Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Commuting (https://www.bikeforums.net/commuting/)
-   -   8 miles, up. (https://www.bikeforums.net/commuting/903979-8-miles-up.html)

buzzman 07-31-13 05:52 PM


Originally Posted by GeoKrpan (Post 15908447)
I totally agree with you on that. There's so much more muscular engagement when standing.

Yes, you're right there. When you stand your muscles are not only doing the work you need to pedal up hill but to support your standing body.

To stand or sit on hills is a much discussed question for racers, tourists and cyclists in general. There is a lot of good information on line about it.

Sheldon Brown has some interesting things to say about it, which may apply to the OP.

I thought about this thread today. I did a long road ride in very hilly country and at the end of a long 3 mile climb, that averaged about 8%, I spun (seated) at a pretty high rpm until just before the crest of the hill, when I shifted up and stood on the pedals and hammered over the top- no doubt its effective and gives power when and if you need it.

I'll repeat that my suggestion is much like what Sheldon Brown suggests- that for the everyday cyclist this may not always be the preferred method of climbing. certainly on those days when you're "feeling your oats" and want to ride like you're in the TDF by all means stand all you want, but for riding to work every day I would suggest learning to effectively climb in a seated position. If you are having problems with a seated position I would check my seat height and bike fit.

Bjforrestal 07-31-13 07:19 PM


Originally Posted by GeoKrpan (Post 15908396)
I don't recall ever hearing a warning about using a 12-34 on a road hub, and, I have seen plenty of people do it. I don't think the "massive" torque of one gear inch is going to matter.


Originally Posted by ThermionicScott (Post 15905480)
If you think the quoted text is marketing hype, you're reading it far differently than intended -- which is that the road hubs (in particular the ratchet mechanism) are about as strong as they need to be for smaller cogs, and 36T pushes them past their design.


Not to mention, the rider, me, apparently isn't putting massive torque on anything hence wanting to drop gear ratios ha!

Bjforrestal 07-31-13 07:25 PM


Originally Posted by buzzman (Post 15910504)

Originally Posted by GeoKrpan (Post 15908447)
I totally agree with you on that. There's so much more muscular engagement when standing.

Yes, you're right there. When you stand your muscles are not only doing the work you need to pedal up hill but to support your standing body.

To stand or sit on hills is a much discussed question for racers, tourists and cyclists in general. There is a lot of good information on line about it.

Sheldon Brown has some interesting things to say about it, which may apply to the OP.

I thought about this thread today. I did a long road ride in very hilly country and at the end of a long 3 mile climb, that averaged about 8%, I spun (seated) at a pretty high rpm until just before the crest of the hill, when I shifted up and stood on the pedals and hammered over the top- no doubt its effective and gives power when and if you need it.

I'll repeat that my suggestion is much like what Sheldon Brown suggests- that for the everyday cyclist this may not always be the preferred method of climbing. certainly on those days when you're "feeling your oats" and want to ride like you're in the TDF by all means stand all you want, but for riding to work every day I would suggest learning to effectively climb in a seated position. If you are having problems with a seated position I would check my seat height and bike fit.

Seat height was too low, did raise it a bit. Realized it after the first day. Want to know the real kicker? I'm getting transferred across town, opposite direction, almost all flat but 6 more miles. Round trip will be 36 miles, a whole different issue now haha!

buzzman 07-31-13 08:26 PM


Originally Posted by Bjforrestal (Post 15910854)
Seat height was too low, did raise it a bit. Realized it after the first day. Want to know the real kicker? I'm getting transferred across town, opposite direction, almost all flat but 6 more miles. Round trip will be 36 miles, a whole different issue now haha!


:lol: the universe is just determined to make you a very fit bike rider with a bike that fits you!


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:33 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.