Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Fitting Your Bike (https://www.bikeforums.net/fitting-your-bike/)
-   -   Ran out of seat post (https://www.bikeforums.net/fitting-your-bike/896967-ran-out-seat-post.html)

STRANA 06-20-13 07:30 PM

Ran out of seat post
 
So I just recenlty (3 weeks ago) back into cycling after many years. I purchased a cannondale Quick 6 XL. I am 6'3" and the sales person at my LBS spent time putting me on different bikes and riding them for fit. I have since found that in fine tuning the seat I am now 2" past the max height on the seat tube and I'm guesssing I need to raise the post a little more. The seat post is 350mm and the largest I have seen for a new seat post is 450mm is this enough? Should I be after the LBS for a poor fitting? Or is it just me?

catonec 06-20-13 08:02 PM

That bike is too small for you even though it is a xl. or you desire a unconventional fit.

a longer seatpost will help with your leg extension but hows your reach??

if you ride with your post above the minimum insertion line you have a very real possibility of destroying your new frame. do not ride it like that.

Im only 5'10 so I dont know what the options are for taller riders but most likely a longer post is not the correct answer.

If you can return the bike and start over you should. You are now more knowledgeable as to how you want your bike to fit and feel.

gluck.

STRANA 06-20-13 08:07 PM

Hmm guess I will make a trip back to the shop. I'm surprised it could actually damafge the frame! I must be right in between though for size as I can barely clear the cross tube on the stand over.

Thank you for the feedback

goldfinch 06-20-13 09:31 PM

Are you sure your seat height is correct?

catonec 06-20-13 09:42 PM


Originally Posted by STRANA (Post 15765903)
... I'm surprised it could actually damafge the frame!....

the minimum insertion point is to assure that the post is at least half way past the top tube intersection. if the post is above the top tube then the weight supported by your seat post (your butt) is transferred to the 2 inch nub of seat tube above the top tube where your seatpost clamp is. that 2 inch section can crack/ bend/ or snap off.

DX-MAN 06-20-13 09:56 PM

Yup, it's shop time again. While a longer post would give you your desired leg extension (you must be REALLY long-legged!), I'm also concerned about the fit of the rest of the bike. (NOTE: Thomson makes a 410mm seatpost....)

Giant makes larger framed bikes; see if your shop deals with them, as well.

STRANA 06-20-13 10:16 PM

I'll take it back but it's been a few weeks I have feeling I'm going to have to make it work there is a 450mm seat post at the Canadian version of REI (MEC). I do have some leg length but I'm a bit tee'd that the LBS didn't see any issue.

zandoval 06-21-13 12:04 AM


Originally Posted by DX-MAN (Post 15766268)
Yup, it's shop time again...

Don't take that seat post indicator lightly...

DX-MAN 06-21-13 06:41 PM


Originally Posted by zandoval (Post 15766503)
Don't take that seat post indicator lightly...

Never!

chaadster 06-21-13 08:58 PM

Wait a minute...how can you barely have standover clearance yet require more than a 350mm seat post? Something is not right...

...maybe you've got really short cranks? I'd think you'd want at least 175mm crank arms, btw.

STRANA 06-22-13 08:18 PM

I went to the shop today and they changed my bike from an XL to Jumbo. Huge difference.

catonec 06-22-13 10:38 PM

nice, thats a lbs you should be happy with. Its been a few weeks since your initial purchase right?

STRANA 06-22-13 10:40 PM

Yes it was over 3 weeks. They really came through.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 07:26 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.