Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Commuting (https://www.bikeforums.net/commuting/)
-   -   single speed or multispeed? (https://www.bikeforums.net/commuting/819099-single-speed-multispeed.html)

mrund3rd09 05-18-12 02:50 PM

single speed or multispeed?
 
I haven't visited this forum in a while, and this question probably has already been asked numerous times, but do you ride a single speed to work/school, or multispeed?

I ride a multispeed, but I only use 2 gears out of the 15 that I have, so I might as well switch to a single speed. Right now, I'm just reading up on some things by Sheldon to get familiar with the single speed, and how I would go about making that conversion. But while I'm at it, I'm just curious how many people prefer single speed and how many people prefer multispeed.

ThermionicScott 05-18-12 02:55 PM

I use both, an 18-speed road bike and a fixed-gear, in equal amounts for my commuting. Love 'em both!

HardyWeinberg 05-18-12 03:07 PM

also both

CliftonGK1 05-18-12 03:09 PM

I have 3 working bikes, all are singlespeed.
I've got a geared bike on the way for playing around at the MTB park.

Doohickie 05-18-12 03:24 PM


Originally Posted by mrund3rd09 (Post 14242112)
I ride a multispeed, but I only use 2 gears out of the 15 that I have, so I might as well switch to a single speed.

No, you should switch to a two-speed.


I ride around a lot on my single speed fixed gear bike. But when I ride to work I take my 21-speed hybrid. There are several reasons for this: 1. I carry extra weight of my clothes, lunch, towel, etc.; 2. I have to climb several hills on both the way to and from work; 3. I almost always return in a headwind, and when I'm tired from the 17 or so mile ride into work and hop back on the bike for the return trip, plus carrying the weight and all the rest of that, I enjoy using the drops on the wind (I installed drops on my hybrid; the FG has a straight bar).

If your commute isn't hilly, windy, or particularly long, and/or you don't carry much, you may want to go with a single speed.

pkulak 05-18-12 03:27 PM

I commuted on a SS for a while, but it started to really hurt my knee. I've got 3x10 now and I'm never going back. The only benefit I can see is in maintenance, and I just don't care about a bit more of that.

somedood 05-18-12 03:27 PM

My commuter has 3x8 = 24 gears. My normal commutes use about 9-10 combinations.
My road bike has 3x9 = 27 gears. A normal ride I'll be using about 16 combinations.

I like my geared bikes.

mrund3rd09 05-18-12 03:30 PM

seriously? 16 different gear combinations?

ThermionicScott 05-18-12 03:44 PM


Originally Posted by mrund3rd09 (Post 14242281)
seriously? 16 different gear combinations?

The world may be flat in "Ron Paul", but it isn't everywhere else. :p

BarracksSi 05-18-12 03:46 PM

On my normal route, I could get along with a singlespeed. Not much slope at all in either direction.

This morning, I rode across the river to meet up with a coworker to "bike-pool" with him. With a bridge on the way, I was glad to have multiple gears.

You might as well ask, "Is your route hilly or flat?"

mrund3rd09 05-18-12 04:03 PM


The world may be flat in "Ron Paul", but it isn't everywhere else. :p
like I said, I hadn't visited this forum in a while.

-----

Also, I have two bikes. One of them is a fuji del rey with a horizontal dropout that will be good for a single speed. I can always ride my multispeed on windy/long distance days.

caloso 05-18-12 04:27 PM

Both. I happened to ride my fixed gear today. I have a very, very, very flat commute.

gmt13 05-18-12 07:04 PM

I ride both - about equally. My multispeed only has 2 gears, though. Does that really count?

-G

Zephri 05-18-12 08:56 PM

I ride both, depends on the day, the weather and how I'm feeling.

Mos6502 05-18-12 09:08 PM

It's good to have a low gear.

Scooby214 05-18-12 09:11 PM

The closest thing I have to a single speed is my 3 speed, which is geared low. We have too many days with strong south winds for me to go single speed. My evening commute today was 13.75 miles of 30 mph headwind. I used my middle gear, which is about 50 gear inches, for most of the commute. On days with lighter wind, I cruise in high gear, which is only about 70 gear inches on my bike. This morning's commute was with a lovely tailwind, so I almost wished I had a higher 4th gear.

john4789 05-18-12 09:32 PM

Fixed. Never going back for commuting.

devianb 05-19-12 01:05 AM

Most of the time I am using a certain gear. I did once buy a single speed hub conversion to try it out. I didn't like it. Those extra gears really come in handy.

mrund3rd09 05-19-12 09:36 PM

I suppose I will stay with my multispeed, even though I never use more than 3 gears on it. Maybe I can change my front sprocket to a single gear. I just don't like extra things on my bike I'm not going to use, pet peeve.

Igo 05-19-12 09:43 PM

I live west of Denver.

ThermionicScott 05-19-12 09:54 PM

In all seriousness, you should buy/build a single-speed/fixed-gear bike to supplement the one you already have. Single-speed riding widens your power-band, and fixed-gear can help break some bad habits. And it's fun. :)

somedood 05-19-12 11:14 PM


Originally Posted by mrund3rd09 (Post 14242281)
seriously? 16 different gear combinations?

Yeah. There are a ton of climbs in this area so I'm in the 1st chainring in the way up, and 3rd on the way down. My cassette is pretty tightly packed too so I change gears in back somewhat often to keep cadence the same.

My commute has a decent hill which is mostly where i shift. If it were flat 3 speeds would probably be fine on that bike.

catonec 05-19-12 11:54 PM

2 Attachment(s)
if you have a multi geared bike, and you find a gear combination which is the perfect, all around, never need to change out of it gear, then just dont shift, it will be like a single. these are the only single speed bike ive ever owned
http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=251265http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=251266

RGNY 05-20-12 04:39 AM

both.

commute on rural county route and gravel access road with long rolling hills: 2x10 CX bike.

urban commute to other office: fixed.

Monster Pete 05-20-12 05:50 AM

I have a 3-speed bike, and a lot of the time I ride in 3rd gear. I wouldn't want less though, it's nice to have a couple of options. Of course, with a 15-speed bike there may only be around 9 distinct gears that are usable. Several gears may be near-duplicates of other gears, and you shouldn't use the 'crossover' gears anyway.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 03:51 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.