![]() |
Originally Posted by RichardLee
(Post 20325989)
It's bad news actually. If after years of tests upon tests, Helix NOW needs a hand-welder, it casts doubt in the once boasted robotic inert chamber welding process.
It’s good news because you can only justify paying a welder if production welding is happening (or is planned in the very near term). |
Originally Posted by RobotGuy
(Post 20326024)
Every production welding operation needs real welders on staff, robotic operations included... |
Originally Posted by RichardLee
(Post 20326053)
Memory is a little vague on this but I recall one of the 2 staff already hired was a welder (among other skills). Is it still good news if they have more than 1 welder in a tiny but supposedly state of the art automated factory?
If thats good good news to you or bad news, can’t help ya. |
To clarify, what I'm getting at is whether the enormous investment in an inert this or that robotic such and such has turned out dismal. And thus whether they're now falling back to good old fashion hand welding for frames of production bikes.
If so, there are numerous implications particularly for quality consistency and production rate, let alone what happened to all that Kickstarter capital, company finances and viability. Sure it's speculative, but so far there hasn't been absolute confirmation of what was touted since circa mid-2016. |
Originally Posted by RichardLee
(Post 20326115)
To clarify, what I'm getting at is whether the enormous investment in an inert this or that robotic such and such has turned out dismal. And thus whether they're now falling back to good old fashion hand welding for frames of production bikes.
If so, there are numerous implications particularly for quality consistency and production rate, let alone what happened to all that Kickstarter capital, company finances and viability. Sure it's speculative, but so far there hasn't been absolute confirmation of what was touted since circa mid-2016. I’m not vouching for these guys, but you are speculating based on zero staffing knowledge and zero production welding knowledge. This is a silly discussion. In all likelihood, they needed more quality assurance / production oversight and need a welder, not even to actually weld. They just need someone skilled and experienced in welding so they know what they’re looking at. or they tossed the robot out the back door and they need a welder to operate the torch that’s gonna cut it up and turn it into beer can scrap. One can only guess. |
Mystery solved.
Originally Posted by RobotGuy
(Post 20326122)
One can only guess. This is one of those "why didn't I think of it before". Closer examination of that job posting: This position requires top level TIG welding and fabrication skills to assist lead robot TIG weld engineer.
The 2 earlier hires were acquaintances of Peter, one being his teacher, the other I got the impression not a direct acquaintance but possibly through the teacher. So this is the first known job advert for an "outsider". Reading job ads can provide clues to inner workings of a company and upcoming products. Take for example the very secretive Apple corporation. Independent analysts and websites scour patent filings and job ads to deduce what they're working on.. |
Originally Posted by RichardLee
(Post 20326391)
This is one of those "why didn't I think of it before". Closer examination of that job posting:
This position requires top level TIG welding and fabrication skills to assist lead robot TIG weld engineer.
The 2 earlier hires were acquaintances of Peter, one being his teacher, the other I got the impression not a direct acquaintance but possibly through the teacher. So this is the first known job advert for an "outsider". Reading job ads can provide clues to inner workings of a company and upcoming products. Take for example the very secretive Apple corporation. Independent analysts and websites scour patent filings and job ads to deduce what they're working on.. |
Hello,
To further add to this eminently interesting discussion, i work in the machine tool industry (lasers specifically) and can tell you that even if the robotic welder is top notch on paper and was sold to Helix as such, there's always a risk that it does not entirely fulfill the requirements it was bought for. This has to do with not everyone being as good as we think at building machines, then there are the over-zealous or downright disingenuous salesmen and the intrinsically flawed machine designs that can simply never exactly give satisfaction. That being said and on a much more positive note, the mere fact that they have shown the welds and are still having a Robotic TIG Welding engineer in the mix means (to me) that they are leveraging at least to some extent their touted awesome production tool. Then besides having the adequate machine tool, that's only about 60% of the work. A good 40% of the success of a machining step is down to adequate fixturing. And there's often room for improvement there, stiffness, positioning, ergonomy, repeatability....etc. Fixturing is sometimes and art. If your Robotic TIG Welder engineer expert is already busy and/or does not have the honed skills in fixturing, then it makes more than perfect sense to hire a guy to assist him. An experienced jig maker will always be a powerful element of your team. Besides, having two experienced welders, as RobotGuy aptly points out, is the only way to fully appraise how good the output is and troubleshoot when needed. Hopefully my experience will resonate with someone here. |
Oh yes, it resonates !
I so often encountered people thinking that buying a tool will replace knowledge and experience ! It is never the case. Same for this welding process: the robotic tool will increase productivity, may increase the yield but will never replace the knowledge and the experience of a TIG Welding engineer. |
Weekends coming!!! Hope we have some good news! I can’t wait till the day where the first customer gets a bike and a YouTube review to say how epic this bike is or isn’t :) |
This 'waiting' thread is going to out live me.
|
Any New Updates?
Why is everyone so quiet all of a sudden? |
Originally Posted by eselanik
(Post 20347113)
Why is everyone so quiet all of a sudden? |
Originally Posted by Joe Remi
(Post 20347651)
What else is there to say?
|
Originally Posted by DaKineDatFolds
(Post 20349027)
...that the fat lady weighs about 98 LBS.
|
Well it looks like this thread has run its course.
Thanks for playing, everyone!~ |
Due to the request of a member, I've decided to go ahead and re open this thread for those of you who are truly following the update.
One request though... Please keep this clean from chatter that does not relate because those who would like to see actual conversation regarding Helix should not have to fish through to find information. Thank you! |
Yay! Thank you =). Those of us who cannot see the updates appreciate any info posted here so we can follow along on the saga.
|
So to recap, thlast few updates have had some news on finish and logo but have not really provided any insight into progress on production etc..
The update this coming weekend is mooted to be a meatier affair with an update on delivery schedule. |
Originally Posted by Gibsonsean
(Post 20354447)
So to recap, thlast few updates have had some news on finish and logo but have not really provided any insight into progress on production etc..
The update this coming weekend is mooted to be a meatier affair with an update on delivery schedule. |
I'm pretty excited to see the optional finish pics (and hopefully pricing), but it will also be really good to finally hear when the bikes are likely to ship. I'm not sure I'll get mine this year now, since I was not an early backer, and they have a thousand or so bikes to make before mine :/
|
Maybe it's good to not be one of the earliest - if they get feedback, then later iterations can correct for small problems.
|
Originally Posted by linberl
(Post 20355897)
Maybe it's good to not be one of the earliest - if they get feedback, then later iterations can correct for small problems.
|
Wooaahh, hold on a second! People are talking about bikes being delivered with faults and/or getting them earlier than every one else.
Making assumptions that Helix will actually deliver. Let's look at history. A lot of knowledgeable and "industry/in-the-know" folks have been burned by many start-ups in the past. Not just on Kickstarter; but even experienced venture capitalists. I don't have any Helix order. So you may ask why bother posting here at all? I'm concerned about all these people who gave millions and only got promises. I'm concerned about the people buying Kickstarter pledges; if they're getting all the info available. Will Helix go for a 3rd round of asking "investors" for pledges/donations? |
Originally Posted by 1nterceptor
(Post 20357963)
Wooaahh, hold on a second! People are talking about bikes being delivered with faults and/or getting them earlier than every one else.
Making assumptions that Helix will actually deliver. Let's look at history. A lot of knowledgeable and "industry/in-the-know" folks have been burned by many start-ups in the past. Not just on Kickstarter; but even experienced venture capitalists. I don't have any Helix order. So you may ask why bother posting here at all? I'm concerned about all these people who gave millions and only got promises. I'm concerned about the people buying Kickstarter pledges; if they're getting all the info available. Will Helix go for a 3rd round of asking "investors" for pledges/donations? |
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:13 PM. |
Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.