Bardleyrichard

I've been riding with clips and straps for years now. I'm building up a new bike soon, and would love to go clipless. However, one of my jobs involves biking place to place, and walking a mile or two between (I'm a dog walker), so I would want to have the most comfortable shoe for walking while having cleats, too.

I've looked at those DZR and Chrome shoes, and they look okay, but it still seems like most people say the cleats aren't recessed enough so that they don't hit certain surfaces. I feel like I'd need a shoe with deeply recessed cleats to be comfortable.

I'm sure the stiffness of bike shoes in general isn't the best for walking, but I currently wear hard shanked hiking boots anyway, so I'd imagine a dual-purpose shoe wouldn't be crazy stiff/uncomfortable in comparison.

Is my best bet to go for those dual-purpose "casual" shoes, or maybe some MTB shoes?
Does anyone have a favorite clipless shoe for walking?

Gatorfreak

IMO, good cycling shoe and good walking shoe are mutually exclusive. One needs a very firm sole and the other should conform.
I'd go with sneakers. Easier to pedal with sneakers than to walk in clipless shoes (even the mtb ones).

jimblairo

Keens make a very good clipless shoe that is excellent for walking.

KD5NRH

Since I usually don't need to be clipped into the ground to walk, (unless the doc has been overprescribing Norco again) I just go to Walmart and get whatever's comfy. Stick to riding your clip-equipped bike for times when you'll need to walk much, or get a trunk bag and keep some deck shoes in it.

ShartRate

Can't you just carry some walking shoes with you?

KonAaron Snake 

That's what I use too...they've also lasted better than other shoes I've used.

Bardleyrichard

Not really, I mean I could carry them, but it' highly impractical because I'd have to change in and out of shoes every half hour and 20-30 times per day.

From the sounds of peoples' responses here, I should just stick to clips and straps while working.

I still would love to go clipless, maybe just for longer rides, or rides that bringing walking shoes along would be practical. If I go that route, I've have the Shimano m520's in mind for a while...

fietsbob

thing is the SPuD cleat system is just barely recessed in the sole of the shoe,
there is some surface grinding on concrete pavements, as You walk.
if it were more recessed It wouldn't engage the pedals mech, the way they are designed.


Best clipless walking shoes, wouldn't those just be 'Shoes'?

thats what I wear.. Shoes..

Bardleyrichard

Haha, I've sort of thought about this, that is, how far cleats could go before not engaging anymore.

fietsbob

Experiment..
Add rubber to the edges of the sole pocket and find out.

mattgmann

I have a pair of DZR Concubines that are okay to walk in. For those who are okay with compromise they do a decent job in both functions.

noglider 

I wear running shoes that have SPD soles. I wear them all day, nearly every day, whether I'm walking or cycling. You might call these better for walking than for cycling, but shoes that are optimized for cycling hurt my feet. I guess I can't deal with an optimal cycling shoe, even if I wanted to. So these end up being optimal for me for both activities. The only problem is the crunching sound the cleat makes on hard surfaces. I don't mind too much.

kookaburra1701

I would check out Keens - I work in an ER, I'm on my feet all day, and the Targhee II's I have are fantastic and have never let me down. They don't have room for cleats, but the sole is noticeably stiffer than most walking shoes, which makes it easier to pedal. (At least that's what it feels like.) Sometimes with my old sneakers I would get pressure points from my pedals, I don't get anything like that with my Keens.

tdister

https://www.universalcycles.com/shopp...&category=3365


Great shoes, extremely comfy on the bike and off. I've only had tried Crank Bros cleats in them.

phulin

I really like the combination of stiffer-soled running shoes and Power Grips - I use New Balance M565s.

CB HI

No such thing, they are all a trade off between cycling and walking. You just have to decide which is more important to you.

jcmkk3

Pearl Izumi X Project - Not released yet
Specialized Rime

AusTexMurf

I like clipping in SPD's for long commutes, long distance riding, fast recreational riding, and certainly when riding a pedicab. Just can't beat that connected feeling and efficiency, IMHO. For shorter/family rides, summer time and swimming holes, etc., I cycle in Vibram Five Fingers and Shimano A530's.
For lots of cycling and walking, I prefer these SPD setups.
The Keen cycling Sandals

The Pearl Izumi Fuel Running Shoes

And the Keen, Austin model.

droy45

If you're using clips now, there will be no inherant advantage to be had going to clipless. Just more of a PITA clipping and unclipping. Like others have mentioned go for a stiff sole like the keens and keep your clips or possibly go with mountain bike shoes which are stiff and remove the clip which will just get worn out right away from walking the dogs.

KonAaron Snake 

The inherent advantage to clipless is not having to use those God awful straps...and while they aren't the most comfortable walking shoe, my Keen commuter shoes (or the sandals for that matter) are comfy enough to walk a mile in without causing problems. Generally I'm not walking that far when I'm cycling, so a mile is fine.

Traps and straps are more difficult to ride with, harder to get in and out of and annoy the top of my foot. They're silly and I can't understand why anyone has used them since SPDs.

droy45

Your thinking of those old fashioned ones with the nylon strap buckle "thing a ma bobs". I guess what I thought the OP had was the newer style clips that you simply slide into and it holds your shoe in place. I have those on my commuter and they are great for on off in traffic lights etc.

KonAaron Snake 

I am thinking of the ones that I used and got rid of in the mid-80s...I didn't know they'd progressed or changed much.

bhtooefr

I ride a recumbent trike, where some sort of pedal retention is a safety-critical item.

I forget what exact model my Pearl Izumis are - X-Roads, maybe? - but they're reasonably walkable (not the most comfortable, but I have no problems walking all over a store looking for things, when I ride the trike to the store), and were the only cycling shoes I found that weren't torture devices for my feet or fit poorly otherwise.

droy45

Yeah, they are specifically for commuting where you can't keep clipping and unclipping 20 times each way for traffic lights etc. I think the clipless were originally designed for long distance or racing where you clip in, stay in and go with no walking around in the mix.

KonAaron Snake 

I find SPDs very easy to get in and out of - there is no effort required. I don't have much problem walking aorund with them and think they work very well for city riding. The clipless systems like the old Looks and Times were annoying as heck to commute with, but SPDs are just effortless and give you some of the advantages to being clipped with none of the downside. Everything is a compromise, but I think SPDs work pretty decently for most non-racing applications.