BMX vs Road bike
#26
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2019
Posts: 316
Mentioned: 0 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 174 Post(s)
Liked 177 Times
in
99 Posts
Update...
My friend objected to clip-less pedals, and I obliged. So I will be racing with flats.
Just waiting on him to set the date. I'm ready anytime, anywhere! 😎
My friend objected to clip-less pedals, and I obliged. So I will be racing with flats.
Just waiting on him to set the date. I'm ready anytime, anywhere! 😎
#27
Senior Member
There are a few youtube videos of this kind of drag race, but the one I watched didn't make clear the distance -- it looked like maybe a quarter mile drag strip. It was a three way race, with a roadie, an off duty sandwich delivery guy on a crappy mountain bike, and a BMXer. The BMX rider got a clear lead, but faded. The guy on the crap mountain bike was never in the race. The roadie started terribly, looked pretty weak, but won easily in the end.
But that was I think a quarter mile course.
I think the 45 mph BMX launch is wildly exaggerated; I'm not super familiar with the sport, but from what I've read if they can hit somewhere north of 30 on a downhill sprint to the first jump, they're doing great. I don't doubt that the elite are launching it with maybe 1,800 watts for the first few seconds, but there's just no good way to have one gear that accelerates well but doesn't spin out at some point.
And the question here is not can an elite BMX rider beat a normal recreational roadie, it's whether two dudes who both ride a little get an advantage in a drag race with their respective bikes.
The 200 pounds gives me doubts, but I'll put my money on you for the win. Use your gears!
But that was I think a quarter mile course.
I think the 45 mph BMX launch is wildly exaggerated; I'm not super familiar with the sport, but from what I've read if they can hit somewhere north of 30 on a downhill sprint to the first jump, they're doing great. I don't doubt that the elite are launching it with maybe 1,800 watts for the first few seconds, but there's just no good way to have one gear that accelerates well but doesn't spin out at some point.
And the question here is not can an elite BMX rider beat a normal recreational roadie, it's whether two dudes who both ride a little get an advantage in a drag race with their respective bikes.
The 200 pounds gives me doubts, but I'll put my money on you for the win. Use your gears!
Likes For ljsense:
#28
Banned.
Supercross BMX track here has a 35 foot gap the riders have to clear on first jump. Fastest riders clocked as high as 45 mph
#29
Senior Member
If they are pedaling to 45mph, then some of the info above has to be incorrect... That would be something like a 275rpm cadence, which seems pretty high. Do you know what gearing they are using to reach 45mph? Honestly, that speed requires a decent cadence even on a 53/11 geared road bike.
#30
Senior Member
If they are pedaling to 45mph, then some of the info above has to be incorrect... That would be something like a 275rpm cadence, which seems pretty high. Do you know what gearing they are using to reach 45mph? Honestly, that speed requires a decent cadence even on a 53/11 geared road bike.
#32
Senior Member
Sure, but even in a straight freefall with no drag, it would take a drop of almost 68 feet to get to 45mph. That sure doesn't look like a seven story building that they are starting off, plus they have all sorts of drag to overcome...
Likes For Wilfred Laurier:
#34
Banned.
I Do think 35 is the average but occasionally they get a little faster. 45 would be the max
almost as quick as a sports car out of the gate
almost as quick as a sports car out of the gate
#35
Senior Member
Supercross BMX track here has a 35 foot gap the riders have to clear on first jump. Fastest riders clocked as high as 45 mph
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=WxN6dTlFcLM
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=WxN6dTlFcLM
It looks like they hit that jump about 2 seconds, or maybe less, after leaving the gate. The camera angle makes it impossible for me to tell if they spin out down that hill, or if they're still pedaling. I'd guess they're still hammering on it. It also doesn't show their speed. Curious to see more.
#36
Senior Member
Reminds me of one of my friends' neighbors in my young days. He told my friend he could beat a motorcycle in a sprint, which he designated and was probably 100-50 feet. Sure enough, he was halfway to the finish line by the time my friend had the clutch engaged. The motorcycle never had a chance and multiple attempts didn't change the results.
This race may be the same deal if it's short enough. For the bmx bike to win, it needs to get to top end first and then immediately cross the finish line. I suspect 1/8 mile will be too long for the bmx bike to retain its initial lead, but who knows???
This race may be the same deal if it's short enough. For the bmx bike to win, it needs to get to top end first and then immediately cross the finish line. I suspect 1/8 mile will be too long for the bmx bike to retain its initial lead, but who knows???
#38
Banned.
#39
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Chicago, IL, USA
Posts: 2,873
Mentioned: 2 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1456 Post(s)
Liked 1,477 Times
in
867 Posts
I love this thread.
I'm pretty sure the only way a BMX rider is 45mph is with a pro level rider clipped in, track standing on the barriers, and sprinting down a start ramp with a huge gravity assist. There's no way they are hitting those speeds on a flat road from a standing start with a foot on the ground. They run gearing in the neighborhood of 46/17 that will spin out around 20-25mph (and street/ramp bikes run even lower gearing).
If we're comparing pro-level riders, take a look at last weekend's UCI CX sprint start for an idea of what a standing start sprint looks like on a road bike.
The start of this race is at 11:50 in the video, and it takes them around 10 seconds to get to the edge of pavement, which is 350 feet from the start line. The riders are clipping in and shifting through the gears while sprinting up to speed.
I have a hard time watching this video and believing that a BMX racer would be ahead by much, if at all, at the edge of the pavement which would be a little more than halfway through a 1/8 mile race. The CX racers are north of 20mph at this point and would continue accelerating on a straight/flat road, where a BMX racer would already be spinning out after 10 seconds of sprinting (or sooner).
My prediction is that the BMX bike will be ahead for around 300 feet, where it will be at/near top-speed. At this point the road bike will quickly catch up and pass for the win in the final 360 feet. I don't think it will even be close.
Also, I hope the thread starter and his buddy swap bikes and try it both ways, so that fitness isn't a factor.
I look forward to seeing the results.
I'm pretty sure the only way a BMX rider is 45mph is with a pro level rider clipped in, track standing on the barriers, and sprinting down a start ramp with a huge gravity assist. There's no way they are hitting those speeds on a flat road from a standing start with a foot on the ground. They run gearing in the neighborhood of 46/17 that will spin out around 20-25mph (and street/ramp bikes run even lower gearing).
If we're comparing pro-level riders, take a look at last weekend's UCI CX sprint start for an idea of what a standing start sprint looks like on a road bike.
I have a hard time watching this video and believing that a BMX racer would be ahead by much, if at all, at the edge of the pavement which would be a little more than halfway through a 1/8 mile race. The CX racers are north of 20mph at this point and would continue accelerating on a straight/flat road, where a BMX racer would already be spinning out after 10 seconds of sprinting (or sooner).
My prediction is that the BMX bike will be ahead for around 300 feet, where it will be at/near top-speed. At this point the road bike will quickly catch up and pass for the win in the final 360 feet. I don't think it will even be close.
Also, I hope the thread starter and his buddy swap bikes and try it both ways, so that fitness isn't a factor.
I look forward to seeing the results.
Likes For msu2001la:
#41
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2013
Location: location location
Posts: 3,035
Bikes: MBK Super Mirage 1991, CAAD10, Yuba Mundo Lux, and a Cannondale Criterium Single Speed
Mentioned: 1 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 344 Post(s)
Liked 297 Times
in
207 Posts
I have to say, I think a bmx is going to spin out gear-wise well before 1/8 mile, so all you should really need to do is find out what gear inches his bike is set up for, and then shift yours into something 2 cogs smaller (that is, if his is equivalent to your 34x17, you just go in the 15 or 14) and you’ll pull away from him in the final 50.
Likes For rebel1916:
#45
Senior Member
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Ohio
Posts: 2,857
Bikes: Road bike, Hybrid, Gravel, Drop bar SS, hard tail MTB
Mentioned: 7 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 1218 Post(s)
Liked 298 Times
in
214 Posts
Hi guys,
So, I'm not exactly sure how the topic was broached, but myself, and a buddy of mine ended up getting into a friendly argument yesterday over which one would win in a short sprint (eighth or quarter mile). He's adamant that he would be able to beat me on his BMX bike, however, I don't agree with that assertion.
I believe that he would pull off the line quicker due to having smaller wheels (not sure what sprocket or cassette he's running), but that it wouldn't be long before I pulled on him.
I think key would be making sure I start off in the correct gear. The only way I foresee myself losing would be user error.
BTW, we have placed a small wager of $40 on the race.
So, what does everyone else think?
So, I'm not exactly sure how the topic was broached, but myself, and a buddy of mine ended up getting into a friendly argument yesterday over which one would win in a short sprint (eighth or quarter mile). He's adamant that he would be able to beat me on his BMX bike, however, I don't agree with that assertion.
I believe that he would pull off the line quicker due to having smaller wheels (not sure what sprocket or cassette he's running), but that it wouldn't be long before I pulled on him.
I think key would be making sure I start off in the correct gear. The only way I foresee myself losing would be user error.
BTW, we have placed a small wager of $40 on the race.
So, what does everyone else think?
Like instead of who is faster blah blah.
Make it a bet on Distance he can get before you pass him, measured in Yards or meters.
otherwise as in make it hurt for him... lol
#46
Me duelen las nalgas
Join Date: Aug 2015
Location: Texas
Posts: 13,513
Bikes: Centurion Ironman, Trek 5900, Univega Via Carisma, Globe Carmel
Mentioned: 199 Post(s)
Tagged: 0 Thread(s)
Quoted: 4559 Post(s)
Liked 2,802 Times
in
1,800 Posts
The BMX guy won't be able to resist slaloming through traffic, curb jumping and riding on the sidewalk. You'll win.