Bike Forums

Bike Forums (https://www.bikeforums.net/forum.php)
-   General Cycling Discussion (https://www.bikeforums.net/general-cycling-discussion/)
-   -   Third bottle cage (https://www.bikeforums.net/general-cycling-discussion/1144905-third-bottle-cage.html)

mstateglfr 05-24-18 09:20 PM

Cheap velcro strap around the bottle and downtube will ensure the cage isn't strained and the bottle wont jump out.

cyccommute 05-25-18 08:01 AM


Originally Posted by jbell_64 (Post 20358739)
Thanks for all the input. Think I'll go stainless.

King. Made in US. Made in Durango, Colorado. Made in a garage in Durango by a grumpy old guy but...damn!

Look at his Iris cages too.

Murray Missile 05-27-18 08:53 AM

I've had a couple bikes with the under the DT bottle cage. I kept it clean by covering it in Saran Wrap until I was ready to use it. I'd switch it out with an empty bottle and then wrap the empty before placing it in the lower cage to make cleanup easier later on.

Cyclcist11023131 05-27-18 09:11 AM

Water
 
Anybody else just throw a couple of bottles in your jersey pockets on a hot day ? Over 90 degrees and I have two on the bike, one in each pocket on my shorts and three on my back. These are all throw away and are used for refills. Then properly disposed. Works for me. No good being thirsty.... Really don’t like hydration/sweat pack. To each his/her/ whatever’s own preference.

one4smoke 05-27-18 06:03 PM


Originally Posted by Bendopolo (Post 20362327)
Anybody else just throw a couple of bottles in your jersey pockets on a hot day ? That’s free, easy, adaptable. Win win...

You fellas sure put a lot of credibility in "jersey pockets."

Kapusta 05-28-18 11:53 AM


Originally Posted by one4smoke (Post 20363150)
You fellas sure put a lot of credibility in "jersey pockets."

+1

Personally I would rather just wear a hydration pack that is actually designed to carry stuff well on my back than shoving my pockets full of water bottles.

That said, as much as I prefer my water in a pack for MTB, on the road I just don't see any reason to carry stuff on my person rather than on the bike.

Dchiefransom 05-28-18 12:34 PM

You could always mount one on the front of the handlebars.

MikeyMK 05-28-18 02:02 PM

Yeah, or two. I can mount five on mine - three on the front bar and one each side of the stem on the inner bar. With straws? Ooh, go on, then.

https://i.imgur.com/OAuKX6v.jpg

Milton Keynes 05-29-18 08:55 AM


Originally Posted by Kapusta (Post 20364326)
+1

Personally I would rather just wear a hydration pack that is actually designed to carry stuff well on my back than shoving my pockets full of water bottles.

That said, as much as I prefer my water in a pack for MTB, on the road I just don't see any reason to carry stuff on my person rather than on the bike.

I've worn a hydration pack while road cycling on long rides, and it's literally been a lifesaver while riding in rural areas with no services, that is, no place to get water. During a hot summer day I sweat so much I can go through two 24 oz. water bottles and a 2 liter hydration pack before I get home. Took the pack along yesterday on a 27 mile ride. Normally I wouldn't need the hydration pack for a short ride like that, but it was so hot out with no wind, and I was on gravel with absolutely nowhere to get water, so the extra water was handy even if I didn't drink it all. The hydration pack has been the best cycling accessory I've ever owned.

lennskii 05-29-18 08:38 PM

Another +1 for King Cages - hold the bottles super securely, don't mark like AL cages and tension strength can be adjusted by bending slightly unlike carbon or plastic cages. Never lost a bottle under the DT.

I rarely need 3 bottles - so I purchased Fabric Cageless Keg and use it on the downtube. If I am touring and need to mount another bottle, I swap out the Keg (put it in the bag) and use a Fabric cageless bottle. All pretty cheap and keeps the bike looking clean.

79pmooney 05-29-18 11:37 PM


Originally Posted by cyccommute (Post 20357504)
While I agree that King Cages are the best (they are on the white bike), the question was about aluminum. Aluminum will work for a very long time. Kings will last a lot longer and they won't leave your bottles black but Kings are a bit expensive...~$20 each.

Those bottles had more than 450 miles on them when I took that picture (they weren't new when I started the tour) including about 200 miles of dirt roads in Ontario and part of the Erie Canal. You can see how clean they are. Bottles in aluminum cages would be dark black under similar conditions.

But ... every aluminum cage I have ever used has broken off the bike and shed the bottle. (Except ones I retired before that happened,) I discovered cracks happening in nearly all my steel cages in the shop and replaced them before they shed a bottle. (Often after decades of use.) Losing a bottle on a screaming descent on a hot day is something I consider a very bad outcome. Yes the OP was talking aluminum but he was also talking of wanting security.

And $20 for a cage is expensive? For a cage that will do its job the next 20 years? I don't blink an eye paying that for that quality. Not for items that are that important. (I keep my mouth shut, but I do laugh rather cruelly on the inside when I see a cage and bottle rolling along the road. And those cages are either aluminum or very light in almost every case.)

Ben

Rollfast 05-30-18 12:14 AM

I just stop at the next place that has water, but then I never leave town.

And I drink that evil diet soda.

cyccommute 05-30-18 07:55 AM


Originally Posted by 79pmooney (Post 20367126)
And $20 for a cage is expensive? For a cage that will do its job the next 20 years? I don't blink an eye paying that for that quality. Not for items that are that important. (I keep my mouth shut, but I do laugh rather cruelly on the inside when I see a cage and bottle rolling along the road. And those cages are either aluminum or very light in almost every case.)

Ben

Lots of people would gladly pay twice (or three times) for something cheap but having it last half (or 1/3rd) as long as paying a lot for something that will last twice or 3 times as long. As the saying goes "buy nice or buy twice".

indyfabz 05-30-18 08:04 AM

I have King cages on my road bike. In what I believe was a very rare occurrence, my ex-GF had one break on her. (Likely caused during transit from the east cost to AZ in a trailer crowded with other bikes.) She mentioned the failure to King when we saw him at the Philly Bike Expo. He was there bending cages. He flipped her a new one for free.

Rollfast 06-04-18 12:49 AM


Originally Posted by cyccommute (Post 20367527)
Lots of people would gladly pay twice (or three times) for something cheap but having it last half (or 1/3rd) as long as paying a lot for something that will last twice or 3 times as long. As the saying goes "buy nice or buy twice".

$5 and I just wire it to the inside of the front basket.

Lazyass 08-17-18 01:02 PM

FYI I came across this on ebay. Kind of cool.

https://www.ebay.com/itm/RockBros-Cy...item58f9a44c2e

https://i.ebayimg.com/images/g/fGYAA...2y/s-l1600.jpg


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:15 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.