Looking for new Ti endurance/gravel bike
#26
Junior Member
Join Date: Jan 2019
Location: WI
Posts: 18
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 14 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 2 Times
in
2 Posts
OP: yes, even with the gravel tires it felt too stiff. Not surprising, though, since all the tubing is 2x oversized and like Mstateglfr wrote, the front end is overbuilt. There's zero fork flex, so if you do end up with a Lynskey, I'd suggest looking for another fork that has some compliance. I hear that there exists a carbon fork or two that might have a bit of compliance. The Whiskey 9, maybe?
If you go steel, I did all the readings this summer on that, and short of a custom frame with old school tubing, the Black Mountain Cycles MCD comes the closest and the price is very good. There's a world of difference between the compliance of the MCD with steel fork and the Lynskey with the Lynskey fork in my experience. The MCD is only 1x oversized (compared to an old style steel frame) which gives it nice lateral flex at the BB and fore-aft flex at the fork/head tube junction.
A 1x oversized ti frame with 1 1/8" steerer and steel fork would be optimal, IMO. The main reason to go ti over steel would be that steel dents more easily.
If you go steel, I did all the readings this summer on that, and short of a custom frame with old school tubing, the Black Mountain Cycles MCD comes the closest and the price is very good. There's a world of difference between the compliance of the MCD with steel fork and the Lynskey with the Lynskey fork in my experience. The MCD is only 1x oversized (compared to an old style steel frame) which gives it nice lateral flex at the BB and fore-aft flex at the fork/head tube junction.
A 1x oversized ti frame with 1 1/8" steerer and steel fork would be optimal, IMO. The main reason to go ti over steel would be that steel dents more easily.
#27
Newbie
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2016
Posts: 28
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 7 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 1 Time
in
1 Post
@nellborg - I do have a Redshift ShockStop on order, that might help with the stiffness. Most of these aspects are pretty new to me, I never really paid much attention to anything but fit.
@mstateglfr - Thanks for the recs, those look interesting. Could make a nice secondary (or fifth) bike. The Kinesis came up in a few of the reviews I was reading and it caught my attention with it's Endurance background. Looks like a pretty solid mid-range option.
@Sully151 - Chumba's look nice! I have not heard of them before. If I were doing 95% gravel, I think they would be a good choice. I looked into Why Cycles R+ pretty early on but the measurements threw me off. I'm right in between sizes, but I think I will revisit them since this thread has me absorbing all this geometry.
@chas58 - I think I've seen that video before. Those Ritcheys are pretty nice. I am looking for internal routing though.
@gus6464 - I do like Konas but this doesn't have internal routing. Really dig the look though.
@mstateglfr - Thanks for the recs, those look interesting. Could make a nice secondary (or fifth) bike. The Kinesis came up in a few of the reviews I was reading and it caught my attention with it's Endurance background. Looks like a pretty solid mid-range option.
@Sully151 - Chumba's look nice! I have not heard of them before. If I were doing 95% gravel, I think they would be a good choice. I looked into Why Cycles R+ pretty early on but the measurements threw me off. I'm right in between sizes, but I think I will revisit them since this thread has me absorbing all this geometry.
@chas58 - I think I've seen that video before. Those Ritcheys are pretty nice. I am looking for internal routing though.
@gus6464 - I do like Konas but this doesn't have internal routing. Really dig the look though.
#28
Senior Member
Join Date: Sep 2017
Posts: 7,741
Mentioned: 37 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 6866 Post(s)
Liked 10,827 Times
in
4,621 Posts
@nellborg - I do have a Redshift ShockStop on order, that might help with the stiffness. Most of these aspects are pretty new to me, I never really paid much attention to anything but fit.
@mstateglfr - Thanks for the recs, those look interesting. Could make a nice secondary (or fifth) bike. The Kinesis came up in a few of the reviews I was reading and it caught my attention with it's Endurance background. Looks like a pretty solid mid-range option.
@Sully151 - Chumba's look nice! I have not heard of them before. If I were doing 95% gravel, I think they would be a good choice. I looked into Why Cycles R+ pretty early on but the measurements threw me off. I'm right in between sizes, but I think I will revisit them since this thread has me absorbing all this geometry.
@chas58 - I think I've seen that video before. Those Ritcheys are pretty nice. I am looking for internal routing though.
@gus6464 - I do like Konas but this doesn't have internal routing. Really dig the look though.
@mstateglfr - Thanks for the recs, those look interesting. Could make a nice secondary (or fifth) bike. The Kinesis came up in a few of the reviews I was reading and it caught my attention with it's Endurance background. Looks like a pretty solid mid-range option.
@Sully151 - Chumba's look nice! I have not heard of them before. If I were doing 95% gravel, I think they would be a good choice. I looked into Why Cycles R+ pretty early on but the measurements threw me off. I'm right in between sizes, but I think I will revisit them since this thread has me absorbing all this geometry.
@chas58 - I think I've seen that video before. Those Ritcheys are pretty nice. I am looking for internal routing though.
@gus6464 - I do like Konas but this doesn't have internal routing. Really dig the look though.
If you do your own maintenance (i.e., cable replacement), internal routing is not a plus. And Kona makes some great steel-frames, with complete bikes that are well-equipped at their price points.
#29
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Ohio
Posts: 2,857
Bikes: Road bike, Hybrid, Gravel, Drop bar SS, hard tail MTB
Mentioned: 7 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1218 Post(s)
Liked 298 Times
in
214 Posts
all depends.... if it's a pre built bike. then all you have to do is chase whatever you pull out. Not difficult at all.
#30
Newbie
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2016
Posts: 28
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 7 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 1 Time
in
1 Post
I used some narrow cable guides to help change some internal cables before. Right now I'm leaning towards the gr300 frameset and ordering an Ultegra groupset online, so I will have to do a complete routing once.
#31
Junior Member
On nice advantage of Carver is they can do almost anything you want ... for a reasonable up charge, including internal cable routing. I get custom geometry for a $200 upcharge which is really reasonable.
#32
Newbie
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2016
Posts: 28
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 7 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 1 Time
in
1 Post
Thanks for the reply Mike. Which model did you order? Their Gravel Grinder looks pretty good. Did you ask them about the cable routing? How do you like the bike? Interesting that it's made in a Lynskey factory.
#33
Junior Member
Yes the gravel grinder is made by Lynskey so you get a USA build option but not as many customizations possible as the All-Road.
I also like Carver because they have met the 90 day delivery on each of the previous purchases which is important to me. I have ordered a lot of custom frames over the years from various builders and all have been over 6 months delivery time. I don't think frame builders are a deceitful bunch they simply underestimate their schedule.
The Carvers also communicate really well which a lot of frame builders are not known for. It is important that your builder really understands what you want and is willing to build it.
If you have any questions just email or call Forest or Davis and see if you get the answers you are looking for. They have put up with my questions and crazy ideas. I really need a custom frame so the big geometry issues are much more important to me than the little stuff.
I can't wait to get the new frame.
#34
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: Pittsburgh, PA
Posts: 2,468
Bikes: Co-Motion Cappuccino Tandem,'88 Bob Jackson Touring, Co-Motion Cascadia Touring, Open U.P., Ritchie Titanium Breakaway, Frances Cycles SmallHaul cargo bike. Those are the permanent ones; others wander in and out of the stable occasionally as well.
Mentioned: 7 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 427 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 339 Times
in
229 Posts
I have ridden a Ti gravel bike quite a lot and ride a carbon one now. Especially in gravel where horizontal stiffness is key and vertical compliance need is even greater, Ti just cannot outperform a good carbon frame. With carbon an astute frame designer can use different carbon, thichness, weave directions etc. to get completely different performance characteristics of the frame in different directions. With any metal fabricated frame, the options to do this are really limited; you basically have nearly the same flex and stiffness of a tube in either axis. About all you can do is change the tube shape a bit by ovalizing or hydroforming. Hydroforming is limited to Aluminum though. About the only advantage Ti has over carbon for gravel is it will last forever (and it looks better!). That is a nice thing to have admittedly, but for me that alone is not enough reason to shell out the $ for a Ti gravel bike. Probably not what you want to hear if your heart is set on the allure of a Ti frame, but hey, if you post for opinions, you may get some you do not like...
Last edited by dwmckee; 11-21-19 at 08:44 PM.
#35
Newbie
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2016
Posts: 28
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 7 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 1 Time
in
1 Post
I chose the All-Road rather than the Gravel Grinder because I could get more custom options on the All-Road. I have a Carver MTB and a Carver Fat bike but I just placed the order for the All-Road. I do not want internal cable routing myself but it is listed on the long list of custom options, at least for the All-Road. I did get custom cable routing but outside, because of the setup on my previous gravel bike - the Cinelli Zydeco which I did not like.
Yes the gravel grinder is made by Lynskey so you get a USA build option but not as many customizations possible as the All-Road.
I also like Carver because they have met the 90 day delivery on each of the previous purchases which is important to me. I have ordered a lot of custom frames over the years from various builders and all have been over 6 months delivery time. I don't think frame builders are a deceitful bunch they simply underestimate their schedule.
The Carvers also communicate really well which a lot of frame builders are not known for. It is important that your builder really understands what you want and is willing to build it.
If you have any questions just email or call Forest or Davis and see if you get the answers you are looking for. They have put up with my questions and crazy ideas. I really need a custom frame so the big geometry issues are much more important to me than the little stuff.
I can't wait to get the new frame.
Yes the gravel grinder is made by Lynskey so you get a USA build option but not as many customizations possible as the All-Road.
I also like Carver because they have met the 90 day delivery on each of the previous purchases which is important to me. I have ordered a lot of custom frames over the years from various builders and all have been over 6 months delivery time. I don't think frame builders are a deceitful bunch they simply underestimate their schedule.
The Carvers also communicate really well which a lot of frame builders are not known for. It is important that your builder really understands what you want and is willing to build it.
If you have any questions just email or call Forest or Davis and see if you get the answers you are looking for. They have put up with my questions and crazy ideas. I really need a custom frame so the big geometry issues are much more important to me than the little stuff.
I can't wait to get the new frame.
#36
Newbie
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2016
Posts: 28
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 7 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 1 Time
in
1 Post
I have ridden a Ti gravel bike quite a lot and ride a carbon one now. Especially in gravel where horizontal stiffness is key and vertical compliance need is even greater, Ti just cannot outperform a good carbon frame. With carbon an astute frame designer can use different carbon, thichness, weave directions etc. to get completely different performance characteristics of the frame in different directions. With any metal fabricated frame, the options to do this are really limited; you basically have nearly the same flex and stiffness of a tube in either axis. About all you can do is change the tube shape a bit by ovalizing or hydroforming. Hydroforming is limited to Aluminum though. About the only advantage Ti has over carbon for gravel is it will last forever (and it looks better!). That is a nice thing to have admittedly, but for me that alone is not enough reason to shell out the $ for a Ti gravel bike. Probably not what you want to hear if your heart is set on the allure of a Ti frame, but hey, if you post for opinions, you may get some you do not like...
#37
Junior Member
"I didn't see internal routing options"
Custom Titanium - Carver Bikes
Long list of options down near the bottom
"Internal cable routing: up to $120.00 depending on configuration"
Cheers
Custom Titanium - Carver Bikes
Long list of options down near the bottom
"Internal cable routing: up to $120.00 depending on configuration"
Cheers
#39
Senior Member
I chose the All-Road rather than the Gravel Grinder because I could get more custom options on the All-Road. I have a Carver MTB and a Carver Fat bike but I just placed the order for the All-Road. I do not want internal cable routing myself but it is listed on the long list of custom options, at least for the All-Road. I did get custom cable routing but outside, because of the setup on my previous gravel bike - the Cinelli Zydeco which I did not like.
Yes the gravel grinder is made by Lynskey so you get a USA build option but not as many customizations possible as the All-Road.
I also like Carver because they have met the 90 day delivery on each of the previous purchases which is important to me. I have ordered a lot of custom frames over the years from various builders and all have been over 6 months delivery time. I don't think frame builders are a deceitful bunch they simply underestimate their schedule.
The Carvers also communicate really well which a lot of frame builders are not known for. It is important that your builder really understands what you want and is willing to build it.
If you have any questions just email or call Forest or Davis and see if you get the answers you are looking for. They have put up with my questions and crazy ideas. I really need a custom frame so the big geometry issues are much more important to me than the little stuff.
I can't wait to get the new frame.
Yes the gravel grinder is made by Lynskey so you get a USA build option but not as many customizations possible as the All-Road.
I also like Carver because they have met the 90 day delivery on each of the previous purchases which is important to me. I have ordered a lot of custom frames over the years from various builders and all have been over 6 months delivery time. I don't think frame builders are a deceitful bunch they simply underestimate their schedule.
The Carvers also communicate really well which a lot of frame builders are not known for. It is important that your builder really understands what you want and is willing to build it.
If you have any questions just email or call Forest or Davis and see if you get the answers you are looking for. They have put up with my questions and crazy ideas. I really need a custom frame so the big geometry issues are much more important to me than the little stuff.
I can't wait to get the new frame.
#40
Junior Member
As I noted before it is not finished yet but the geometry is my choice. I have other 62x57 custom frames. After 50 years I now know what works for me and this is it. The trend in the industry has been to increase the top tube length longer and longer over the decades. My hands start going numb with a top tube that is too long for me. So .... That is one reason that Carver is attractive to me. I can get custom geometry for a $200 upcharge.
#41
Newbie
Join Date: Jun 2017
Posts: 2
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 0 Times
in
0 Posts
Hi, did you get the Lynskey? I'm looking at the GR300 right now and I'd love to hear what an owner would say about the internal routing. The position of the entry hold on the bottom of the downtube seems odd and likely to create frame and fork rub, but that's about the only reservation I have. Also, Lynskey's frames seems to weigh more than other ti frames and it may be due to the tubing wall thickness or something. If you got one, do you like the ride feel that ti frames are supposed to have?
#42
Newbie
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2016
Posts: 28
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 7 Post(s)
Likes: 0
Liked 1 Time
in
1 Post
Hi, did you get the Lynskey? I'm looking at the GR300 right now and I'd love to hear what an owner would say about the internal routing. The position of the entry hold on the bottom of the downtube seems odd and likely to create frame and fork rub, but that's about the only reservation I have. Also, Lynskey's frames seems to weigh more than other ti frames and it may be due to the tubing wall thickness or something. If you got one, do you like the ride feel that ti frames are supposed to have?