-10 11:00 PM

I'd heard that there's a higher concentration of pollution inside of the average car than outside of it. Don't know how true this actually is. True or not, breathing exhaust sucks.

I figure that as long as I'm no safer from pollutants in the car, and am getting a cardiovascular workout while I'm on the bike, then the bike is still healthier. And I'm not adding to the pollution to boot.

akohekohe 03-20-10 02:43 AM

It seems that many feel that exercising when there is a lot of air pollution is a bad idea but I haven't seen any articles specifically measuring these effects on bicycle commuters. The air is generally pretty good here in Hawaii but Kilauea has been acting up lately and we are getting a lot of vog. Just doesn't seem to bother me when others are complaining. The worst air I get are from the stupid 2 cycle mopeds (although school buses are a close second). I'm starting to see a few electric mopeds and they are so quiet and clean I wish they would catch on.

LesterOfPuppets 03-20-10 03:10 AM

I don't worry about the pollution aspect too much. It doesn't seem like taking another transportation mode would make much difference in your overall health. I only feel the pollution effects when riding in/alongside wall-to-wall cars that are inching along, and we don't get that around here much.

+1 on getting behind one of dem 2-stroke scooters.

Timber_8 03-20-10 03:39 AM

The air is the air, don't worry about the things you can not control. It is better than it was 10 years ago. In the colonies I sware 1/2 the cars are those Toyota Prieus things.

dedhed 03-20-10 04:07 PM

I don't think it's any worse than the cigarette I light up after my rides.

devianb 03-22-10 10:57 PM

I don't pay attention to it, just like with global warming.

crazyed27 03-22-10 11:01 PM


Originally Posted by dedhed (Post 10553500)
I don't think it's any worse than the cigarette I light up after my rides.



Or during my rides!

crazyed27 03-22-10 11:05 PM


Originally Posted by electrik (Post 10551434)
Urea is now injected into the exhaust to neutralize some harmful chemicals. NO2 maybe.


Urea might make your crops green and healthy,since it is the active chemical in products like Vigaro, but a cars exhaust?

electrik 03-22-10 11:06 PM

At least you aren't commuting here.

busted knuckles 03-22-10 11:23 PM

I dont think the pollution is too bad where I live, my health would suffer more if I quit commuting by bicycle.

HFTB 03-22-10 11:37 PM

not that serious man

HFTB 03-22-10 11:37 PM

if anything you'll contribute with drivving

Booger1 03-23-10 10:04 AM

No,I'm too worried about other things...like getting hit.

chandltp 03-23-10 11:29 AM

I'm not worried about it, but my traffic level is pretty light. The health benefits outweigh the risks, IMO.

EKW in DC 03-23-10 12:08 PM

Nope... not worried.

Quickbeam 03-23-10 12:12 PM

Only if it gets bad enough that I chip a tooth.

ItsJustMe 03-23-10 12:13 PM

No, because I'm riding in an area that's in the 90+ percentile for clean air in the US. I looked it up a few months back and every place I've lived has been in the 90+ percentile, one was in the 98th percentile - to do better I'd pretty much have to live in a national park in Alaska.

noglider 03-23-10 12:13 PM

Long ago, I read that the benefits of cycling outweigh the detriments of the pollution. Of course, this could be different in some places. It was written in the 1970's in the US.

Sixty Fiver 03-23-10 12:17 PM

I can say that after spending some time in Mexico city that anywhere else you go can only be up...

Research studies (will have to find them) show that the air quality outside a car is significantly better than inside as the car absorbs pollutants and also out gasses a lot of chemicals from the interior materials.

Riding and maintaining a healthy cardio system goes a long ways toward fighting bad air but there really is nothing like getting out of the city where the air is fresh and the only pollution smells like manure and sileage.

daven1986 03-23-10 02:22 PM

There was a study that said that bus and car users get more pollution than cyclists who then get more than pedestrians. I'm not too worried about it tbh.

yaztromo 03-23-10 03:14 PM

Getting stuck behind one of these at a junction in Sheffield is not good. They smoke like crazy on set off and the position of the exhaust sends it directly into your face.

Buses are touted as the greenest transport but they are the dirtiest on the road, much worse than lorries.

http://i146.photobucket.com/albums/r...tromo/1166.jpg


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:33 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.