Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   Folding Bikes (https://www.bikeforums.net/folding-bikes/)
-   -   Building two Brompton clones (https://www.bikeforums.net/folding-bikes/1163297-building-two-brompton-clones.html)

Pahana 04-25-20 12:15 PM

I'm late to this discussion so maybe this has been answered. Every once and a while I go to ebay and search Brompton to see what's new. More and more I'm seeing clone ti frames, forks and rear triangles. How is Brompton letting this go on? Can't they stop this. What is going on there. I'm ignorant but this on the surface seems to be easy to stop. I can understand selling parts upgrades but frames seems like copyright infringement.

leinadhok 05-19-20 05:55 PM

Thanks for sharing your build journey.

bugly64 05-22-20 10:26 AM


Originally Posted by Pahana (Post 21438158)
I'm late to this discussion so maybe this has been answered. Every once and a while I go to ebay and search Brompton to see what's new. More and more I'm seeing clone ti frames, forks and rear triangles. How is Brompton letting this go on? Can't they stop this. What is going on there. I'm ignorant but this on the surface seems to be easy to stop. I can understand selling parts upgrades but frames seems like copyright infringement.

Here's an article about such happenings. It's interesting that Dahon sued someone when the Curl is a blatant rip off of the Brompton. https://www.bikebiz.com/folding-bike...-to-be-jailed/

bee-man 05-22-20 03:54 PM


Originally Posted by Pahana (Post 21438158)
I'm late to this discussion so maybe this has been answered. Every once and a while I go to ebay and search Brompton to see what's new. More and more I'm seeing clone ti frames, forks and rear triangles. How is Brompton letting this go on? Can't they stop this. What is going on there. I'm ignorant but this on the surface seems to be easy to stop. I can understand selling parts upgrades but frames seems like copyright infringement.

According to lexology: "The manufacturing is complex and the company designs all of its own tooling. Keeping this know how within the company makes the bike difficult to copy and helps to keep the company a step ahead of potential competitors." I remember Will Butler-Adams saying this in an interview as well.

Some good info here as well:
https://www.gov.uk/government/case-s...perty-brompton

Jipe 05-23-20 04:17 AM

These explanations seems to me at least partially bull****:

And no one would have a clue how we do it. Even if you downloaded all our drawings, it would still take you two years to make a really good bike. By then, we would be producing something different anyway.
says Butler-Adams
The Brompton bike didn't change since more than 10 years !

The only "improvements" were some components changes, part of them to reduce the bill of material, part because the replaced components weren't available anymore.

Most of the "new" components are heavier than their predecessors (crankset, brake levers, shifters...) resulting in a bike weight increase.

All this is the results of a CEO aiming only at profit increase !

Butler-Adams built new company offices with a doubled production capacity... but Brompton sales are stagnating (while the global cycle industry sales are booming).

For remembrance, Andrew Ritchie, left the company disgusted by Butler-Adams company management.

2_i 05-23-20 06:14 AM


Originally Posted by Jipe (Post 21491999)
The Brompton bike didn't change since more than 10 years !

The only "improvements" were some components changes, part of them to reduce the bill of material, part because the replaced components weren't available anymore.

Most of the "new" components are heavier than their predecessors (crankset, brake levers, shifters...) resulting in a bike weight increase.

Yes, I noticed myself this half-full glass!

Jipe 05-23-20 06:54 AM

Its really a pity because the Brompton is an excellent bike and with some minor changes it would become even much better (allowance for wider tires, modern transmission like its done by Kinetics... if a single man company can do all what he does on the Brompton, how is it possible that a company cannot).

AeroNautiCal 07-07-20 06:03 PM


Originally Posted by Jipe (Post 21492131)
Its really a pity because the Brompton is an excellent bike and with some minor changes it would become even much better (allowance for wider tires, modern transmission like its done by Kinetics... if a single man company can do all what he does on the Brompton, how is it possible that a company cannot).

Your "single man company" observation speaks volumes about the management of their current CEO...

BromptonINrio 07-07-20 06:12 PM


Originally Posted by Pahana (Post 21438158)
I'm late to this discussion so maybe this has been answered. Every once and a while I go to ebay and search Brompton to see what's new. More and more I'm seeing clone ti frames, forks and rear triangles. How is Brompton letting this go on? Can't they stop this. What is going on there. I'm ignorant but this on the surface seems to be easy to stop. I can understand selling parts upgrades but frames seems like copyright infringement.


its quite simple: their pattents are expired.
thats why the can make those copycat and walks

mlau 07-27-21 12:20 AM

Sorry, Raxel.

I forgot about this thread. After getting a Brompton, I have to completely agree with you. Excellent fold. Okay ride. Nice luggage options. Horrible, overpriced, unnecessarily proprietary parts. Built like a boat anchor.........and that's a fully upgraded M6R with titanium seatpost, dynos, etc.

I'd love to pick your brain for a possible build around an EasyTi frame


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 06:00 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.