Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Commuting (https://www.bikeforums.net/commuting/)
-   -   Bicycle Commuting is harder in the U.S. than Europe ? (https://www.bikeforums.net/commuting/978451-bicycle-commuting-harder-u-s-than-europe.html)

TransitBiker 10-27-14 01:24 PM


Originally Posted by Marcus_Ti (Post 17248482)
Most places in USA have no commuting infrastructure for bikes. Roads are made for cars and that is it,and those roads frequently are falling apart. And to make matters better the single-person occupied cars using those roads are of the opinion that bicyclists have zero ight to use those roads and are jagoffs about it.

You want to live close to work? Guess what...you'll be 10 miles away from the nearest grocery store. Unlike most other (read smaller) countries we in the USA have tons of sprawl.

Further living close to work will likely not pay the bills like rent/mortgages/food/insurance etc.

The automobile centric nature of US population centers is a huge problem, especially to motorists, ironically. The more automobile centric a location is, the more unstable it becomes in rough economy. The more prone volume related delays are & crashes to happen as well. When you have a certain balance of transit, walk-ability, and bike conscious laws and mindsets, often not in the city or population center, but farther to where it thins out a bit, people tend to be less stressed and the economy ofthe area less unstable in rough times. In short, transportation equality is a cornerstone of a stable society, both from a civic and economic standpoint. In europe they had small, diverse economies and diverse population center types (metropolis vs remote/rural) that transportation equality was required from roman times on to sustain those economies & communities. Here in the US you have towns where everything is 15+ miles away with no means of leaving aside from automobile. This is not a sustainable or viable community model any longer, because you concentrate consumption, with little to no local production ie made and consumed locally. Sure, some of these towns are surrounded by crops & they export the crops, but little of the crops if any are used locally for local economic exploitation. I feel that if smaller communities were tied together via safe, affordable, frequent regional transit, you would see our economy stabalizem our government become less vitriolic, and people be healthier and less likely to go shoot up a school or off themselves due to anger and.or hopelessness. It;s like they are trapped, in some places.


Originally Posted by jwarner (Post 17248943)
Without diving in deeper in what I consider to be a very broad generalization. I've commuted in Seattle, Anchorage, and Fairbanks in the US. I've also commuted in Frankfurt, in Munich, and in areas around Munich extending into Austria. I much prefer Germany, and found it much easier and safer.

There are roads all around this region with no shoulder and the edge of the pavement is broken down, so riding becomes less about skill and more about hoping you'll see the 3 foot cave-in that is 2 feet deep in time to steer around it AND not get hit by motorists. As i sad above, transportation equality has taken not just a back seat here in the US, it's been left behind entirely.

- Andy

acidfast7 10-27-14 01:56 PM


Originally Posted by TransitBiker (Post 17253931)
I feel that if smaller communities were tied together via safe, affordable, frequent regional transit, you would see our economy stabalizem our government become less vitriolic, and people be healthier and less likely to go shoot up a school or off themselves due to anger and.or hopelessness. It;s like they are trapped, in some places.
- Andy

Have you read about the Garden City concept?

I've recently spent some time in the second Garden City in England and it's an interesting concept.

Garden city movement - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

WGC ... interesting place as most of the pharma/biotech in the UK is located there ... very interesting layout ... very interesting people displaced from London at the beginning that have evolved independently for 50+ years :)

Welwyn Garden City - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Leisesturm 10-27-14 02:59 PM

Has it been mentioned that more than a few U.S. employers actively discriminate against car free job candidates. I know hiring managers personally who require not just valid drivers ID but actual proof of car ownership before they will move forward in the hiring process. If you have to have a car to get the job you want you will probably use it to get to work. Start showing up on a bicycle and you get put on the flake track. That will most definitely NOT be the case in an EU country. That's huge right there.

acidfast7 10-27-14 03:07 PM

1 Attachment(s)

Originally Posted by Leisesturm (Post 17254247)
Has it been mentioned that more than a few U.S. employers actively discriminate against car free job candidates. I know hiring managers personally who require not just valid drivers ID but actual proof of car ownership before they will move forward in the hiring process. If you have to have a car to get the job you want you will probably use it to get to work. Start showing up on a bicycle and you get put on the flake track. That will most definitely NOT be the case in an EU country. That's huge right there.

Of course.

Instead, in some countries one needs a photo, age, sex, marital status, number of children and parental profession instead of a driver's license.

Lebenslauf ? Wikipedia

http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=414372

edit: before you ask, i have no idea what the 10-finger-system is.

energyandair 10-27-14 03:14 PM


Originally Posted by Leisesturm (Post 17254247)
Has it been mentioned that more than a few U.S. employers actively discriminate against car free job candidates. I know hiring managers personally who require not just valid drivers ID but actual proof of car ownership before they will move forward in the hiring process. If you have to have a car to get the job you want you will probably use it to get to work. Start showing up on a bicycle and you get put on the flake track. That will most definitely NOT be the case in an EU country. That's huge right there.

That's great!

They are telling you right up front that they are opinionated morons and that you won't be happy there.

Think of the time and misery you have saved.

wphamilton 10-27-14 03:27 PM

I wouldn't trade my Greenway trip for anything I've seen in the videos of European commuting.

Leisesturm 10-27-14 03:56 PM


Originally Posted by acidfast7 (Post 17254280)
Of course.

Instead, in some countries one needs a photo, age, sex, marital status, number of children and parental profession instead of a driver's license.

Lebenslauf ? Wikipedia

http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=414372

edit: before you ask, i have no idea what the 10-finger-system is.

Why Acid... it sounds as if you might prefer a little American style autochauvanism to what I assume you feel to be excessive personal scrutiny on the part of European employers. I am HWP, heterosexual, have 3 children and my spouse is gainfully employed. I've got better marketability... what about age... when is old tooo old? Not to fear, its a rhetorical question. To see the slightest criticism on your part of the hallowed EU... priceless. May this moment be seared indelibly into my long term memory storage...

acidfast7 10-27-14 03:59 PM


Originally Posted by Leisesturm (Post 17254412)
Why Acid... it sounds as if you might prefer a little American style autochauvanism to what I assume you feel to be excessive personal scrutiny on the part of European employers. I am HWP, heterosexual, have 3 children and my spouse is gainfully employed. I've got better marketability... what about age... when is old tooo old? Not to fear, its a rhetorical question. To see the slightest criticism on your part of the hallowed EU... priceless. May this moment be seared indelibly into my long term memory storage...

Only the less-educated get burdened. The EU provides an excellent for those with highly marketable skills. I was just demonstrating that the argument you made wasn't totally relevant. It does have significant merit, but needs to be refined for effect.

acidfast7 10-27-14 04:08 PM

4 Attachment(s)
I should state the I don't dislike all American things/icons/items/ideologies ... in fact, I was recently here, which was an excellent game!

http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=414389

http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=414390

http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=414391

http://bikeforums.net/attachment.php...hmentid=414392

CrankyOne 10-27-14 05:45 PM


Originally Posted by spare_wheel (Post 17250857)
Large parts of Spain and Italy make London seem like tea and biscuits. Bucharest and Sofia are on another level. And while part of Istanbul is technically not Europe it's one of the worst places I've ever cycled in (then again Turkey is also one of the deadliest places to drive in the world so it's not personal).

My experience in Italy is that drivers are much more considerate (Rome excepted) of people riding bicycles than drivers in the U.S. or London. Interestingly, outside of London, while mostly unappealing for bicycling is much better than the U.S., mostly because drivers are more considerate. It's really kind of fascinating given that lanes are narrow, shoulders or bike lanes extremely rare, and the speed limit is 60 mph. It's scary, but drivers do almost always wait patiently until they can move over to the other lane to pass. Not sure what happens to people once they get within London or Rome.

Both Seville and Barcelona are quite good for bicycling.

I think all of eastern Europe is generally poor though my experiences are limited so I have to rely on others.

CrankyOne 10-27-14 06:18 PM


Originally Posted by cyccommute (Post 17253347)
It's harder in some places and easier in others...just like Europe. I doubt that rural areas in any country have much infrastructure for commuting while urban areas do.

Netherlands has extensive bicycle infrastructure throughout connecting every city, town, and village. Finland, Sweden, and Germany have a moderate amount and then Denmark has a bit.


Originally Posted by cyccommute (Post 17253347)
Further, the cost of buy a residence in any large large city is going to pale in comparison to buying outside of a city. That's why we have so much sprawl in the US. The city center is expensive while further out is usually less expensive. The median US income is around $50,000 which is only slightly higher than the UK income ($43,000). Comparing apples to apples, you couldn't buy a residence in New York City on the median income either. You couldn't hardly buy a residence on a median US income in the City and County of Denver. Average prices in my neighborhood are 10 to 15 times the median income.

You have to be careful saying you're making an apples to apples comparison between cities and especially comparing a variety of cities to a national median. Income isn't equal across the U.S. Three people who have the same job in NYC, WDC, and BHM will usually make different wages with the person in NYC making more than WDC who makes more than the person in BHM makes. That's not to say that everyone in NYC has the same standard of living for the same job as their counterparts in WDC, ATL, MSP, or DEN, but it's not hugely different.

As to the costs of living closer in to further out. Housing costs might be more closer in, but transportation costs can more than make up the difference, especially if someone living in a city can forego a car or two. Most people who live in the suburbs don't have a clue how much extra they spend for motor vehicle xportation (I think it's around $1.90/mile avg). Further, these costs will be skyrocketing in a few years when suburban cities and counties have to start major road replacements (lane miles (and water/sewer) per capita in 'burbs is about 12 - 14 times what it is in urban areas and few have yet to begin major overhauls though this is expected to start hitting around 2025).

spare_wheel 10-27-14 06:27 PM


Originally Posted by CrankyOne (Post 17254715)
My experience in Italy is that drivers are much more considerate (Rome excepted) of people riding bicycles than drivers in the U.S. or London. Interestingly, outside of London, while mostly unappealing for bicycling is much better than the U.S., mostly because drivers are more considerate. It's really kind of fascinating given that lanes are narrow, shoulders or bike lanes extremely rare, and the speed limit is 60 mph. It's scary, but drivers do almost always wait patiently until they can move over to the other lane to pass. Not sure what happens to people once they get within London or Rome.

Both Seville and Barcelona are quite good for bicycling.

I think all of eastern Europe is generally poor though my experiences are limited so I have to rely on others.

Have you tried cycling in Manchester or Glasgow? London is one of the better places to cycle in the UK -- it's comparable to Denver, SF, or Portland in the USA.

I've not cycled in Sevilla for many years but I found Barcelona to be quite unfriendly outside the inner core.

CrankyOne 10-27-14 06:53 PM


Originally Posted by spare_wheel (Post 17254834)
Have you tried cycling in Manchester or Glasgow? London is one of the better places to cycle in the UK -- it's comparable to Denver, SF, or Portland in the USA.

I've not cycled in Sevilla for many years but I found Barcelona to be quite unfriendly outside the inner core.

I've ridden in Glasgow and agree with you and from visits to Manchester I'd guess it would be the same. Most everywhere I went in Barcelona was quite good compared to most U.S. cities.

Sullalto 10-27-14 06:55 PM


Originally Posted by energyandair (Post 17254301)
That's great!

They are telling you right up front that they are opinionated morons and that you won't be happy there.

Think of the time and misery you have saved.

Unless, of course, you don't have your choice of jobs. Then you're screwed.

OneLessFixie 10-27-14 10:34 PM

It's not just transportation equality
 

Originally Posted by TransitBiker (Post 17253931)
As i sad above, transportation equality has taken not just a back seat here in the US, it's been left behind entirely.

Sad indeed. Then again, every other kind of equality has been left behind entirely in America. America makes no bones whatsoever about the fact that it only cares about the 1%.

Dannihilator 10-27-14 10:51 PM

Thread has run its course.

Dannihilator
Forum Moderator.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:10 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.