Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Commuting (https://www.bikeforums.net/commuting/)
-   -   I am haveing a hard time figureing out sizes (https://www.bikeforums.net/commuting/828487-i-am-haveing-hard-time-figureing-out-sizes.html)

windhchaser 06-27-12 11:32 PM

I am haveing a hard time figureing out sizes
 
ok on bikes direct this link says http://www.bikesdirect.com/products/..._xiii.htm#size i should ride a 46 cm
but this link says a 54 http://www.bikesdirect.com/products/roadsizing.html im 5 foot 5 inches with my riding shoes on and a book under my crotch its like 30 to 31 inches

megalowmatt 06-27-12 11:50 PM

It's because the Dawes Lightning has a sloping top tube. In the second link you provided it specifically says those measurements are for bikes with straight top tubes.

It states"
(These are ball-park measurements are for most typical road bikes with straight cross bars/top tubes
- please refer to the model-specific geometry before making a decision)"

Personally I'm not sure how I would I would categorize you at 5'5" with a 31" cycling inseam...


You may be better off at a bike shop.

bragi 06-28-12 01:40 AM


Originally Posted by windhchaser (Post 14415095)
ok on bikes direct this link says http://www.bikesdirect.com/products/..._xiii.htm#size i should ride a 46 cm
but this link says a 54 http://www.bikesdirect.com/products/roadsizing.html im 5 foot 5 inches with my riding shoes on and a book under my crotch its like 30 to 31 inches

Maybe this will help:

http://www.ebicycles.com/bicycle-tools/saddle-height

acidfast7 06-28-12 02:42 AM

what about the Denali?

no1mad 06-28-12 07:38 AM


Originally Posted by acidfast7 (Post 14415283)
what about the Denali?

OP still has it. The OP was going to save up a grand before 'upgrading', then decided to pull the trigger on a BD bike now.

OP- just save up a bit and buy from the LBS. They will be able to eyeball your positioning and make adjustments to fine tune the bike to you.

debit 06-28-12 08:34 AM


Originally Posted by no1mad (Post 14415766)
OP- just save up a bit and buy from the LBS. They will be able to eyeball your positioning and make adjustments to fine tune the bike to you.

Seconding. And most shops will be accommodating about future adjustments and/or modifications. My bargain bikes have ended up costing me almost as much as a new one when all was said and done.

no1mad 06-28-12 08:56 AM

While stand over height is an important measurement, there are a whole lot more things that you may not be aware of that goes towards a proper fit. The frame itself will get you close, but then the following can be 'tweaked' for fit/comfort:

-seat post height
-saddle positioning on the rails
-saddle tilt
-crank arm length
-stem length
-stem angle
-width of the handlebars
-sweep and/or rise of the handlebars

himespau 06-28-12 09:05 AM


Originally Posted by windhchaser (Post 14415095)
ok on bikes direct this link says http://www.bikesdirect.com/products/..._xiii.htm#size i should ride a 46 cm
but this link says a 54 http://www.bikesdirect.com/products/roadsizing.html im 5 foot 5 inches with my riding shoes on and a book under my crotch its like 30 to 31 inches

For a true cycling inseam you want to be barefoot.

Try this on for size.

windhchaser 06-28-12 12:55 PM

im just researching now.. Im crazy as hell on buying something. Like i said in another post it took me many months to finally pick my camera. And at the end it was so close between a canon and the sony i got. My denaili is a odd duck its says its 22.5 inches and it feels like its my corect size. Top bar may be a tad high but it feels comfy matter fact i think i have to raise the seat. Ps took me forever to pick my mp3 player to .Maybe im ocd or something

gerv 07-01-12 12:31 PM


Originally Posted by windhchaser (Post 14417278)
iPs took me forever to pick my mp3 player to .Maybe im ocd or something

I went through a phase like that with MP3 players. Came to the conclusion I didn't need one. :)

jeffpoulin 07-01-12 01:45 PM

I'm about the same size as the OP and my bikes range from 50cm to 54cm, but they all fit the same. The top tube length, whether it's sloping or straight, tube angles, spacers under the stem, seat back position, etc... all play an important role in fit too. When I buy a new bike, I determine fit with 3 measurements:

1) a standover height of around 77cm at the middle of the top tube
2) 62cm horizontal distance from the center of the handlebars to the center of the seat post
3) a 2cm drop from the top of the saddle to the top of the handlebars with at most 4cm of spacers under the stem (I prefer 0-2cm, but will go up to 4 if I have to).

Once I have those to within 0.5cm or so, I know the bike will fit. On some frames (like my crosscheck), that happens with the 50cm frame size. On others (like my audax bike), it's 54cm. Most bikes have frame specs that let you calculate these measurements by using a little trigonometry. I bought my last 2 bikes based on calculated size only (didn't test ride them), and they fit perfectly.

no1mad 07-01-12 01:57 PM


Originally Posted by jeffpoulin (Post 14428368)
I'm about the same size as the OP and my bikes range from 50cm to 54cm, but they all fit the same. The top tube length, whether it's sloping or straight, tube angles, spacers under the stem, seat back position, etc... all play an important role in fit too. When I buy a new bike, I determine fit with 3 measurements:

1) a standover height of around 77cm at the middle of the top tube
2) 62cm horizontal distance from the center of the handlebars to the center of the seat post
3) a 2cm drop from the top of the saddle to the top of the handlebars with at most 4cm of spacers under the stem (I prefer 0-2cm, but will go up to 4 if I have to).

Once I have those to within 0.5cm or so, I know the bike will fit. On some frames (like my crosscheck), that happens with the 50cm frame size. On others (like my audax bike), it's 54cm. Most bikes have frame specs that let you calculate these measurements by using a little trigonometry. I bought my last 2 bikes based on calculated size only (didn't test ride them), and they fit perfectly.

How long did it take you to be able to do this, as in how many frames? OP is on his second big box BSO and is currently contemplating his first BD purchase. I'm sure it'd ease his concerns some if he knew he could nail the fit this time.

windhchaser 07-01-12 02:03 PM

the bike im riding now is 22.5 inches.And it feel right to me. but every chart says it is to big

jeffpoulin 07-01-12 02:07 PM


Originally Posted by no1mad (Post 14428402)
How long did it take you to be able to do this, as in how many frames? OP is on his second big box BSO and is currently contemplating his first BD purchase. I'm sure it'd ease his concerns some if he knew he could nail the fit this time.

I went through 4 bikes before I had the fit measurements nailed down. However, if his current bike fits him well, he can use it to take his baseline measurements and compare it to the different BD models. If it doesn't fit him well, then I would suggest a proper bike fit session and test ride at the LBS.

windhchaser 07-01-12 02:11 PM

the only part that dont fit is the top bar is a bit high.as i am touching it when i straddle the bike. i pretty much need to buy online since my budget is still low

windhchaser 07-01-12 02:14 PM

there are the 2 bikes im looking at http://www.bikesdirect.com/products/...ntnoir_xii.htm and http://www.bikesdirect.com/products/...record_xii.htm

no1mad 07-01-12 02:19 PM

Then save up until you can buy at the LBS. Otherwise, you run the risk of experiencing the same thing over again....

Hold on a sec, I just remembered you claim to be a tad short for guys, right? Like 5'5"? Don't take this wrong way, but maybe you ought to check out the ladies frames- a bunch of guys ride 'em (called 'mixte' frames). Just an option to consider.

ThermionicScott 07-01-12 02:24 PM


Originally Posted by no1mad (Post 14428468)
Then save up until you can buy at the LBS. Otherwise, you run the risk of experiencing the same thing over again....

+1. Keep working on that $1000 goal.

And I'm not sure if I've voiced this in another of your threads, but I touch the top tube on my road bike. Having 1-2" of standover clearance is way overrated.

windhchaser 07-01-12 02:24 PM


Originally Posted by no1mad (Post 14428468)
Then save up until you can buy at the LBS. Otherwise, you run the risk of experiencing the same thing over again....

Hold on a sec, I just remembered you claim to be a tad short for guys, right? Like 5'5"? Don't take this wrong way, but maybe you ought to check out the ladies frames- a bunch of guys ride 'em (called 'mixte' frames). Just an option to consider.

yes im around 5 foot 5 but very long limbs for my size.kinda like a monkey lolol.

windhchaser 07-01-12 02:26 PM


Originally Posted by ThermionicScott (Post 14428493)
+1. Keep working on that $1000 goal.

And I'm not sure if I've voiced this in another of your threads, but I touch the top tube on my road bike. Having 1-2" of standover clearance is way overrated.

i just wish the lbs was at least close to the price you can get online


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:23 PM.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.