Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Commuting (https://www.bikeforums.net/commuting/)
-   -   Cleats vs Traffic (https://www.bikeforums.net/commuting/850936-cleats-vs-traffic.html)

wolfchild 10-20-12 07:40 AM


Originally Posted by tractorlegs (Post 14861047)
It's like arguing the difference between road tyres and mountain bike tyres.

LOL, Or arguing about singlespeed vs gears, backpack vs panniers, messenger bag vs backpack. It never ends. Every person needs to follow their own path and do what works best for them.

Mark Stone 10-20-12 07:44 AM


Originally Posted by wolfchild (Post 14861140)
LOL, Or arguing about singlespeed vs gears, backpack vs panniers, messenger bag vs backpack. It never ends. Every person needs to follow their own path and do what works best for them.

+1:)

silmarillion 10-20-12 08:35 AM


Originally Posted by Rick@OCRR (Post 14818746)
I use Shimano (mountain bike type) SPD's on my commute bike (DaHon folder) and I would recommend them for the OP (as have others above) but the other pedal I would recommend is the Crank Bros. Egg-Beater.

I ride Egg-Beaters on my fixed gear bike and find them very easy to get into, esp. because I have to hit a moving target when riding the fixed gear, i.e. 4 positions to click-in as opposed to just 2 with the SPD's.

Rick / OCRR

+1

I do exactly the same thing. I have a pair of Lake MTB shoes that work great and keeps me from grinding the cleat on the pavement. I also have egg beaters on my SS/FG and so far I love it.

Besides, egg beaters are simply some of the best mud-shedding pedals out there. Not that this is an issue on the road, but you could walk through the mud and still clip in to them.

rex_kramer 10-20-12 08:50 AM

I went to SPD with double-sided MTB pedals and a Shimano MT32L MTB shoe. I've never had a problem with quick starts/stops or getting off the line quickly with this set-up. My bike is a hybrid anyway, so it doesn't look too funky.

Carley P. 10-20-12 07:53 PM

SPD's are the way to go. I have eggbeaters and have a pair of mountain shoes and a pair of skate-style shoes that I can walk in without the cleat scratching floors. It's easy to clip in and out because they're double sided pedals. Also, if I want don't want to clip in I don't have to. With mountain shoes and (especially) those skate-style shoes I have, my feet won't slip off even if I'm not clipped in.

The shoes I have are something like these: http://www.jensonusa.com/!9!44o5KFMU...FY1DMgodenIAog

CptjohnC 10-22-12 06:41 AM


Originally Posted by noglider (Post 14858793)
You could unclip one foot or both feet before you start the trackstand.

I'm still terrible at it. That's probably because I'm good at keeping one foot clipped in and leaning on my other foot, then taking off and clipping the other foot in very quickly.

The biggest problem I see with trackstanding is that it appears to cause motorists some anxiety in terms of what the cyclist is likely to do -- will they attempt to cross the intersection against the light? are they going to fall? Will they move in an unpredictable direction?

Don't get me wrong: Trackstanding is far better than one of the other alternatives I see a fair amount of here, which is riding in small circles while waiting for the light to change. That's just bad for everyone, I think.

I really don't find clipping in and out to be that difficult, and have never understood folks who trackstand for 20-60 seconds (or more) waiting for the light... and almost invariably creeping closer and closer to the flow of traffic. I get it if the light is 10 seconds or so from changing, but really: The 60 second trackstands I see from time to time? I admire the skills, but I question the judgement.

noglider 10-22-12 07:51 AM

You're right, Captain John! This happened to me yesterday. I was behind a car which was stopped at a stop sign. I saw the driver in her rear view mirror, trying to figure out what I was doing. I realize that a track stand is not something a car driver sees often. Food for thought!

wolfchild 10-22-12 04:13 PM


Originally Posted by CptjohnC (Post 14866570)
The biggest problem I see with trackstanding is that it appears to cause motorists some anxiety in terms of what the cyclist is likely to do --

That's very true, I trackstand a lot when riding my fixed gear and I noticed that most drivers are a little confused when they see me do that, some get angry, some just shake their heads. I still believe that trackstanding is much better then riding around in circles. I've seen this too many times...I'll stop at the light and trackstand and all of a sudden some guy with clipless pedals comes up ahead of me and starts wobblying and riding circles all over the place, they look so dumb when they do, I just shake my
head. If somebody doesn't know how to trackstand then they should unclip and put their foot on the ground and wait, don't wobble and ride around in circles because it just looks dumb and idiotic.

noglider 10-22-12 05:58 PM

Oh whatever. Let people ride the way they want to, as long as it doesn't impinge on someone else's riding.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 05:55 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.