Bike Forums

Bike Forums (
-   Fifty Plus (50+) (
-   -   That new bike (

stapfam 10-22-11 06:18 AM

That new bike
There is a word for most bikes and that is COMPROMISE. Unless you are buying somewhere near the top end- You have to make a compromise somewhere. But where is it going to be? Frame?- Components?- Groupset? or someother?

I always feel that the heart of a bike is the frame. Get that right and you have a bike you can build on. Most manufacturers have a model that will use the same frame up the range-so a Giant Defy 4 will have the same frame as a Giant Defy 1. But as you go down the range to a 4- The components- Groupset and Wheels will be of a lower standard. I feel that 105 is the lowest groupset that is worth having- so why did I get on so well with my OCR3 that had Sora? I may have been missing a gear or two on the back and the changes may not have been as crisp and sharp as a higher grade but it worked- and worked well. Other components may have been a bit on the heavy side but I doubt that I gained 2lbs on the bike by buying cheap. Where I did make a change though was with regard to the OM wheels. They were OK. They were round and went along the road but when I did change the wheels- it transformed the bike into something about 5 leagues better. That basic bike was my first road bike but it was good enough to adapt me to road riding and it got me up Mont Ventoux in my first year of road riding.

So working on my premise that the frame is the part that matters- I am looking at my next bike and am prepared to go down a level from what I would say is the minimum I can call a "Good" Bike. One of the bikes I am looking at is a Giant TCX. The cyclocross bike and with the grade Of bikes I currently have- I should be looking at the TCX"0". I retire next year so finances are a bit tight at present so at $2470 it may be a bit above my price range for a bike that will still have to be adapted to the use I will be giving it. So looking at the TCX "2" at $1070. Affordable- Only 9 speed Sora but I could get by with that-and it is a couple of lbs Heavier. Let down is going to be those wheels again but they are easy enough to change and I would then have the OM wheels for Foul weather and winter use.

Only problem is- Would I be happy with a "Downgraded" bike? Think I could. The frame is the same-The wheels could be changed to something far better and as for losing a gear By going down to Sora? I only use one gear going uphills- and that is the lowest on the bike so no difference there.

So help--Am I making the right choice for my future riding.

And just in case you don't know me- I have a couple of good Road bikes and an MTB that although old still works but does need replacing (Hence the TCX). But If I want FUN- then out comes the offroad Tandem if I want to worry the ultra fit stoker that is fool enough to volunteer to help me up the hills.

John_V 10-22-11 07:14 AM

That's a nice bike and like you, I am partial to Giant. The TCX 2 has pretty much the same drivetrain that came on my '09 Defy 2. With all the bikes and riding that you do, I don't think any bike is really a "downgrade", just slightly different components. I know that a lot of roadies dislike the Sora shifters, but I actually love mine. I was thinking of upgrading them to Tiagra, so all components are the same, but I have gotten so used to them that I think I will stick with them. Plus, I am sure that the weight of the TCX is going to be lighter than the MTB that you already have, so it looks like a win win situation to me. I would go for it. If I had the storage space, I would love to have more than just two bikes. I may end up building another shed in the back yard just for bikes.

bradtx 10-22-11 07:58 AM

stapfam, The touring bike I referenced to in your other thread has the lowest level of components, many are 16 year old carry overs, that I've built with in years and I'm perfectly happy with it. I've had my D-A roadies and XTR mountain bikes and aside from an exclusive feature or two, weren't a giant leap in performance nor personal enjoyment.

BTW, I too think it's the frame that makes the most difference.


bruce19 10-22-11 08:03 AM

When I buy a bike or motorcycle I always consider how I will use it. To me that's the starting point. For what I do a 14 lb. bike is irrelevant...OTOH a 17 or 18 lb. bike is nice. I won't go on and on but I have to say for my needs a new bike is going to retail for $2-3K. Hopefully I'd get it for less.

John E 10-22-11 08:12 AM

The frame is the bike. Everything else can be upgraded or updated as desired at a later date. Get a frame you like, i.e., one that fits you and your intended application(s).

wobblyoldgeezer 10-22-11 08:23 AM

A sentence to agree with Stap, a sentence to digress
To agree

I have a bike with Tiagra and a bike with Ultegra, and I can't detect the slightest difference in accuracy or crispness of the shift: the differences are that the Tiagra is on a heavier bike with downtune shifters, but that's not a difference in shift quality

To digress

I just costed up a custom build for a comparable bike to my best bike - Niobium steel in the middle, carbon at the corners, full Ultegra, Mavic Ksyrium pros, FSA. 3 times what I paid, and mine is still available as NOS

So, I'd agree with Mr S - slightly lower in the brand chain can be just as good for most of us, and judicious shopping can still find discounted 'top of the chain'

All times are GMT -6. The time now is 10:04 PM.