Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Commuting (https://www.bikeforums.net/commuting/)
-   -   Balaclava recommendations (https://www.bikeforums.net/commuting/701535-balaclava-recommendations.html)

storckm 12-16-10 08:28 PM

I got some swiss wool military surplus two winters ago. It was about six bucks, and has done a good job for me, although I'm a little further south than you.

scroca 12-16-10 08:31 PM


Originally Posted by Kuma (Post 11945220)
Speak to Lou at Foxwear and have him make you one out of Polartec fleece of any thickness material you'd like. I've worn mine at 8 degrees (F) and been perfectly toasty. I think he charges $11 for them. He also makes really good, inexpensive other winter commuting clothes. Highly recommended. http://www.foxwear.net/

While I am a big advocate of Lou, in this case I say go into any sporting goods or outdoor shop and buy a polartec without having to wait for one to arrive. I have one that works well.

I also have a merino wool one that is good when it is not too cold.

IknowURider 12-16-10 09:20 PM

I hate balaclavas. They either constrict your jaw or you have to breathe through the fabric.

1. Poly pro beanie or hat (thicker one for colder

2. Neck gaiter Polypro

3. A strip of polypro fleece or even just some spandex cut from a pair of tights to drape down the sides of your nose and cheeks. You can adjust this well . Sometimes I'll pull it down then pull it back up if it gets windy.

Advantages: better adjusting and breathing. Much more comfortable. The other day I draped a wool middle eastern style scarf over my head and under my helmet, and that worked well too. A bit more adjustment is availiable in the neck area with that as well.

Try "bag Balm" on your face with the above system. I can ride in anything with that.

That Linux Guy 12-16-10 09:20 PM

I recently got a balaclava and I love/hate it all at once.

Mine is pure polyester so wind-blocking is out of the question. It's also tight fitting, something I never cared for on my face. It also messes up my hair but that's par for the course with any hat. I notice my nose running more, it can be a bit suffocating when breathing heavy, and my glasses fog up while using it.

It does keep reasonably warm down into the 20's for me though. And it scares the young kids I pass on the way to work sometimes. That's amusing at least. However, even if you're just running into the gas station for one thing, take it off. Almost had a silent alarm hit because I needed AAA batteries in a rush.

dehoff 12-16-10 10:29 PM


Originally Posted by Ember (Post 11943349)
I have a Serius Ultra Clava

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00...ef=oss_product

This clava has worked for me from 40 to at least 9 degrees. You can move the face covering down when you get too warm. It's got a wind blocking, too. I highly recommend it, as my face has not been cold since I started wearing it.

I have a Seirus Combo TNT. They make really nice stuff at a decent price.

http://www.amazon.com/s/ref=nb_sb_no...bo+tnt&x=0&y=0

Fleece lower portion, neofleece(close to neoprene but more comfy on the face) facemask, and a thin Thermax top. If the temps dip below zero I can add a beanie without adding a lot of bulk.

geetlord 12-17-10 09:55 AM


Originally Posted by flyingWeez (Post 11942063)
I have an Under Armor balaclava and I am very pleased with it. I've never used it in 12 degree weather mind you, but for 30 or so here in Georgia it works nicely.

http://www.amazon.com/Under-Armour-M...2514728&sr=8-1

+1 I've used mine down to temps of -5 F

hubcap 12-17-10 10:59 AM


Originally Posted by IknowURider (Post 11945481)
I hate balaclavas. They either constrict your jaw or you have to breathe through the fabric.

I don't think you have found the right balaclava. If it is constricting your jaw, then you need a larger one or one that is constructed of different material. You don't have to breath through it if you don't want too. The same applies with a neck gaiter. Some balaclavas and gaiters have a small area with more porous material around your mouth/nose area to allow for easier breathing. I have only found this necessary for the gear made with windproof membranes. And I have already said that a windproof balaclava is way too hot for me regardless of the temp.

hubcap 12-17-10 11:01 AM


Originally Posted by TGVZG (Post 11943839)
I have used a few, but the one that fits best snugly around my face is the Pearl Izumi Barrier model. The only draw back with the tightness of the balaclava, is that if you wear thick templed cycling glasses (Specialized Helix in my case - has prescription insert), the elastic puses the glasses temples against your face. for a short, one hour ride, its not realy so bad, but I rode last Sunday from Prospect Park, Brooklyn, to Stricly's bike shop in NJ, and back... my temples still hurt when I chew... I would sugest making holes on the sides of the Balaclava, for tghe temples to slide through. However, this must be done using hot scissors, that quickly melt the openning, to prevent the elastic fabric from unraveling.
Another issue with wearing cycling glasses with a balaclava, is that wind enters aroun temples, making it quite noisy. This can be solved by suffing cotton balls around the temples.
The Pearl Izumi Barrier balaklava is windproof, covers neck well, and is ergonamicaly constructed. I use it daily in Prospect Park, and its mighty chilly these days!

Are you wearing the arms of your glasses under your balaclava? If so, that is your problem. Put the balaclava on first, then put your glasses on with the arms on the outside of the balaclava material.

mkeller234 12-17-10 11:14 AM

I want to thank everyone for their replies, I haven't had the time to read through each one just yet but I definitely will.

So far the Underarmor and the Serius ones look pretty good. I think I will stop at Dick's sporting goods sometime this weekend.

Thanks again everyone.

Spudd 12-17-10 12:15 PM

I have this one:
http://www.mec.ca/Products/product_d...34374302883734

I like it. I would definitely look for one where you can adjust how you wear it depending on the conditions. If it's warmer out I can pull it under my chin, and if colder, I can wear it on the face for more protection.

seeker333 12-17-10 01:40 PM

It's not a full face balaclava, which I don't need for riding, but I've used the OR Peruvian Hat for years.

Fits well under helmet, blocks wind with Windstopper fleece.

http://www.campmor.com/outdoor/gear/Product___95301

PaulRivers 12-17-10 01:42 PM


Originally Posted by hubcap (Post 11947155)
You don't have to breath through it if you don't want too. The same applies with a neck gaiter. Some balaclavas and gaiters have a small area with more porous material around your mouth/nose area to allow for easier breathing. I have only found this necessary for the gear made with windproof membranes. And I have already said that a windproof balaclava is way too hot for me regardless of the temp.

It sounds like you haven't had experience with trying to breath through a windproof balaclava because you don't use them.

It's a major pain.

Sigurdd50 12-17-10 08:31 PM

I got a Gore Wind something... pretty nice. has a grid for the mouth...easier to breathe. NOt too heavy

bikester62 12-20-10 08:12 AM

I'm still trying to solve the glasses fogging up business. I'll try putting the arms of the glasses outside the fabric. I've been using a balaclava. I also wear a ski goggle over my glasses. This weekend I bought a Serius face mask with a nose hole and little perforations over my mouth. Hmm. It was no better. The glasses still fogged up.

rumrunn6 12-20-10 08:37 AM

I got one from the hunting dept at Dicks Sporting Goods last year that I was very happy with. it had a single large opening for both eyes just big enough for my safety glasses; a hole for my mouth and a special fabric to cover the bridge of my nose. I found it imperative to cover the bridge of my nose cuz it also covered the top part of my cheeks which is where the sinuses are located I think. I did trim the length of the neck though cuz it was too long

AdamDZ 12-20-10 08:58 AM


Originally Posted by flyingWeez (Post 11942063)
I have an Under Armor balaclava and I am very pleased with it. I've never used it in 12 degree weather mind you, but for 30 or so here in Georgia it works nicely.

http://www.amazon.com/Under-Armour-M...2514728&sr=8-1

I'll give this one a shot. I heard good things about it. This will be my third balaclava. I only like the thin one I have, I forgot who makes it but it's too thin when it's less than 30F and windy. See below.


Originally Posted by Ember (Post 11943349)
I have a Serius Ultra Clava

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00...ef=oss_product

This clava has worked for me from 40 to at least 9 degrees. You can move the face covering down when you get too warm. It's got a wind blocking, too. I highly recommend it, as my face has not been cold since I started wearing it.

I have this one too, it's warm, breathable and has a grid of holes for easier breathing but I find the piece that goes over the nose very uncomfortable, it either puts too much pressure on my nose or slips down.


Originally Posted by JPprivate (Post 11943553)
Yeah, don't laugh, I did that once, and the clerk was really happy when I took it off and looked quite "normal" ;)

LOL, I walked into a Post Office once. Although I had my bike with me, but people still gave me looks. I realized, took it off and said "sorry!"

seenoweevil 12-20-10 12:28 PM

I have several silk balaclavas from Wintersilks.com I think and a couple of fleece ones from various places. I just use the silk ones anymore. They are very thin, easy to rinse out and hang dry while I'm at work before the ride home, and if I need a little more on the ears(under about 30f and windy) I wear clamp on earmuffs over them.

mkeller234 12-20-10 01:33 PM

Just to follow up here. I read through the posts the other day and ended up buying a Serius Balaclava, I like the idea that I can move part if I get too hot. It looks promising in the warmth department, I will be able to test it later today during my commute. It wasn't the cheapest at 29.00 but it was close by so I payed a bit for convenience.

Thanks again, the help is much appreciated!

nice_marmot 12-20-10 02:08 PM

I picked up a Mountain Hardwear balaclava at REI a couple years back, and I love it (for skiing, anyway). It's some kind of spandex/fleece combo, so the inside is soft while the outside repels water. Thin enough to fit under the helmet, and it's got enough give that I can comfortably slide down the mouth covering under my chin if I want. You should be able to find one for under $30 -- I think it was closer to $20.

hubcap 12-20-10 02:43 PM


Originally Posted by PaulRivers (Post 11947847)
It sounds like you haven't had experience with trying to breath through a windproof balaclava because you don't use them.

It's a major pain.

Hi Paul,

I normally like your posts, but this one needs a response since you obviously did not read my post with any care.

I agree that windproof membranes make breathing difficult if you pull them up over your mouth and nose, that is why I mentioned windproof products that have an area for your nose and mouth that make it easier to breath. I have indeed tried using windproof materials (neck gaiters) without sections of breathing fabric and it just does not work for me.

Paul, if you have found another way to comfortably use those products tight up against your mouth and nose, please let us all know.

PaulRivers 12-20-10 03:07 PM

hubcap - you're right, I have no idea how I missed that one (important) sentence where you said "Some balaclavas and gaiters have a small area with more porous material around your mouth/nose area to allow for easier breathing" - I can only suggest that perhaps I had a total brain fart, lol.

You're right, I obviously missed an important part of your post, and my response was really kind of ridiculous now that I realize I missed that part. My apologies. I can only say that I think this cold weather, short days, and lack of sunlight must be affecting my brain...

hubcap 12-20-10 03:22 PM

No problem Paul. I will continue to look forward to reading your posts as an experienced bicycle commuter.

You folks up in the MN area usually deal with more winter than us in Chicago anyway and I need your advice to stay comforatable through the cold months.

mkeller234 12-21-10 12:59 AM

Well, I used the Serius Balaclava tonight and had a problem with it. The material at either side of my eyes bunches up and and sits away from my face. The wind flows right in, and I can hear it moving past my ears much like a helmet does. I got a large, maybe I should have gotten a medium?

hubcap 12-21-10 09:25 AM


Originally Posted by mkeller234 (Post 11962608)
Well, I used the Serius Balaclava tonight and had a problem with it. The material at either side of my eyes bunches up and and sits away from my face. The wind flows right in, and I can hear it moving past my ears much like a helmet does. I got a large, maybe I should have gotten a medium?

Heavier weight material like that in the Serius will not conform as well to your face as a lighter fleece or polypro fabric that has elastic lined openings. I think the Serius would likely work well if you are using goggles, but I can't imagine the conditions in which I would want to be riding with that over my head anyway. I use a windproof neck gaiter with mesh at the nose and mouth when it is really cold. The gaiter pairs well with a lighter watch cap style hat under my helmet.

tarwheel 12-21-10 09:27 AM

I've been very satisfied with my Craft balacava, riding in temps as low as the mid-teens F.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 08:59 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.