Cost to build MTB trails
#27
Been Around Awhile
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Burlington Iowa
Posts: 29,973
Bikes: Vaterland and Ragazzi
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 12 Post(s)
Liked 1,536 Times
in
1,045 Posts
#29
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Sunny Tampa, Florida
Posts: 1,542
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 101 Post(s)
Liked 49 Times
in
41 Posts
Not sure, over at pinkbike maybe. Too plausible to bother with being skeptical for me, high-power executives of a multi-national corporation with 160 miles of trails accessible from downtown aren't riding "Mount Rage Attacker" bikes. And I'd be surprised if none of them had a sense of humor about their brand loyalty.
#30
I think I know nothing.
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: NE PA
Posts: 709
Mentioned: 6 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 233 Post(s)
Liked 290 Times
in
204 Posts
Here where I live in Carbon County PA that's in the Poconos near Jim Thorpe. The "Famous" D&L Rail Trail is supposed to be connected with the Lehigh Canal (Weissport section) making a whopping 57 mile continuous trail which will someday be something like 165 miles. So there is a less than 1 mile gap and a river between the Canal and the Rail Trail just south of JT. Because of the topography there is no easy way to get from Lehighton to Jim Thorpe on a bicycle. Simple solution: build a pedestrian bridge over the river. So in 2014 with the help of the D&L LLC the county had the needed 3.1 MILLION dollars in grant money to build the bridge, which was slated to open in 2016 and bring all kinds of adventure seekers into Jim Thorpe and spend their money.
3.1 million dollars to build a bridge over a 250 foot river. Here we are late 2018 the now 4.3 MILLION dollar bridge is there in all it's glory but needs another Million dollars and another year at least to build on/off ramps and safe passage through the County parking lot in JT. So a 3.1 million dollar 1 mile gap becomes a 5.5 million dollar project that is 3 years at least behind schedule but the D&L LLC is happy because they were able to dedicate the bridge and let RTC Sojurne riders who paid $1000 to make that ride they got to cross the bridge but as soon as the last Sojurne rider cleared the east abutment they barricaded the bridge and that is that. It is an outrage of the 10th order. If it were on schedule and half the original cost it would have been a excess but it's apparently ok because the D&L LLC and the state of PA thinks the county will see so much money spent by adventure seekers from New Your City that they will need to build more banks to store the money. In the mean time the tax payers are looking at this bridge to no where.
Funny but true, in the years 1818-1820 they built the original canal which actually started right at the site of the new pedestrian bridge. Using hand labor 200 years ago they built a 45 mile towpath canal complete with locks and aquaducts in 2 years without heavy equipment just picks and shovels. And toady with all the stuff it takes 4 years to build a 250 foot bridge.
3.1 million dollars to build a bridge over a 250 foot river. Here we are late 2018 the now 4.3 MILLION dollar bridge is there in all it's glory but needs another Million dollars and another year at least to build on/off ramps and safe passage through the County parking lot in JT. So a 3.1 million dollar 1 mile gap becomes a 5.5 million dollar project that is 3 years at least behind schedule but the D&L LLC is happy because they were able to dedicate the bridge and let RTC Sojurne riders who paid $1000 to make that ride they got to cross the bridge but as soon as the last Sojurne rider cleared the east abutment they barricaded the bridge and that is that. It is an outrage of the 10th order. If it were on schedule and half the original cost it would have been a excess but it's apparently ok because the D&L LLC and the state of PA thinks the county will see so much money spent by adventure seekers from New Your City that they will need to build more banks to store the money. In the mean time the tax payers are looking at this bridge to no where.
Funny but true, in the years 1818-1820 they built the original canal which actually started right at the site of the new pedestrian bridge. Using hand labor 200 years ago they built a 45 mile towpath canal complete with locks and aquaducts in 2 years without heavy equipment just picks and shovels. And toady with all the stuff it takes 4 years to build a 250 foot bridge.
Last edited by Thomas15; 11-11-18 at 11:26 PM.
#31
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 2015
Location: Metro Detroit/AA
Posts: 8,207
Bikes: 2016 Novara Mazama
Mentioned: 63 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 3640 Post(s)
Liked 81 Times
in
51 Posts
I mean, I used to sell computers at Office Max, I made no attempt to make people think my personal computer came from there.
#33
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2010
Posts: 39,242
Mentioned: 211 Post(s)
Tagged: 1 Thread(s)
Quoted: 18416 Post(s)
Liked 15,556 Times
in
7,331 Posts
Toured through there in September of 2017 during an Erie to Philly ride. Camped in East Side, came down the Lehigh Gorge Trail from White Haven (for the 8 millionth time) and then rejoined the D&L in Bowmanstown. Wish it had been open back then so I could have avoided the PA 903 and Cherry Hill climbs. The trail gap between "NoCat" and Allentown was also a PITA. But from there to Easton it was smooth sailing despite some poor signage.
#34
vespertine member
Join Date: Jul 2013
Location: Land of Angora, Turkey
Posts: 2,476
Bikes: Yes
Mentioned: 22 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 687 Post(s)
Liked 220 Times
in
163 Posts
They ride the trails of course, and pick up ideas for how to improve the local MTB trails.
#35
I think I know nothing.
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: NE PA
Posts: 709
Mentioned: 6 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 233 Post(s)
Liked 290 Times
in
204 Posts
Wut It's still not open?
Toured through there in September of 2017 during an Erie to Philly ride. Camped in East Side, came down the Lehigh Gorge Trail from White Haven (for the 8 millionth time) and then rejoined the D&L in Bowmanstown. Wish it had been open back then so I could have avoided the PA 903 and Cherry Hill climbs. The trail gap between "NoCat" and Allentown was also a PITA. But from there to Easton it was smooth sailing despite some poor signage.
Toured through there in September of 2017 during an Erie to Philly ride. Camped in East Side, came down the Lehigh Gorge Trail from White Haven (for the 8 millionth time) and then rejoined the D&L in Bowmanstown. Wish it had been open back then so I could have avoided the PA 903 and Cherry Hill climbs. The trail gap between "NoCat" and Allentown was also a PITA. But from there to Easton it was smooth sailing despite some poor signage.
Further to this, when the local media reports on this fiasco they claim that the issue is the trail on the canal side of the bridge. They discovered a couple of weeks before the supposed opening that they were just shy of $600,000.00 of funding to complete the trail to the bridge. The state (DCNR) supplemented the grant in lightning speed so by the first of August the additional money was there but the Boro of Jim Thorpe (land owner) didn't award the contract to finish the work until Sept 12th and there has been zilch in the media about the bridge since, It is obvious that 1. the contractor cannot start until spring as the weather isn't cooperating and winter is coming on strong, and 2. The amount of work that has to be done to make it ADA compliant and to build a sea wall to protect the sewer plant is going to take in my opinion 6 months to accomplish.
In the meantime, while it is true that the conditions on the canal side of the bridge are rough (but passable I have biked to the barricades numerous times) the reason I think everyone is dragging their feet has to do with the west side of the bridge, where the D&L trail cuts through the County parking lot. Same as with the canal side, the money to make needed improvements is there in the bank. However, the way the trail cuts through the parking lot right now is dangerous to say the least and I doubt the county's insurance carrier is thrilled. To build the trail in the optimum configuration will cost the county between 35 and 75 parking spots. Parking already sucks in JT so this is not good news, however the county is getting ready to tear down a building right across the street from the bridge and build a 110 space parking garage for county employees and I believe court/jury members. This will not be done most likely for another 2 years.
The D&L is saying that the bridge will open in spring 2019. My opinion is it will be very late in the year 2019 or maybe mid 2020. Everyone is looking at the east (canal) side but the problem is I think on the west (county parking lot) side, This project dominated the local newspaper's front page for months and since the dedication hardly a word about it. Very strange. I'm reasonably connected to numerous people that are knee deep into the bridge project and literally no one want to even comment or make a guarded prediction on when it will open, except the D&L who speaks in vague terms and with one hand stretched out looking for a donation.
OK enough on that.
When you went down by on the D&L to Northampton Boro and had to detour that is supposed to be done in 2020 but what no one is saying is that once that bridge (Northampton/Coplay) is done, the rt. 329 bridge just up stream is going to be replaced. This is the bridge that now takes trail users from the west (river right) bank to the east (river left) side, so a detour will be a lot more complicated, The Allentown Rt. 22/Fullerton Ave mess solution is still a few years off. On the Delaware Canal section, the Scutter Falls bridge north of Trenton is gumming up the works and The gaps in Bristol are far from being solved. Then the 10 miles from Wilkes-Barre to Mountain Top the land isn't even purchased yet. They have been working on the Middleburg Road rail road crossing (on the black diamond section) for a year or more, it was supposed to be opened this year but there has been zero work completed since spring. If the D&L Trial is the best managed trail in the country, as the RTC is fond of saying, then the rest of the trail networks in this country are really screwed.
Anyway, I think you were referring to Cherry Hill Rd near Lehighton or Parryville? This is very close to where I live, Bicycle Rt. L runs through Franklin Twp where I live. Riding the rail trails 40 miles in an afternoon is easier than 10 miles in my neighborhood!
#36
Senior Member
An interesting article in favour of spending money on bike paths
https://road.cc/content/news/134759-...-cost-says-dft
https://road.cc/content/news/134759-...-cost-says-dft
#37
Senior Member
Join Date: Jan 2010
Posts: 39,242
Mentioned: 211 Post(s)
Tagged: 1 Thread(s)
Quoted: 18416 Post(s)
Liked 15,556 Times
in
7,331 Posts
Yeah. From the top of 903 I took Maury, Long Run, Fairyland, Harrity, U.S. 209, Cherry Hill and Fireline to get to Bowmanstown. Cherry Hill starts off tame, but then gets very nasty, especially on a fully-loaded bike. I lost momentum on the double digit grade section and ended up walking a bit. Pretty though.
#38
Senior Member
Lots of trails are hand built with volunteer labor. Ma Nemba guy here. Often times in our terrain, power equipment is not needed or desired, plus its too rocky. Sure some bridging and decking are needed for streams and wet areas. 20 workers with a clear flag line can get a lot done in a day. Mcleods, pickaxes, rogue hoes work well. It you want 8' wide flow trails of smooth dirt in the woods? That's another story.
#39
Senior Member
I agree with the OP's question, the math doesn't check out here.
Based on what I've heard, the Walton brothers have spent about $70MM to build ~1,000 miles of trail. Setting aside the fact that 1,000 miles of professionally built singletrack seems like an unfathomable amount of awesomeness to me, that's $70K / mile. That's ridiculously expensive trail building. My local trail building / advocacy group is all volunteer (501c3) and spends less than $20k/year to build ~10 miles of new trail a year and maintain ~100 miles of trails. My local trails see very heavy use (just outside a major city) and have armored stream crossings and berms, waterbars, drainage, carefully maintained trees and undergrowth etc, they're nice, durable trails.
They must be spending money on bike right of ways on roads, advocacy, bike racks etc. That stuff can get expensive quickly. Spending this amount of money on singletrack alone just doesn't seem possible.
Based on what I've heard, the Walton brothers have spent about $70MM to build ~1,000 miles of trail. Setting aside the fact that 1,000 miles of professionally built singletrack seems like an unfathomable amount of awesomeness to me, that's $70K / mile. That's ridiculously expensive trail building. My local trail building / advocacy group is all volunteer (501c3) and spends less than $20k/year to build ~10 miles of new trail a year and maintain ~100 miles of trails. My local trails see very heavy use (just outside a major city) and have armored stream crossings and berms, waterbars, drainage, carefully maintained trees and undergrowth etc, they're nice, durable trails.
They must be spending money on bike right of ways on roads, advocacy, bike racks etc. That stuff can get expensive quickly. Spending this amount of money on singletrack alone just doesn't seem possible.
#40
I think I know nothing.
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: NE PA
Posts: 709
Mentioned: 6 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 233 Post(s)
Liked 290 Times
in
204 Posts
Yeah. From the top of 903 I took Maury, Long Run, Fairyland, Harrity, U.S. 209, Cherry Hill and Fireline to get to Bowmanstown. Cherry Hill starts off tame, but then gets very nasty, especially on a fully-loaded bike. I lost momentum on the double digit grade section and ended up walking a bit. Pretty though.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
bbeasley
Clydesdales/Athenas (200+ lb / 91+ kg)
22
03-26-14 11:41 AM