Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Commuting (https://www.bikeforums.net/commuting/)
-   -   Do you use clipless for commuting? (https://www.bikeforums.net/commuting/684257-do-you-use-clipless-commuting.html)

squirtdad 09-30-10 01:19 PM

I use clipless on my commute, but often ride in whatever i have on for short utility rides. I use the peformance campus pedal which has spd on oneside and clipless on the other.

On my road/training bike it is always clipless

Maxxxie 09-30-10 02:14 PM

I only have one bike, so the platform/clipless decision isn't there. I always ride clipless. I test rode a bike the other day with platform pedals and I just couldn't do it! My feet kept slipping off the pedals. But worse, I found that I really do use the upstroke to pedal. I never realised this. So I'd be pulling up with my foot, and, of course, my foot would come off the pedal.

Never again! Platform pedals, begone! :lol:

For my commute (53Km round trip), I have no hassles with clipless pedals. You get used to using them and as someone else mentioned, stopping is second nature.

Max

canyoneagle 09-30-10 02:25 PM

I went from numb forefeet (from cinched down toe clips/straps) to clipless freedom in about 1986. Now I can't ride a bike without clipping in. To me riding a bike without being clipped in feels like driving without a seatbelt.

ItsJustMe 09-30-10 02:41 PM

I don't cinch down my toe straps, I just leave them loose. I only want them so that my feet don't slip off the pedals, I don't need to be cinched down for that.

bhop 09-30-10 03:12 PM

Clipless on my road bike, clips/cages on my fixed gear. I do feel an advantage up hills and on takeoffs, but just cruising, not so much. I started with the M324s as well, but quickly realized they're a pain to use because my foot kept landing on the wrong side when I wanted to clip in. I literally never used them with normal shoes, so I ended up switching them to double sided spd and have been much happier.

Seattle Forrest 09-30-10 03:26 PM


Originally Posted by Maxxxie (Post 11549123)
So I'd be pulling up with my foot, and, of course, my foot would come off the pedal.

I test-drove a bike that had platform pedals on it. I came to a few red lights ... when they turned green, I'd go to pull the pedal to where it should be for me to get moving, and it didn't come with my foot. Annoying.

wolfchild 09-30-10 04:18 PM

No I never use clipless for any type of riding. I use toe clips and straps on my fixed gear and singlespeed bikes. In winter I switch to platforms. I like wearing regular shoes, that's the reason I don't use clipless.

groovestew 09-30-10 04:31 PM

Clipless on the road bike, BMX-style platforms on the beater/winter bike. I was going to put clipless on the beater bike for the summer, but never got around to buying any. Because I alternate bikes often enough, I don't have any issues with my feet coming off the pedals when using platforms. I'm just programmed to know how to pedal on each bike.

caloso 09-30-10 04:35 PM

All my bikes have clipless: Ultegra or 105 on the road bikes; M520 on the CX. It feels weird to not be attached to the bike.

travelmama 09-30-10 04:39 PM

I usually ride with them but if I don't want to work in my cycling shoes, I wear street shoes.

sci_femme 09-30-10 07:35 PM

Platform/SPD combo. Took some time to get over apprehension in traffic. More control clipped.

kjmillig 09-30-10 10:35 PM

I have a pair of fairly comfortable Specialized MTB shoes. They do clack a bit on hard surfaces, which is all my workplace has, but I could probably get away with it. I may just leave an extra pair of sneakers at work. Thanks for all the advice and experiences. I'll try it next week.

nelson249 10-01-10 07:58 AM

Nope. I have lots of stops along a MUP and I don't want to have to carry or leave an extra pair of shoes on the other end. I use toe clips without straps and I find they work fine with cycling shoes, casual shoes and combat boots

Nucks 10-01-10 12:45 PM

I use clipless all the time. I started with some shimano spd pedals but I could never get the right one dialed in properly so it was hurting my right knee. I went to speedplay frogs and have no problems. I could never handle platforms without clips anymore but I wouldn't mind regular toe clips, I just prefer the clipless.

modernjess 10-01-10 02:56 PM

Yes, always and forever forward on all my bikes period.

mustang1 10-01-10 03:03 PM

11 miles ones way, ride clipless (shimano m540, I prefer mtb shoes coz I can walk with them). Plenty of stopping at lights. Wouldn't ride any other way.

GriddleCakes 10-01-10 04:14 PM

Had 'em for a couple of years, until they (and the bike that they were mounted on) were stolen back in '06. When I replaced the bike I didn't bother with new clipless pedals, since I'd stopped using the clipless side of the pedal for commuting long before they were ganked. I never found a pair of shoes that were comfortable enough for the 8 to 9 hours that I was on my feet for work (restaurant workers represent! We don't get no breaks, YO! We don't get no breaks, HEY!), which more than trumped the minor gains I received from riding clipped in, gunning it up the hills on the way to work at maybe 2 to 3 mph faster than riding in my work shoes and using the platform side of the pedal.

Drew Eckhardt 10-01-10 07:50 PM


Originally Posted by kjmillig (Post 11546398)
I just bought a set of Shimano M324 pedals for my Giant CS800 commuter/ all around transportation bike. How many of you use clipless for commuting? Do you find any real advantage using them around town?

I do. They're more secure than platforms especially when hammering (there's 12.5 miles between my home and office with 23 traffic lights and 10 stop signs. Getting there or back in under 50 minutes means parts of the ride are happening at 18-22 MPH) or in inclement weather (I've slipped off wet platforms riding in Seattle on the comfort bike I picked up after herniating a disc - that sucked).

For over a decade I wore my Shimano BMX shoes around the office, although since switching to Bebop cleats which are only somewhat recessed I started changing into Tevas.


My commute is not long, and there's lots of traffic lights.
It's not a big deal.

BarracksSi 10-01-10 07:52 PM


Originally Posted by Drew Eckhardt (Post 11556455)
I do. They're more secure than platforms especially when hammering (there's 12.5 miles between my home and office with 23 traffic lights and 10 stop signs. Getting there or back in under 50 minutes means parts of the ride are happening at 18-22 MPH).

Around here, that'd be the same time in a car... ;)

da07079 10-01-10 08:47 PM

Always. Shimanon PD-M424 combination platform and clipless. Platform lets me get started at lights (and I have a lot of them) without worrying about clipping in instantly, while the clips give me confidence that my feet will stay on the pedals over the potholes and other "irregularities" in the Newark streets. I use them all year around, including when I've put the studded tires on to deal with the ice.

dynodonn 10-01-10 09:31 PM

No.

scroca 10-02-10 11:13 AM

I have clipless pedals on my fixed gear, but not on my road bike. When it gets cold I will have to give up the fixed gear for the winter because my shoes are too tight to layer socks for warmth.

1nterceptor 10-02-10 11:46 AM


Originally Posted by kjmillig (Post 11546398)
I just bought a set of Shimano M324 pedals for my Giant CS800 commuter/ all around transportation bike. How many of you use clipless for commuting? Do you find any real advantage using them around town? My commute is not long, and there's lots of traffic lights. I'm wondering if I'll end up just using clipless for longer weekend rides.

Clipless for commuting, 4 years now:

RaleighComp 10-02-10 01:07 PM


Originally Posted by CCrew (Post 11546569)
I do unless there's snow/ice on the ground. Then I'm on a MTB with meat tenderizer platforms.

I find that Shimano 5 series SPDs are affordable (I bought both pairs used) and shed mud and snow wonderfully in the winter. I would be kind of scared to ride anything except clipless on snow/ice. It seems that even when conditions surprise me they just release automatically at just the right time.

GriddleCakes 10-02-10 01:40 PM


Originally Posted by Seattle Forrest (Post 11549541)
I test-drove a bike that had platform pedals on it. I came to a few red lights ... when they turned green, I'd go to pull the pedal to where it should be for me to get moving, and it didn't come with my foot. Annoying.

This takes a little practice, and a set of platforms with decent grip would certainly help; but I do it at every stoplight, without clipless and without problems. From the 6 o'clock position you apply forward lateral force to the pedal, then bring your foot up as the pedal swings forwards and upwards. It's just circular pedaling technique applied in reverse.


Originally Posted by RaleighComp (Post 11558786)
I would be kind of scared to ride anything except clipless on snow/ice.

Why? I could see how someone would be inconvenienced if they were big fans of clipless and had to go without, but how is it scary?


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 06:11 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.